Toutes les histoires

La détransitionnée qui argumentait contre son propre passé

Féminin · Détransitionné·e91
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui, en 2019-2020, a posté dans des communautés détrans des conseils critiques exhortant les jeunes à chercher l'acceptation de soi plutôt que les hormones ou la chirurgie. Je soutenais que l'identification trans découle souvent de problèmes d'estime de soi et de stéréotypes sur le sexe, et que vouloir être un mec n'est pas une dysphorie suffisante pour justifier une transition. Je refusais l'étiquette de thérapie de conversion pour des efforts visant à résoudre ce que j'appelais une maladie mentale, et j'approuvais l'idée que les enfants finissent généralement par dépasser leur confusion de genre. Je n'ai pas détaillé dans ces commentaires ma propre chronologie de transition, mon historique médical ni mes regrets précis. Je reste critique envers la transition et envers l'idée que le sexe est un spectre.

Histoire complète

I am a detransitioned woman who, in the fall of 2019, was active in online detrans spaces offering blunt advice to others questioning or considering transition. My own transition and detransition timeline is not something I laid out in these comments, so I will only speak to what I actually said. In August 2019 I responded to a young woman who was thinking about becoming a guy. I told her plainly that "there is no real difference between men and women," that whatever kind of boy she imagined being was "based on some stereotype in your head and not the actual reality of maleness." I acknowledged that she was female and told her to "be female and be yourself," to wear what she wanted, and not to "cling to a meaningless stereotype and beat yourself up over your biology." I framed her situation as a self-acceptance and self-esteem problem that needed addressing "way before testosterone/surgery/binding," and I added that she did not sound like someone dealing with "the crippling dysphoria necessary to justify transition - just wanting to be a guy is not enough to transition for!!" A few days later I generalized that view, saying that "a lot of trans struggles seem to be rooted in deep self esteem issues - wherein trying to do the impossible (change sex) is seen as easier then confronting the true menace." When someone pushed back sharply, I defended the tone of my advice, saying nothing in the original post indicated a medical emergency and that the person's attitude sounded casual; I added that if she were "miserable every single day over your body" then she would need medical assistance. In September 2019 I weighed in on the conversion-therapy debate, writing: "It's not conversion therapy it's helping someone resolve a mental illness - stop the BS rhetoric." In October 2019 I shared a video featuring Sydney pediatrician John Whitehall, quoting his line that many children are confused about gender identity as "a normal phase that they would go through" and that "they're going to grow out of it - don't mess them up," adding that he was "spot on with what we've all been saying on this sub." Later that year I commented on someone's post with "Naturally Beautiful <3 proud to see the change," and in December 2019 I expressed confusion over media headlines about detransition, writing that "these are males that stopping transition going back to men with balls? These headlines confuse the dick off me," and clarifying that "usually trans men refers to females." In March 2020 I endorsed a statement that shut down "the 'sex is a spectacular spectrum' bs used to manipulate and indoctrinate." Overall my public stance has been critical of transition, particularly for young people, and skeptical of both the medical pathway and the ideological framing around sex and gender. I have not, in these comments, described my own medical interventions, surgeries, mental-health diagnoses, family situation, sexuality, or the specific regrets I carry, so I cannot detail those here. What is clear is that I now identify as female and detransitioned, and I spend time in detrans communities advising others to pursue self-acceptance rather than medical transition.