Toutes les histoires

Vécue en garçon de 11 à 19 ans, puis rejet de la dysphorie elle-même

Féminin · Désisté·eTransition sociale 11 → Désistance 19607
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a vécu en tant que garçon de 11 à 19 ans et qui rejette maintenant l'idée que la dysphorie de genre soit légitime. Je crois que ma transition venait de la misogynie intériorisée, d'une faible estime de moi, d'une masculinité atypique et d'une vision romantisée du fait d'être une femme, plutôt que d'un véritable décalage d'identité. Je suis maintenant très critique de la médecine de la transition et de l'activisme trans, et je soutiens qu'être trans est un mode de vie choisi plutôt qu'un trait immuable ; je défends activement la colère des détransitionnés sur les forums. Je n'ai décrit dans ce matériau ni interventions médicales précises ni inquiétudes de fertilité.

Histoire complète

I was born female, and I first started identifying as trans around age 11, living as male from then until I was 19 — eight years of presenting as a man before I detransitioned. Looking back, I describe what drove me as "a wistfulness for femininity borne from being atypically masculine and from romanticising/idealising aspects of femaleness, coupled with low self-esteem and a lack of understanding for the realities of transitioning." I also had a deep-seated dislike of women and what I now recognise as internalised misogyny: I told another poster "i literally have no concept of being female" and that "i greatly dislike women and no matter how much i did to try to make myself feel comfortable as female nothing worked at all." I did not care about gender stereotypes or clothing — I said plainly, "I just want to be biologically male." I came to see my own experience as part of a wider pattern. I pointed others toward the Tavistock findings and Hannah Barnes' work, citing statistics I'd read: 97 percent of referrals had comorbid conditions such as depression, anxiety, PTSD and body dysmorphia, 48 percent of female referrals had autism, 35 percent of all referrals had autism, 90 percent of females and 80 percent of males were same-sex attracted, and outcomes of gender-affirming care were negative for the vast majority. I argued that what clinicians read as "transgenderism" was in many cases internalised homophobia or an extreme averse reaction to trauma and memories of sexual abuse. I have OCD, which I used as a lens for questioning feelings: "I have OCD - I have lots of feelings about things that I know aren't based on reality and can't be trusted. Why trust a feeling that tells you that you'll only be happy if you're male when that isn't true for the rest of the planet?" On detransition forums I found myself in a mentoring role, offering tough love to others still identifying as trans. I challenged one person to examine whether they wanted friendship or "the validation that comes from 'romantic' attention," and told them they needed to "confront your internalised misogyny" and stop trying to "BE female or male and just DO things you enjoy instead." I suggested therapy for body dysmorphia and told another poster they needed to "grieve being female and accept being female." My broader advice was to shift from "being" to "doing": "Forget about who you are. What do you want to do?" I observed that "most cis people don't care about their gender, sex or identity at all" and that the health of cis people comes from job, family and recreation rather than identity. I hold strongly critical views about transition and about trans activism. I was permanently banned from a Doctor Who discussion subreddit simply for accurately stating why J.K. Rowling was described as transphobic — her defence of biological sex — and I noted that "it's like entire online communities are being policed by trans-activists to prevent any kind of alternative view getting through." I believe "the reddit admin are captured as well." I argue that "being trans is not an immutable characteristic, it is a lifestyle choice, and involves willing subscription to a social and political philosophy," because "you can desist" — "You can't choose to stop being black or gay or male. You can choose to stop being trans." I distinguish gender dysphoria from body dysmorphia, saying the latter was "the condition behind anorexia, bulimia, and transsexualism," and I've written that "The idea that gender dysphoria exists at all is just trans gaslighting." I'm protective of detransitioners' right to anger. I've argued that detrans people have been "marginalised by trans activists and have in many cases been groomed and manipulated by trans people into harming themselves on false pretences," and compared calling detrans people transphobic to calling ex-cult members "cultphobic." I said this subreddit "should be a safe space to work through that hatred" and that "the hostility of the victims shouldn't be silenced." I've accused posters I disagree with of LARPing as detrans people and of trying to disrupt the community. I've also engaged with autism as a factor, commenting that "a big part of the autistic community is trans." I don't describe specific medical interventions, surgeries, hormone use, or fertility concerns in this material, and I don't describe my current relationship status, mental health trajectory after detransition, or whether I experience regret about particular bodily changes.