Toutes les histoires

Cinq ans d'allers-retours dans l'identité trans

Féminin · Désisté·e183
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une desisteuse : une fille de 18 ans qui a fait une transition sociale mais jamais de transition médicale, et qui ne s'identifie plus comme trans. Pendant environ cinq ans, j'ai fait des allers-retours dans l'identité trans, m'en servant comme d'une distraction face au stress familial et sociétal, comme d'une explication à mon sentiment d'être différente et comme d'une échappatoire à la dysmorphie corporelle et aux standards de beauté, avec en plus une contagion sociale venue d'influenceurs trans. Je ressens toujours une dysphorie/dysmorphie fluctuante à propos de ma poitrine, de mes formes, de mes cheveux et du fait de ressembler à une jeune adolescente à cause d'une puberté lente, et je reste confuse sur ma sexualité depuis mes 12 ans ; je soupçonne que je suis plus attirée par les femmes que par les hommes. Je suis politiquement centriste, critique de la transition médicale des jeunes et de ce que je perçois comme la promotion de la transition en ligne et à l'école, et je ne regarde plus de contenu trans par peur d'être de nouveau influencée vers le questionnement. Je ne rapporte ni idées suicidaires ni automutilation ; ma santé mentale va mieux depuis que j'ai quitté le lycée, même s'il reste des moments d'insécurité.

Histoire complète

I am an 18-year-old female who has been confused about my gender identity for over four to five years and about my sexuality since I was 12. I socially transitioned but never medically transitioned, so I describe myself as a desister rather than a detransitioned person. My gender feelings come and go: some days I feel certain about my identity, other days I have no idea, and I sometimes fall into the mindset of believing I'm trans for months before realizing I'm not and feeling comfortable with my birth gender again for a few months, until the 'trans' feeling returns. I never actually wanted to be male. I wrote, 'I don't want to be a man or a boy at all, in fact I think I look TOO much like a little boy sometimes lol, I just wanna be a girl.' Instead, I saw transition as a way to explain why I was already different, and as an easier path than putting in the effort to become a pretty girl. Several factors pulled me toward identifying as trans: I like girls and thought that meant I had to be 'the guy' in a relationship; I saw trans YouTubers and influencers who said they were much happier and wanted that for myself; my friends called me boring for being a 'cis girl'; and I hated stereotypes about women, so as a preteen I concluded I must want to be a guy. I also used trans identity as a distraction from unresolved problems in my family or stressful things in society — whenever I faced something I couldn't fix, my mind would go to 'well I want to be a boy, so f*ck whatever else is going on.' Being a boy seemed like a way to be stronger, and it gave me an excuse to be down on myself; if I was trans, I wouldn't have to explain why I wasn't happy with myself and my life. It was a simpler, temporary explanation for my body dysmorphia and struggles with beauty standards. I also think social contagion played a role — seeing a trans YouTuber or an IRL friend who seemed happy with transition made me think I'd be happy too or would fit in with a community. I no longer watch any trans content because I fear it would influence me to start questioning again. My body image issues are significant. I hate having visible breasts and would prefer to appear flat, don't like longer hair, don't like being curvy or shapely, don't like painting my nails or wearing tight clothing (though I clarified this is about how tight clothes make my body look, not texture, so it's a body image issue). I don't look good in much makeup, only natural makeup, though I'm fine wearing a little because I think it makes me look better. I'm impatient growing out a bob I've had since I was 13, and my hair is dark, frizzy, and sometimes flat, so I don't feel stylish or girly even though I wish I did. I feel stuck between tomboyish and feminine and often look like a little kid. I'm still going through puberty due to slow development, so I look and feel physically 13-15 even though I'm in college, which is frustrating. I grew up not caring about beauty standards — I liked running outside barefoot and digging for worms — was shy in school because the cool girls were into boyfriends, makeup, and fashion, which I knew I didn't like at 8-10 years old. I made friends by middle school, mostly boys and tomboyish girls. In high school I dressed 'like a teacher,' had glasses and good grades, and was christened 'the nerd,' which made me hate myself and everyone there. I couldn't fit in with the leggings-and-spray-tan crowd, was too terrified to drive, and couldn't even eat in the cafeteria because the smells and sounds overwhelmed me, so I stayed in teachers' classrooms. I've always been aloof and never showed emotions as a kid; now as a young adult I feel I'm just getting to know myself emotionally. On sexuality, I've questioned it since I was 12 and still don't know it. I don't really get crushes. I learned about sex at ten and hated the idea of it, and I still do, which feels weird since many people my age are sexually active. I've never thought about dressing to attract a man. I haven't had a crush on a guy since I was about 12; after that I would 'choose to have a crush on a guy' out of boredom and would be relieved when he left or had a girlfriend. I went on a couple of dates with guys in high school and didn't like them. I had one 'real' relationship: just after turning 16, I asked out a friend I'd known since elementary school because my friends were dating and it seemed cool. Playing 'girlfriend' with a dress, makeup, and long hair felt like acting; when he asked to hold my hand it felt robotic and wrong, and though he was nice, I didn't want to date him, so I called it off a week later. I have a repulsion to being 'the girl' in a relationship — the idea of a guy driving me, holding doors, paying, making the first move feels humiliating — and I'd rather be the one driving, buying gifts, holding doors, leading dances, and wearing a suit. I picture taking that role with a woman; I do kinda wanna date a girl someday because I want a girlfriend, though I acknowledge it's harder to find. I'm definitely not asexual but haven't felt sexual attraction to men yet, so I might not be heterosexual. I don't have many signs of autism but am somewhat socially awkward in group settings and don't like big crowds. I have never medically transitioned, so I have no surgical or hormonal complications or fertility concerns. I don't describe a formal diagnosis of dysphoria or dysmorphia — I question whether my claimed gender dysphoria is 'probably false' and whether it's body dysmorphia instead. I don't report suicidal ideation or self-harm. Mentally, I described feeling depressed at times during high school and having ongoing insecurity, but I say I'm 'a lot better' now that I'm out of high school, while still having moments of insecurity and dysmorphia that make me want to change who I am entirely. I'm politically centrist rather than liberal, not very political, and probably LGBTQ but don't agree with allowing kids to transition or with everything in LGBTQ spaces. I think detransitioning or desisting makes people question the trans and LGBT agenda, and that questioning isn't hate. I believe transition is heavily promoted online, in children's shows, doctors' offices, and classrooms, and that 'transition is basically manipulation' — the message that transition will fix insecurity or suicidality. I think there's proof it's a social contagion and that detransitioning itself proves many people transition when they aren't really trans. I'd rather let a child grow up in the body they were given than put them on puberty blockers. I also argue that 17- or 18-year-olds aren't mature enough for adult-level risks, noting you can start hormones but can't get a tattoo or drink in the US, and I say I was wrong to believe in trans ideology. I'm critical of 'tomboy erasure' — noticing that tomboyish girls and masc/androgynous lesbians often end up identifying as boys or using they/them pronouns — and of the idea that not shaving or wearing makeup makes someone masculine, when it's just casual. I don't want to be 'trans' to be different, but to explain why I'm already different.