Toutes les histoires

Deux ans de confinements et d’hormones, puis un prénom remis comme avant

Masculin · Détransitionné·e2 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis né homme, j’ai transitionné à la fin de la vingtaine après une enfance marquée par un père alcoolique, un manque de modèles masculins, un usage intensif d’internet et un traumatisme non résolu, et j’ai pris des hormones pendant deux à trois ans. Pendant les confinements du Covid, être seul m’a fait tout remettre en question, et j’en suis venu à voir ma transition comme narcissique et enracinée dans un développement arrêté et des problèmes avec mon père plutôt que dans une véritable dysphorie. J’ai arrêté les hormones, remis légalement mon ancien prénom et détransitionné, ce que j’ai trouvé libérateur malgré un embarras initial. Revenir à l’Église catholique après des années d’athéisme a été la meilleure décision de ma vie et m’a plus aidé que la thérapie ou les médicaments. Je m’identifie maintenant comme un homme détransitionné et je suis critique envers la transition des jeunes, la WPATH et les dynamiques de contagion en ligne qui, je crois, ont porté ma propre transition.

Histoire complète

I was born male and grew up with a father who was, as far as I can tell, a checked-out alcoholic. I didn't have a good male role model to do things with, and stereotypical male activities like sports or camping were never part of my life, which made it hard to feel like I fit in with my peers. I had a lot of girl friends when I was young and was interested in some stereotypically girl things. I was also heavily online from a young age — I grew up with unfiltered internet access, forums and chat rooms, and I consider myself terminally online. I believe that online pro-trans circles played a large role in influencing me, and I've noticed how aggressively those spaces remove anything that disagrees with their narrative, a red flag I didn't consider at the time. I transitioned in my late twenties. I went to an LGBT center at a nearby hospital that had been recommended by a local trans support group I attended, because some members had trouble finding endocrinologists willing to prescribe certain hormones. The center was staffed entirely by doctors doing their residency, with no permanent doctor for the three-plus years I went there, just new doctors rotating out every year or so. I don't think those doctors were acting out of money or nefarious purposes, but they were young and ignorant and probably didn't want to make waves before their careers began, so they followed orders pushed down by a board that would quickly label any pushback as transphobic. I was on hormones for roughly two to three years. During that time I had a medical scare: something in my blood tests was high and increased over time, raising concern about my pituitary gland, and I needed an MRI to rule out a tumor. Insurance refused to cover it and I argued with them and the hospital for months over a bill of more than $3,000. The results came back fine, but it showed me the risks of messing with hormones and how much simply isn't known in endocrinology. I also had a friend who came out as trans a few months after I did. I never actively tried to make them trans, but I've felt guilty about being an influence on them. When I started contemplating detransition, that friend was less than a year into discovering they were trans and was scheduled for bottom surgery. I wasn't able to properly express my concerns and they distanced themselves from me and went through with it. I regret not being able to get them to at least wait or reconsider, but I was too emotional at the time. The surgery had originally been scheduled four months later, but the doctor — somewhat well known in the region, who only required a letter from a therapist who had seen the client for six months — had a cancellation and moved it up. My friend was excited the healthcare system had 'finally removed the gatekeeping.' They were caught up in the typical online communities and worked for a small company that hired mostly LGBT people; they were the third or fourth employee out of maybe ten to fifteen to go through SRS. What moved me toward detransition was the Covid lockdowns. Everything shifted to full-time telework, I had few chances to see friends or family, and few reasons to leave the house. Being alone, none of it mattered, and I didn't think about gender at all. I was mostly by myself, wearing comfortable clothes around the house, and I got more comfortable with myself as a human rather than thinking about gender. The walls started to crumble. My mentality changed: I came to feel the whole transition had been extremely narcissistic, and that the gender dysphoria had a lot to do with childhood trauma and not having a good father. Studying philosophy and theology, I realized there was no reason I couldn't just go back to living as a male and stop caring how I presented myself to the world. I no longer wanted a lifetime of medical issues, prescriptions, and surgeries. I stopped hormones about two years before I publicly came out as detransitioned, and I dragged my feet on 'coming out' until I legally changed my name back roughly six months after stopping. The legal process involved getting a court order first, then updating my driver's license, birth certificate, Social Security, banks, credit cards, workplace, and other accounts. It was tedious but nobody gave me a hard time. I only needed the court order for name and gender on my license and birth certificate; I'd never changed my gender at Social Security so I only needed the name change there. I found the process stressful enough that I never went back to the doctors I had seen for HRT — I just stopped taking it — and I haven't had my hormone levels or fertility checked since. I also had my driver's license photo retaken when I changed my name back. Coming out as detransitioned was hard at first. There was a blow to my ego in feeling I had been wrong and having to admit that to others, and an embarrassment that people had 'put up' with my transition only for me to say never mind. But most people who accepted my transition accepted my detransition. I found that going out in public without worrying whether I pass, what others think of me, whether I missed a spot shaving, has been freeing. I don't regret it at all. The feeling after detransition hasn't been that I lost something but rather gained a better sense of who I am — like moving out of a childhood home or leaving a bad relationship. The main reason it took me a while was embarrassment and shame rather than fear of what I'd lose; I knew it wasn't right and wanted out. A major turning point was returning to the Catholic Church after detransitioning, which I've called the best decision I've ever made. I'd been an atheist for more than fifteen years. I found that returning to God and spirituality helped me far more than any therapist, prescription, or treatment had. I'd grown up in a family that had grown more ambivalent about practicing faith over several generations, and I hadn't cared to learn about it then, but as an adult I appreciate it deeply. I've recommended meeting with a parish priest for spiritual direction, and I've read about the spiritual foundations of AA and its roots in Jung. I also find prayer and meditation helpful. I've come to believe my transition was driven by arrested development, lack of proper ego development in childhood, and not fully integrating the self — with causes ranging from trauma to a weak or absent father. I've read Erich Neumann, including 'Fear of the Feminine,' and find it describes me and several trans and detrans people I know. I also see a link in myself between not wanting to mature into a masculine man and what I'd call Peter Pan syndrome — a desire to maintain a youthful appearance and avoid adult responsibilities, including pride in keeping the same clothes size from freshman year of high school into my thirties and hating any facial or body hair on myself. I've recognized narcissistic traits in my former obsession with my own appearance and worrying what others thought of me. I also see a strong online and social-contagion component. Being into computers, CS, and IT is practically a meme in the trans world because it's so common; anecdotally, a large percentage of trans people I've known were heavily online. I've compared the radicalization to what you'd see on 4chan among incels. I've also come to believe there's a correlation between childhood trauma and transitioning, and between people rebelling against religion and finding a new community in the LGBT world. I think the dramatic rise in young female-to-male transitioners in the last decade, when it basically didn't exist before, has a good argument for social contagion behind it, similar to the contagion of other conditions on TikTok. Since detransitioning I've thought a lot about what I now believe about transition for others. I think it's a mistake for most, though not all, people who transition, because I believe there are far better ways to deal with what they're going through. I don't hate anyone who transitions; I feel bad for them because I think they were taken advantage of and pushed through a system not designed for their long-term interests. I'm against children transitioning, and I'm critical of WPATH standards, loosened guidelines, and the way studies exclude detransitioners or are conducted by biased researchers. I'm skeptical of claims about suicide reduction after transition and of research published by people I believe have an agenda. I would still use someone's preferred name and pronouns if asked, and I believe everyone deserves love and kindness, but I've grown critical of trans activism, particularly those who broadcast to children. I've also become politically more conservative in my thinking about these issues. In my daily life now, I care much less about what others think, I've dropped the worry about others' expectations of masculinity, and I've accepted that it's fine to be a nurturing, feminine man with interests or mannerisms that align more with women. I play drums as a hobby. I've deleted most of my social media because it was wasting my time and too addictive, though I still use Reddit casually. I've also dealt with friends stopping talking to me and have tried to learn not to shut everyone out or put up walls. I've thought about wanting children — something I didn't think I wanted when I was younger but now feel strongly about, seeing it as an outward expression of love more fulfilling than the self-centeredness of transition. Overall, I feel I've gained a better sense of who I am and that detransition was the right choice, even though the process was embarrassing and difficult.