Toutes les histoires

Six mois d'œstrogènes, puis une autre forme de féminisation

Masculin · Détransitionné·e154
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné — je n'ai jamais transitionné socialement et je me décris comme « MtFtM (en quelque sorte) » — qui a pris des hormones à faible dose (raloxifène, brièvement de la spiro, puis des œstrogènes pendant environ six mois) au milieu de ma vingtaine et arrêté quand elles m'ont fait me sentir plus mal. Je suis passé d'une grave dysphorie de genre à une simple dysphorie esthétique de bas niveau grâce à la méditation, à une épouse qui me soutient, à la thérapie et au dépassement de la misogynie et de l'homophobie intériorisées. Je porte maintenant du maquillage en mode mec complet, j'envisagerais la chirurgie esthétique mais plus jamais les hormones, et je conseille aux autres d'essayer d'abord la féminisation non médicale et de se méfier des risques du THS.

Histoire complète

I am a 28-year-old male, a biomedical PhD student, and I have lived with mild-to-moderate gender identity disorder (GID) for most of my life. Between ages 10 and 13 I was a typical pre-trans kid: socially awkward, anxious, introverted, into video games and science, and I occasionally wore my mom's dresses without feeling anything intense from it. From 14 to 17 I discovered masturbation with a primarily receptive sexuality but 90% attraction to women, discovered porn where I identified with no one but idolized the women, and found the then-small online trans community, which gave me a simultaneous sense of understanding and confusion. I got a girlfriend and had a loving but very self-loathing, obsessive/withdrawal relationship, and I once ordered hormones online but threw them away. At 18 to 21 I went to college, found myself surrounded by hypersexual men and women and even more confused, and buried myself in my dorm room masturbating all day. I found refuge in studies and friends, but when the relationship began unraveling I went through a period of severe anxiety and depression, all the while buying, briefly taking, and throwing away hormones. I finally talked to people and a gender therapist and decided to appreciate myself for who I was and be more open. Reading "The Power of Now" and getting into meditation strongly diminished the stress aspect of my GID. From 22 to 24 I started my PhD, spent the first year in a healthy relationship with a bisexual/questioning girl based on mutual issues in life, and had a number of flings with men ranging from very negative to positive but still slightly unfulfilling. I decided I was bisexual but should focus on a long-term female partner who appreciated the same things I did sexually, was tomboyish, and liked kind of feminine guys. I dated that woman and became much happier emotionally. From 25 to 28, still deep-diving in trans community information and hearing it everywhere, I realized my body dysphoria persisted but not my gender dysphoria anymore — just a desire to have a cute twink-like face and body for longer. I began taking hormones online: first raloxifene (a SERM), spiro briefly, and then estrogen for half a year. I felt slightly less mental energy, slightly more depressed/anxious, moderately less tense/obsessive, and the residual gender dysphoria dissipated, but the body obsessiveness actually got worse. My face got slightly softer and my butt a bit bigger, but I actually gained muscle and a bit of fat. I got into makeup, did my eyebrows, got a slightly more androgynous fit of clothes and haircut, and realized that got me much closer to the look I wanted than the hormones did, without any question of passing, just a few offhand comments that I looked kind of gay. I went off hormones realizing they weren't helping, went "a bit crazy for a few weeks but recovered," and pledged to continue on my path of self-affirmation without them. I began seeing a psychiatrist, renewed my focus on mindfulness, and became more active about seeking actual medical answers — including for my slightly obsessive-compulsive tendencies — rather than trusting the internet, since being a biomedical PhD made it easy to mistakenly think I was well enough informed. I also got married to that woman. The decision to try low-dose hormones came from a mix of reading online that some people with my type of GID had done it successfully without failing to pass as a man, and stress at work driving depression forward. I never socially transitioned and I never had genital dysphoria; for me it was always a question of whether I wanted hormones, and going on them briefly made me realize it probably wasn't worth it for me. What helped me most: having a compatible sexual/romantic partner who appreciates me and to whom I can admit feminine or gender-incongruent thoughts with pride rather than sheepishly — this alone largely took me from "gender identity issues" to aesthetic/femininity issues only; being loving and consistent in friendships rather than using people to assuage my pain; "modular reasoning" with hypothetical questions like "if I had to live the rest of my life as a man and could only wear loose clothing, would I still want wide hips?" (no, showing that aspect was partly about needing attention) versus "if everyone who loved me loved me and everyone else despised me, would I still want a cute twink face?" (yes); radical honesty to myself and others, since people with GID build a victim complex and the way past it is being unabashed about what you want; absolute self-ownership, including accepting that I had a strong testosterone-driven sexuality, that I liked both sides in sex, that my PhD difficulties were my own failings, and that I genuinely wanted to look feminine; mindfulness and my Buddhist religion; going for a pretty-boy look unabashedly; building a personality around being caring and lovable while molding slight femme voice resonance and mannerisms into it; getting over internalized misogyny, where I had thought of menstrual cycles, pregnancy, and motherhood as not meaningful components of womanhood to fit my narrative; getting over internalized homophobia and misandry, where I had subconsciously bought into the narrative of men as closeted rapists and seen them as just the thrusting penis in porn — appreciating male emotional nature, tenderness, and the male body let me appreciate my own sexual nature, my bisexuality, and recognize that some of my GID was an escape from a gender I thought tainted with evil karma; acroyoga and yoga; climbing; nature; and working hard. What made it worse: porn, which I consider the worst thing for someone with even a bit of AGN tendencies, since even gay porn makes me think about how I want to look cute forever; obsession with beautiful people and beauty, since looking at pictures of pretty androgynous women I want to look like for two hours makes my dysphoria worse; hormones taken just to look or feel a different way, because of the many variables and risks — I felt good on raloxifene and my skin was nice, but it was experimental and I wouldn't recommend it, whereas makeup, good skincare, and eventually surgery or botox at least let you know what you're getting without screwing up your physiology; gender subject matter and hardcore gender politics; violent or hypermasculine material, which increases amygdala activation; masturbation in certain circumstances, which I avoid when it's driven by stress, inability to sleep, reading gender material, or as an answer to a question about self-identity; identifying as non-binary, which I relate to but have seen become a "stress pot" very fast, and which I think often avoids confronting negative internal thoughts about men and women simultaneously; general life stress, lack of sleep, lack of routine; toxic people and anger; binge eating; excessive alcohol, on the rebound of which I almost always get anxiety, dysphoria, and impulse-control difficulties; and whole days or weekends spent alone. The books that helped me most were the Tao Te Ching, for affirming feminine energy as valuable in males; The Power of Now by Eckhart Tolle, for the "inner body" versus "pain body" distinction; and The Courage to Be Disliked by Fumitake Koga and Ichiro Kishimi, for its breakdown of how people use layers of rationalization to construct a victimization narrative that avoids their inner fear of not being appreciated. I also found yoga and acroyoga helpful because they affirm that this energy is not tied to gender and is inside you, unlike pornography, which encapsulates loving soft life energy as something sexualized and outside of you. My turning point was a series of eureka moments: I realized estrogen actually made me feel worse, didn't make me feel more feminine, was making me fat, and had negative long-term health consequences; I realized a haircut and eyebrow threading did more to my face than hormones ever could; and I realized the toxic nature of left-wing identity politics and that I was spending five times as much time thinking about this stuff as about my work. Overall I went from having quite bad gender dysphoria and no real identity to having an identity I am proud of and only low-level aesthetic dysphoria now, and I appreciate men, women, and trans people more than ever. I now describe myself as "MtFtM (sorta)." I happily get surgery to restore my hair or reduce the masculine intensity of my face when I need it or have excess money, but I will avoid taking hormones again because they have far-reaching and unpredictable biological implications potentially much worse than developing breasts. I wear makeup in full guy mode all the time — BB cream, concealer, nude lipstick, maybe brown eyeliner — so people think of me as a pretty guy rather than a crossdresser. My advice to others considering transition is cautious: I say the only time I could honestly recommend HRT for someone who is MtF is if they are living the social role of a woman actively, have been for at least a year, and want to blend in better; if it's to feel more feminine mentally, don't count on it, and don't buy the idea that it feminizes your sex drive, which I consider placebo or a side effect of watching less porn; if it's for looks, consider how much makeup, hair, dress, and health habits contribute to transition timelines, and try a professional makeup job, femme eyebrows, a wig, shaving, feminine perfume, androgynous clothes, and even a corset before committing; and if you think man boobs are the worst long-term consequence, read about HRT's effects on cortisol (mostly from spiro), cancer risk, blood sugar and triglycerides, autoimmunity and thyroid risk, and the fact that high estrogen/low testosterone for even a few months can shrink brain volume to female levels and be harder to recover. I also tell people that if they feel nervous before the first pill that is a red flag, that switching on and off is terrible for you, and that incarnating an inner-body feeling is a poor reason to take hormones. I have told people going off after a week should be pretty easy, that the drop in estrogen without testosterone can cause headaches, migraines, low energy, brain fog, anxiety, and stress susceptibility but that it all goes away when T comes back, and that spiro is likely the cause of many complaints since it binds to essentially every nuclear hormone receptor, has diuretic side effects and elevated cortisol causing visceral fat gain, and doesn't block testosterone super effectively except at doses where side effects are awful. I have also said there is a big difference between a grandma letting their grandkid wear a dress and a doctor pushing hormones on them, and that I ironically support the notion that you shouldn't have to tell someone they need dysphoria to transition, because there is a degree of unnecessary mental self-victimization everyone with dysphoria does at some point to feel valid. I have been supportive of someone accepting themselves as an autogynephile, noting that AGP is not abnormal and that painting nails does not necessarily imply femaleness, while also cautioning someone not to define themselves either by suppressed inner feelings or by how they think they should be.