Toutes les histoires

Une voix devenue grave et la confiance que la transition a emportée

Féminin · Détransitionné·e75
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée qui en est venue à voir ma dysphorie comme un problème de santé mentale traitable plutôt que comme quelque chose à médicaliser. Je crois que l'on peut être convaincu d'entrer dans la dysphorie comme d'en sortir, et j'attribue mon propre rétablissement de la dépression à un travail personnel et à des consultations. Je suis critique de l'affirmation sans esprit critique dans les espaces pro-trans en ligne et des professionnels de santé qui encouragent la dysphorie plutôt que de la traiter. Je regrette que la transition ait détruit ma confiance en moi plutôt que de me rendre plus forte, et je vis avec une voix définitivement grave après l'arrêt de la testostérone. Je parle ouvertement de mon rétablissement et je suis sceptique envers les gens que je crois transitionner pour des raisons fétichistes.

Histoire complète

I never liked living as a woman — being treated as one felt extremely unnatural and grating to me, and that discomfort is where my whole story begins. I came to believe that transition was the answer, but looking back I see it as the opposite of empowering: it only destroyed my self-confidence and left me vulnerable and questioning everything. One of the practical realities I've had to deal with is my voice. It stayed deep even after I stopped testosterone, and I've told others that unless you voice train, your voice will stay deep even off T — I pointed out that trans women deal with the same issue in reverse. I've thought a lot about how dysphoria takes hold and how it can be let go. I fully believe people can be convinced into and out of dysphoria, the same way you can fall into depression and then work with counseling to get out of it, or the way people with eating disorders can learn to stop hating their bodies. What frustrates me is that only in the case of dysphoria do medical professionals encourage what I consider a mental illness instead of treating it. When people tell me recovery is impossible for them, I push back: it always seems impossible until it isn't. Having a defeatist attitude toward your own health puts you at a significant disadvantage when it comes to getting better — that was the first thing I discovered on my path to recovery. Depression is arguably the most studied and most widely treatable mental illness out there; it just takes personal work and sometimes professional help. I used to feel uniquely hopeless too, but I've come to understand that depression is precisely what makes you think you can't be cured — that conclusion isn't rooted in sound thinking. I've been open that I did get out of it myself. I'm also critical of the online culture around transition. I've said that the pro-trans subs have a big problem with mindless, uncritical affirmation, so any community that doesn't religiously adhere to that standard looks to them like a skinhead rally or something. I think they've been conditioned to need the "you pass so well hon" comments 24/7. In a more lighthearted moment I reassured someone worrying about testicles that nobody's balls are attractive, so not to worry about it. I've also been blunt with people I suspect are transitioning for the wrong reasons — telling one person their description sounded pretty much like they'd be transitioning because of a fetish. Overall I'm skeptical of uncritical affirmation and I encourage people toward recovery and personal work rather than toward medicalization.