Toutes les histoires

Le plus dur n’était pas le corps — c’était d’admettre l’erreur

Masculin · Détransitionné·e530
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme qui a détransitionné, début trentaine, marié et père d’un enfant, qui est revenu à son corps naturel après une transition erronée et a passé 2020 à soutenir d’autres personnes dans les espaces détrans. Je n’ai pas détaillé publiquement mon propre parcours médical, mais je décris la prise de conscience de mon erreur comme la partie la plus dure et je parle d’expérience du retour à son corps naturel. Je suis très critique du parcours médical, surtout pour les mineurs, en qualifiant les cliniques de négligentes et en conseillant de déposer plaintes et poursuites, tout en restant bienveillant envers les individus. J’attribue la transition chez les jeunes à l’influence d’internet et des forums, au porno, à des émotions d’adolescent non digérées et à une sexualité qui oriente vers la voie trans. Je n’ai décrit ni idées suicidaires, ni automutilation, ni diagnostics précis.

Histoire complète

I'm a man in my early thirties — I've said elsewhere I'm 5'11, which I describe as "a great man height" — and I'm married with a wife and at least one child, since I refer to myself as "a husband, father." I've been active in detrans and questioning spaces on Reddit through 2020, mostly offering support to other people rather than talking about myself, but a few things about my own situation come through. I went through a period of questioning my own transition and came out the other side. In May 2020 I told someone who was stuck between two options that "if I were you, I'd go back to your natural body and make peace with it," and I added that "you can still do whatever you want, and you'll have to deal with the surgery etc, but it might make at least some things feel more normal." That advice came from my own experience of having gone back to my natural body. On 31 May 2020 I wrote, "yes maybe you made a mistake, but realising is the hardest time," which reads to me like I was remembering how hard the realisation itself was. On 11 June 2020 someone welcomed me with "Welcome back brutha," and on 26 June I wrote "This is fucking awesome to hear. Welcome to the rest of your life" — that was my own sense of having started over. I've also said "I'm not trans but I grew up pre internet," which places my adolescence well before the current era of online gender communities. I don't have a detailed medical timeline in what I've written publicly. I've never described hormones, surgeries, or a specific age of coming out for myself. What I have done is argue strenuously against those interventions for others. I called GenderGP "basically child abusers" and said I'd "love it if you could get some sort of malpractice" against the clinician involved. I described the medical pathway as "100% affirmation, drugs, surgery" and said the clinics were "negligent by all concerned," pointing out that a 20-year-old asking for a hysterectomy on the grounds she'd never want kids would be refused, "yet you can ask for that in the guise of being trans." I advised people to "raise these as formal complaints against those involved." In August 2020 I told someone who had transitioned young to "look at sueing the people who did this to you at such a young age," and I noted that "detrans isn't really on anyone's agenda" and that US health plans cover trans surgery but not detransition. When someone said they'd been an adult, I replied "I know what you mean, you were an adult, but that doesn't mean they did the right thing." On the causes of transition, I've been explicit. I told a 15-year-old boy that "getting weird feelings about things like skirts and knee high socks (and hard ons) is not uncommon esp for a 15 year old boy," that "I vividly remember the intensity of emotion at that age, for me mostly lows but some highs, and it can cloud your judgement," and that "loving girly things might mean you're dysphoric, might mean nothing, or somewhere in between." I warned that "the internet and forums really encourage labels on people, don't be pushed to label yourself," asked whether someone had good male role models besides their dad, and warned that "porn, esp porn writing, can be really addictive and invade your thoughts all day (I remember well). Lay off it as much as you can." I also told someone that "if you're gay or bi it can steer you down the trans route," and I've said that sexuality is a factor worth thinking about. I've argued that "unrealistic expectations" are a commonly cited problem in detransition and that telling a young person they can "become a girl" sets them up for a downer. I've been blunt about what I think transition can and cannot do. I told one person, "You know you can never be a girl, right? Don't let anyone tell you that you can," and to another, "you're a boy, a man, and can never be a woman. The Instagrams and Blaire Whites are just a show, the reality of hormones etc is brutal." I've recommended the Pique Resistance Project videos on YouTube as a detrans resource. At the same time I try to be kind about it: I told a young person "there's no rush to decide anything," and I've pushed back on the idea that you have to "feel" like a man or a woman, saying "like wtf does that mean, people focus on it but it's bollocks" and pointing out that as "a husband, father" he doesn't necessarily feel anything in particular. I've encouraged people to live however they want regardless — "Be a man who does whatever he wants. Straight or gay, james bond or david Bowie, go get it boss" — and I've told detransitioners "Welcome back to being an awesome MAN who lives, loves and does what tf he wants." On my own mental health I've only said indirectly that my teens were hard: "I vividly remember the intensity of emotion at that age, for me mostly lows but some highs." I've not described diagnoses, self-harm, or suicidal thoughts. I've not written about therapy. I'm supportive of people who desist or detransition and quite critical of the medical pathway, especially for minors, but I'm not hostile to individuals who transition — I've told people "you can do, dress, sleep with, and feel anything" and wished them well. I haven't described any formal advocacy or activism beyond posting on Reddit and encouraging others to file complaints. My own regret, to the extent I've expressed it, is implied rather than spelled out: I talk about going back to your natural body and making peace with it, about realising you made a mistake, and about the difficulty of that realisation, but I haven't itemised what I regret or whether it's improving.