Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Histoire complète
I was born female and grew up hitting puberty very early — I was the only one of my friends to get my period for about five years, and I was so ashamed, embarrassed and angry that I literally could not say the word 'period' until I was in my twenties. That early puberty was massively traumatic for me.
When I identified as trans, I was a frequent flyer in the online 'vortex' of trans talking points and anger. I was truscum back then, before the term transmed even existed — I believed only people with real dysphoria were trans and that others were 'trenders'. I also briefly went the they/them route. I transitioned, and I was on testosterone long enough that people on the phone sometimes commented on my voice, though I've been told it still sounds like a woman's. I don't have exact dates for when I started or stopped hormones in this record, but I know I moved away immediately after my detransition and then came back once it was 'all done and dusted'.
What led me to transition was a tangle of things I only untangled later. I was assaulted at around 19, and that was really the beginning of my 'dysphoria' kicking into gear — I used to have grotesque thoughts about what I'd do to my genitalia, anything to make the flashbacks stop. I thought that was bottom dysphoria; it was actually PTSD, and once I dealt with it, it got a lot better. I also had eating disorders and internalised homophobia. Wanting to be a man gave a nice wrapper to all these other huge, ugly problems I couldn't begin to think how to solve. I subconsciously blamed my body for what had happened to me — assault and abuse being so tied up in our bodies as sex objects — and transition let me ignore the parts of my body that had direct memories connected to bad things. I could tell myself that happened to the previous version of me, I'm not her anymore.
I also used transition to cut off the version of me that experienced the abuse, to silo it away. More broadly, I wanted to be male, not just look like one so long as I kept my clothes on. I hated periods, my voice, being perceived as feminine, having curves. In retrospect there were other causes, but nothing in your head pops up with a helpful label telling you what it's caused by.
The turn toward detransition came when I realised transition was compromising everything I actually enjoyed. My body being how it was, I knew transition would never end in me passing and would likely leave me 'in between' — a really hard realisation, but once I accepted it I moved on. I thought hard about what I actually enjoy in life, and for me that's working. What I don't enjoy is never-ending self-reflection and being paranoid about how people saw me. Transition was going to compromise work, relationships, all the constant psychological hoop-jumping — and for what? To force my body to be something it wasn't and wouldn't ever be? All I'd done was try to solve one problem (sex dysphoria) by creating a million other problems, and it never actually solved the sex dysphoria in any meaningful way because medicine and surgery are not magic. Becoming an approximation of a cis man was not what I wanted; I would always have a female physicality in terms of height and body shape, and a choice between testosterone leaving me with enlarged genitalia and health problems, or a penis that doesn't work or look real, just didn't appeal. It became exhausting and depressing running after a goal I could never reach.
Realising that cultural misogyny and homophobia play into how we see ourselves and can lead to dysphoria was critical for me and improved my life immeasurably. I also found Tara Brach, a psychotherapist/Buddhist teacher who wrote Radical Acceptance and has a podcast, really helpful for learning to sit with discomfort and relate to my body in a friendly way — surprising, since I'd never have been someone for meditation.
Detransition itself was embarrassing and stressful for a while, but it didn't last that long. The fear of it was way worse than the actual experience. I went through a phase of being hyper-feminine afterwards — I wanted all the makeup, all the hair, everything — which was stressful because I had to rebuild my whole wardrobe and aesthetic, and the 'trans me' had been so tied up in image. Even though I'd been pretty good at makeup before I transitioned, all the trends had changed (eyebrows are a massive deal now, which they weren't previously). I found YouTube videos and trial and error helpful, and cheap Chinese sites like Romwe and Zaful for rebuilding a wardrobe. I also dealt with significant hair loss from a medical thing about two years before mid-2019, which was upsetting and scary, and I suggested microblading/tattooing to others with hairline concerns.
Several other people who had identified as trans at the same time as me got in touch afterwards to say thank you for speaking out, that they'd been having similar feelings. I also found connecting to a history of butch women who passed as men helpful — I'd recommend Jack Halberstam's Female Masculinity and Alison Bechdel's Fun Home — because thinking of myself always as a detransitioner felt like a big symbol of 'I made a mistake' around my neck. I've noted that basically all my butch exes transitioned, which is sad to watch.
I do ascribe to a lot of gender critical thought, but I'm here because I'm a detransitioner. I find most GC feminists are really weird to detransitioners — it feels just like back when I was trans and everyone made me into a symbol of their ideology. This is the only place I have to talk to detransitioners. I've also said that detransitioners get so much backlash from the trans community already, and that being kicked out of the community is like leaving a religion — some people use the term 'gender apostate'.
On transition for others, I think there may be a tiny handful of people with such severe issues that transition is the only way for them, but fundamentally I think they have other serious mental health issues. Your body is not optional; you don't get to edit it into a different one, and I think it's lying to people to tell them you can or should. Of the people I know who have transitioned, they say they're happy, but all they talk about is their mental health diagnoses and it's an endless race to the next surgery or the next T shot. I'd advise a young person considering blockers to stop them — we've no idea what it does to never go through natural puberty, lupron is controversial with lawsuits over long-term mental health issues and bone and joint deterioration, and sibling/parental influence plus autism-related black-and-white thinking can be a factor. I've also noted the 4000% increase in young women presenting as FTM at the Tavistock in London.
I've been critical of trans activism's treatment of straight women ('They talk about straight girls like it's the most pathetic thing you could be'), of the siloing of trans and lesbian communities, and of GC feminists screenshotting sensitive posts to Twitter. I've given a lot of advice on this forum — to SA survivors, to people worrying about voice or facial hair after T, to someone whose younger sister was angry about their detransition — and I've shared detransitioning YouTubers I follow. I've also noted that obsessive thinking and anxiety are factors in dysphoria for a lot of people, myself included.
Regret: I regret that I didn't solve the original problem and instead created a million new ones — the lost time, the identity built around something that wasn't working, the career opportunities and relationships being trans cut me off from. The grief of realising transition wasn't the solution was huge, but I've said you haven't discovered there is no solution to sex dysphoria, you've only discounted one of many possible solutions. That grief has lessened — I'm a couple of years down the road now and it's such a smaller part of my life. Going back to being 'cis' was a huge weight off my shoulders; I just wanted to stop explaining myself, stop worrying about passing or pronouns, and I did, and it was freeing. I now feel like I can do whatever I want with my life, whereas before I spent all my time figuring out how to navigate anything while still being trans.