Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme qui a détransitionné ; j'ai pris de la testostérone pendant environ 1,5 an à partir de 19 ans et arrêté en janvier 2024. J'ai détransitionné en grande partie par épuisement d'être trans, par peur de la discrimination sociale et par désir d'une vie plus facile, plus normale, même si je reconnais que j'éprouve encore parfois le désir de transitionner. Après une période de deuil intense, de vérification obsessionnelle du subreddit et de quasi-mutisme face aux inconnus, j'ai reconstruit ma vie : ma voix s'est suffisamment éclaircie pour que personne ne la prenne pour celle d'un homme, j'ai un emploi où je parle toute la journée, et des lesbiennes m'ont acceptée et trouvée attirante pour mes traits masculins. Mon principal regret restant est le sentiment de mise à l'écart que cette expérience procure : je ne me reconnais tout à fait ni dans les autres femmes ni dans les personnes trans, mais la plupart des jours je suis sereine et j'assume mes traits androgynes. Je m'exprime avec force contre la transition précipitée et plaide pour la prudence, une thérapie non affirmative, et pour voir la détransition comme un choix valide, voire bienveillant envers soi.
Histoire complète
I was 19 when I started transitioning, and I began testosterone at that age. I was on T for about 1.5 to 1.6 years — a pretty high dose — and I stopped in January 2024. I never had any surgeries. I'm 21 now, and I'm in a PHP (partial hospitalization program) doing therapy.
Before I transitioned, I was pretty femme and liked doing my makeup, but it felt like drag every time I did it. I'd always felt uncomfortable having a female body — something I either ignored or actively tried not to engage with. I voiced serious doubts three months on T, verbatim saying "I think I might just be a cis woman," but the queer people around me literally tried to talk me out of it, citing that I was visibly uncomfortable being referred to as one. I approached the decision to transition very rashly, which I recognize now was a mistake.
Part of why I started detransitioning had to do with the pure exhaustion that came with transitioning. Another reason was that being trans automatically opts you out from certain social circles, and I felt like it would be easier to get by if I didn't have to learn how to socialize with men as a man. I also didn't want to deal with the mental weight of encountering transphobia — knowing a certain percentage of the population thinks you're despicable no matter what you do. I fully acknowledge that I will never be a cis man.
After stopping T, I was at my lowest mentally. For the first couple of months off T, I felt worse than I ever had in my life, both mentally and physically. My chest got bigger, my hourglass shape became more obvious, and I hated it — I felt so disgusted with myself as things feminized. I could objectively recognize that I have attractive facial features, but I felt out of control looking in the mirror. I've considered that some of these feelings might come from ingrained beauty standards, my disordered eating, or the weird inappropriate comments my mom made about my body when I was younger — but that doesn't change the fact that I've always felt uncomfortable having a female body.
Being off T has been helpful for me in accepting that my natal body is female, but I still have the strong desire to transition despite that. I played around with being comfortable with androgyny, but I feel uncomfortable being "in-between." Detransitioning for me is about accepting that life was and will be easier if I return to presenting as a woman, and that my transition was a band-aid solution for problems that could and should have been solved by other means.
My voice was a huge concern. Before T, I had a high voice — around 290 Hz. On T it dropped to around 110–126 Hz. After stopping, it lightened to about 170–180 Hz, and with voice training I could reach 175–190 Hz. I worked with a voice teacher focusing on forward resonance and SOVT exercises. Around three months off T, I posted a voice sample and people said it sounded female. By about a year off, my voice had lightened significantly and no one mistakes it for a man's voice. It's still the main thing that clocks me as formerly trans, and I get they/themed occasionally, though mostly she/her from strangers.
The first months of detransition were brutal. I struggled immensely to function at a basic level, overcome by grief and regret. I felt like an open wound, found it hard to go out, and was on the verge of tears all the time. I was checking the detrans subreddit obsessively — unable to go an hour without scrolling, even though it wasn't making me feel better anymore. I leaned into weed, which made my anxiety worse. I was functionally mute around anyone I didn't know when I came off T. This was my last semester of college, and I felt like I was missing out while my peers were enjoying it.
Things gradually got better. I did voice training, tackled my body hair, and started doing makeup again. I also did a lot of weightlifting to get a more masculine physique — I stopped lifting for about eight months and then got back into it, and I've mostly gotten back to how strong I was on T. My neck thinned noticeably around 5–6 months off T, though my shoulders stayed broad from muscle I'd built. I had random cramping after stopping T that eventually went away. T also messed up my skin, and I've dealt with a mustache shadow that I cover with orange color corrector under concealer.
By April 2024 — about three months off — I reached a point where I was just about as content with myself as I'd been early on T, which was probably the height of my confidence. Getting off HRT actually allowed me to tackle the real issues I'd been trying to cover up by transitioning. I still have a low voice and excess body hair, but I haven't caught nearly as much shit from non-trans people as I feared.
Dating was a big worry. I prefer women and was scared I'd never find someone who's attracted to me. I worried that many lesbians prefer femme4femme and that I wouldn't fit into that. But I was pleasantly surprised — I've been accepted by many lesbians, and many have been attracted to my masculine features. I live in a very gay area on the East Coast. Being accepted and considered attractive for my masculine traits has been really healing.
I had a mentor who told me, "any decision made to survive is a beautiful decision," which helped me when I questioned whether I was detransitioning for the right reasons. The death of a trans person I knew — self-inflicted — was what sent me over the edge into detransitioning.
I've also had trans friends be accepting of my detransition to my face and then heard through the grapevine that my current identity offends them — that I'm privileged and taking the effects of HRT "for granted."
Now, about a year and some change off T, I have a job where I talk to people all day. A customer told me I have a great voice for broadcasting/radio, and my coworkers agreed — it nearly made me tear up because I'd been so insecure about my voice. I look like a woman enough that people write me off as a woman with an unusual voice.
My biggest regret is going through an experience that feels so othering — I don't feel like or completely relate to other women, and I don't completely relate to trans people either. On my worst days I feel sad about not feeling normal, but most days I try to embrace my more androgynous features (deeper voice, muscles, broad shoulders) since I generally enjoy being a bit masc. It didn't ruin my life, but I still have plenty of moments of wishing it hadn't happened.
I've become quite vocal about my views on transition. I wrote a long post defining what I see as "trans ideology" — centrally the idea that sex and gender are separate, that cross-sex hormones are the primary treatment for gender dysphoria, and what I see as an ingroup-outgroup mentality that punishes dissent. I believe HRT should be a last resort, that there are other ways to treat gender dysphoria, that children shouldn't medicalize, and that transition doesn't always resolve suicidality or dysphoria. I've advised people with even remote doubts about detransitioning to get off hormones immediately, since voice and body hair changes are pretty permanent. I've recommended finding a therapist who isn't overly affirming and ruling out mental health issues before transitioning, and I've told people that if they have doubts to this degree, the answer is not to go on testosterone. I also believe that even if someone detransitions because of social pressure, that's a valid choice — avoiding a lifetime of discrimination and medical dependence is worth celebrating.