Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a vécu comme un homme et pris de la testostérone pendant trois ans, et je ne regrette pas d'avoir transitionné : je considère que cela a été une étape importante pour me sentir à l'aise avec mon corps et ma féminité. Après deux ans sans T, ma voix est revenue à une tessiture féminine sans entraînement vocal, mes règles sont revenues en un mois environ, et je n'ai eu aucun problème au travail ni en amour. Je n'ai pas cherché d'autre intervention médicale et je travaille plutôt sur la neutralité corporelle, en acceptant mon corps tel qu'il est plutôt qu'en recourant à une chirurgie risquée. Je plaide pour la nuance dans les communautés de détransition : le regret n'est pas universel et les points de vue concordants des personnes désistées sont valables.
Histoire complète
I was born female and detransitioned after living as a man and taking testosterone. I don't regret my time transitioning or my decision to do so, and I've been frustrated by detrans media that assumes strong regret is the standard experience — I felt 'very out of place and confused having not regretted my time transitioning' and frustrated that people talked down to me as if I hadn't done enough research. I think people's reasons for detransitioning vary widely: some regret it, some don't, some are ambivalent, and all are equally real.
I spent a long time trying to manage my dysphoria without transition and actively wanted to avoid it, but I didn't really make progress until I did transition and got into a better headspace. I consider my transition an important part of my process of becoming more comfortable and accepting of my body, my sex, and my womanhood. I was on testosterone for 3 years. Both my significant other and I transitioned as adults and detransitioned around the same time. It took about a month max for our periods to come back after stopping T.
On my voice: after 3 years on T I had a pretty deep voice. Two years off T, my voice is back in a female range — at worst I sound 'fem-androgynous' or like an older woman. I've done zero voice training either way. I can't get my voice anywhere near as deep as it once was no matter how hard I try, and I can now get it much higher than I could when it was at its deepest — I remember trying to see how high it would go while on T and sound physically wouldn't come out and it hurt, and now I can get my voice quite high with no issues. Most people say I sound like 'a really gay dude' or 'a woman with a deep voice.' I'm also almost 6' tall and broad shouldered. Even with a deep voice on T I didn't really 'sound' like a man — I just had a deep voice, and because I never voice trained or altered my speech patterns it got me clocked; I sounded like a man making fun of a woman. I wasn't frequently assumed to be a trans woman. I believe with a vocal coach I could get my voice pretty close to where it was pre-T. I'd encourage others to try voice training, therapy, self-care, and patience before considering risky voice surgery.
I also got pregnant from my ex while she was on HRT — she'd been on HRT for 10 years when it happened, unintentionally, and we both assumed there was no way she was fertile by that point. I know many detrans women who started transition as adults and had little problem regaining their period and fertility. I think fertility problems after transition are more likely linked to Lupron (puberty blockers) — in an adult, ovaries, fertility, and cycles fully develop for years and are resilient to just T, whereas I'd worry Lupron halted ovarian development before cross-sex hormones.
I've seen people convinced they're trans due to OCD, obsessively worrying about being trans and convincing themselves they must be because they're told 'cis people don't question their gender that much.' I also think dysphoria can worsen after transition following a 'honeymoon' period, where people chase the next surgery the way plastic surgery doesn't fix body dysmorphia because the root cause is mental health, socialization, self-worth, trauma, etc.
On medical gatekeeping, I've argued that informed-consent doctors are often hands-off, that doctors get concerned about dose changes for legitimate medical reasons, and that going off HRT is different from adjusting it. I told my doctor I was going off HRT and she was happy for me when I said I'd found other ways to deal with it that work better in the long run; my doctor was also happy to remain my primary care physician after I went off T.
I've advocated for more enforcement of rule 1 in detrans spaces — I don't think desisted people should be told their opinions are invalid when they match detrans people's opinions, and I'd rather see people avoid words like 'mutilated' unless referring to themselves. I don't think everyone should detransition; I've told a trans woman she doesn't need to detransition and could embrace being a trans woman, accepting that she'll always be male and different from cis women, and that those things are okay.
Currently I identify as a woman. I haven't pursued any further medical intervention for things I'm not thrilled about, because I want to get out of the mindset that being unhappy with something about my body means I need major and risky intervention. What has helped most is moving from 'body positivity' to 'body neutrality' — my body doesn't have to be appealing, look good, or make me happy; it can just be, and that's okay. I think many body insecurities stem from how other people might feel about our bodies and how society tells us to feel, and that's reason to work through it rather than pursue risky surgical modifications that may not make us happy. I have a new career I'm starting that involves talking in person and on the phone, including with rural, Christian clients, and I've had little problem with dating both men and women — I just give them a heads up. I'm overwhelmingly treated like any other woman.