Toutes les histoires

Un paracosme où il était une fille — et une décennie qu'il ne veut pas effacer

Masculin · Détransitionné·e349
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné (ou désistant) qui s'identifie maintenant comme bi et défend une position modérément anti-transition. Garçon à l'apparence féminine, entre 13 et 18 ans environ, dans un foyer socialement conservateur, j'ai développé un paracosme intense où j'étais né fille, qui, combiné à la validation des espaces queer, a formé une identité genderfluid/femme trans. J'ai pris des hormones à un moment donné et j'ai arrêté avant janvier 2025, et je parle d'environ une décennie de vie trans que j'accepte aujourd'hui plutôt que d'effacer. Je crois que seulement environ 1 personne sur 500 est véritablement trans et que la plupart de celles qui transitionnent ont besoin de psychothérapie plutôt que d'hormones, et je me moque du chiffre de 1 % de regret largement cité. J'ai été élevé dans la suppression des émotions et les punitions corporelles, et je travaille sur l'acceptation radicale de moi-même.

Histoire complète

I have never posted on this community, only commented, and my comments show a consistent critical, largely anti-transition position. My own story comes out most clearly in one reply from March 2025: I describe myself as having been 'a rather feminine/soft looking boy with large hips, full lips etc. when I was around 13-18', which 'made me feel very unmanly and unattractive'. Combined with 'the masculinity image of my very socially conservative household', this left me feeling 'like being stuck in the wrong place', so I 'started having an intense paracosm in which I was born a girl', which together with 'the promises and validations and thought patterns and solutions for questions queer spaces presented me' formed my 'genderfluid/trans female identity'. So my route toward a trans identity ran through a feminine boyhood appearance, a conservative masculine ideal at home, an elaborate fantasy life (paracosm), and affirmation from queer online spaces. I have taken hormones at some point: in January 2025 I wrote 'Now that I don't take any medication anymore, I am a relatively average sized guy (1,82, but that's average in Germany), have a feminine babyface, and I have a very high hairline related to genetic balding in combination to a widows peak.' I also envy 'both men with full, long hair, with sharp facial features and high self esteem who are extraverted and fun; and also women with beautiful voices', and I concluded 'no hormone in the world will change that' and that 'I have to work on my self image, radical acceptance is the key.' This tells me I stopped hormones before January 2025, that I am male and about 1.82 m tall, that I have a feminine face and early genetic balding with a widow's peak, and that I am working on self-acceptance rather than further medical change. In the same comment I addressed a female-identifying reader, telling her that 'Taking the transmasculine turn won't make you one of them' and that as a girl she has more room for self-expression, which suggests I now read transmasculine identification in women as a response to patriarchy and low self-esteem rather than an identity to affirm. I also said in January 2025 that 'Growing up I was basically raised to not feel or show emotions, I was forced to only like certain things, I was beaten when I showed weakness and much more', pointing to physical punishment and emotional suppression in my upbringing, in a household I have called 'very socially conservative'. I have described myself as bi: 'I am bi, and let me tell you, you look better as a girl' (January 2025). In March 2025 I said 'I deleted all but two photos' and, in a thread about a decade of transition, 'I wouldn't erase a decade of my life either. In the end, it was you all the time, you were, are, and always will be the same person. I would try to take it with pride :)' — implying roughly a decade of identified/trans life that I now frame as something to accept rather than erase. I have not stated my current identity label explicitly anywhere in the transcript, but everything I write is from a detransitioned, critical standpoint. On transition in general I am 'Moderatly anti-transitioning'. I wrote: 'everyone should be able to do whatever they want to as long as it's a matter regarding themselves only', but I believe many transition 'as some kind of trendy solution for any dissatisfaction with one's life', which 'leads to some bad mechanisms that cause the infamous 40% suicide attempt rate', and that 'Therapy would help this group, not hormones.' I also named 'autosexual reasons' as a driver for another group. My estimate: 'a small group, maybe like 1 in 500 (0,2%) people in general, who genuinly is trans beyond any therapeutic capabilities. Those should transition if they want to. But the other 4 in 500 (0,8%) trans people we have in modern times ... rather need psychotherapy than hormones', while noting 'My numbers are based on my memory, so they might be wrong.' I am sceptical of the widely cited regret figure: 'I think that the "only 1% regrets transitioning" "fact" is wrong, and it's at least 10% if not more', and later 'I still laugh at the 1% lie by them'. I am also sceptical of brain-sex research: 'What would make brains male or female in that study?' I have argued that 'gender dysphoria has been morphed into a term that's so easy to resonate with and identify with it's easy to become stuck with', and that easy online access to trans topics is 'a terrible thing' because it can echo-chamber 'an already tortured soul' into 'even more pain and self hatered, likely together with the romantization of mental illness'. My positive prescription is 'radical acceptance'. I have not described any formal advocacy, activism, therapy, or current relationship status.