Toutes les histoires

Cinq ans en transmasc, puis la sortie de la secte

Féminin · Désisté·e1,2 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

J'ai désisté après m'être identifiée comme transmasc pendant cinq ans et je suis maintenant une femme non conforme au genre qui garde un look masculin. Je crois que l'identité non binaire est sexiste parce qu'elle réduit la féminité à des stéréotypes, même si j'accepte encore les personnes trans binaires qui ont une dysphorie de sexe depuis l'enfance. J'ai l'impression d'être sortie d'une secte et que l'idéologie trans m'a fait du mal, tout en me méfiant de la religion comme croyance de remplacement. J'avais 14 ans, j'étais malade mentalement et victime de violences émotionnelles et de négligence de la part de parents négligents quand j'ai transitionné, et j'ai maintenant l'impression d'avoir récupéré ma vie.

Histoire complète

I identified as transmasc for about five years, and over the past year I've come to believe that "gender identity" — and non-binary in particular — is sexist. It honestly feels like I've woken up from a parallel universe; I can't believe I used to believe all of that, and I can't believe I used to support it. What started shifting things for me was seeing a woman who calls herself non-binary and uses they/them describe her childhood "signs" of being non-binary as not liking dresses and wanting to play the prince rather than the princess. Those are apparently the signs now, and to me that is just sexism. Girls can play male or masculine roles; girls can hate feminine clothing. Just because I like the "male role" doesn't make me male, because the male role is made up and consists of stereotypes — so girls can like the male role too without it making them any less girls. I've also noticed that people who claim to be breaking gender roles are actually reinforcing them, and it angers me when they call themselves feminists. My current position is that I can get behind binary trans people if they have sex dysphoria from birth, but if they bring any of those stereotypes in as "signs" of not being girls, I'll stop taking them seriously from now on. I've desisted, but I've kept my masculine look. Even in real life people still ask for my pronouns and whether I'm trans, which is frustrating — I'm a gender-nonconforming woman, and these "progressive" people automatically assume I must not be a woman. I've also been frustrated by claims from trans subs that the detrans community is just a hate sub full of people who never actually transitioned, or "magas and TERFs making things up," when people here post before-and-after pictures almost every single day. I feel like I've left a cult — these people are lying to each other all the time and are in their own world, and I was too, and now I'm not, and now I see all the hypocrisy. Sometimes I ask myself whether I'm going crazy or going sane, whether I'm crazy or they are. I also used to hate detransitioners — they used to just make me mad and I didn't know why. Now that I've desisted I realise it was because they showed me the truth and destroyed my trans worldview. At the same time, I still struggle with doubt: I desperately need somebody to tell me I'm not crazy and that non-binary actually is sexist, because with all the people in the world who support it and say it's real I keep having doubts, even though all of the world's logic points to non-binary being sexist and made up. On causes, I was emotionally abused and neglected. I was 14 and mentally ill, with neglectful parents who let me have 24 hours a day of screen time without caring. In a recent post I pushed back on the idea that "nobody forced you," arguing that at 14, mentally ill, with neglectful parents, I wasn't in a position to be making these decisions freely — and that for me it feels like I got my life back. I've also become critical of religion as a replacement belief system. I've said that leaving one mass delusion (modern trans ideology) because of another mass delusion (religion) is crazy, that we should all just come back to reality again, and that religion is a great coping mechanism but a lie — I told someone I personally wouldn't want my coping mechanism to be a lie, and that being trans hurt a lot of people, me for example. I've also pushed back when someone implied I'm not chronically online and therefore my opinion doesn't matter. I don't have detail in this record about hormones, surgeries, medical complications, fertility, therapy, or my current relationships and daily life beyond what's above.