Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a fait son coming out à 15 ans, une transition sociale, pris de la testostérone pendant presque quatre ans, subi une mastectomie à 21 ans, et détransitionné à 22 ans après avoir failli aller jusqu'à une hystérectomie et une phalloplastie. J'en suis venue à voir ce que j'appelais dysphorie comme en grande partie de la misogynie et de l'homophobie intériorisées — reprocher à mon corps la façon dont j'étais traitée — plutôt qu'une carte cérébrale innée désaccordée. Je ne crois plus au genre comme système, même si je me considère comme une femme et une lesbienne. Je regrette de m'être assez détestée pour m'injecter des hormones et subir une chirurgie, mais je ne regrette ni ma pilosité faciale ni ma poitrine plate. J'ai pensé au suicide d'innombrables fois mais n'ai jamais fait de tentative sérieuse.
Histoire complète
I came out at 15, socially transitioned, and started testosterone at 17. I had document changes at 18 and a mastectomy at 21, and I detransitioned at 22. Throughout that period I oscillated between identifying as female-to-male and non-binary. I now consider myself a woman, but I no longer identify with the system of gender itself — I feel that my sense of having "failed" at being a woman in the culturally understood sense is what got me into transition in the first place, and I don't want to tie more emotional baggage to a concept that has caused me harm. I have a physical sex and that is as far as I care to take it.
I was raised devout Christian in a highly conservative denomination, though by liberal parents. I left the church a year before coming out as trans and did not return until right before detransitioning, this time to the Episcopalians. My mom's wife is now a priest in the Episcopal Church and it's the best experience of Christianity I've had, but it's still not for me. I think the ubiquity of God the Father in the Christian church probably accounted for a huge portion of my dysphoria when I used such words to describe my mental state; biblical views and expectations of women seem pretty bleak to me. I've found comfort in nature-based and Goddess-based religions but I don't tie myself to any particular group.
Prior to transition but after coming out as trans I was diagnosed with depression and came close to a diagnosis of Asperger's (now ASD) but was just below the cutoff for clinically significant symptoms. I haven't been to therapy since I detransitioned but suspect I may also have ADHD; inattention does cause some issues in my life and I think at some point I want to be evaluated, though it's not a high priority. I work clinically with kids who have ADHD, among other conditions, which helps me cope.
My mental health was the worst it had ever been at the time I detransitioned, due to other factors. It was bad enough that I thought about ending it countless times, but not bad enough that I ever made a serious attempt. I was in the process of getting referrals and planning for phalloplasty, and even when I decided to detransition I kept my hysterectomy date until a couple weeks out from the surgery.
What changed was that my mental health was so bad from other things that I began to feel my dysphoria didn't matter anymore — it was the least of my worries. That disconnect from the urgency I'd felt before let me step back and see the big picture: what I called dysphoria was a whole bunch of other things that boiled down to blaming my body for the way I was treated. That wasn't how I conceptualized it while transitioning; if you'd asked me if it was about society I'd have laughed in your face. I was a feminist from a young age and would never have thought I had internalized those ideas about what it means to be female, but that's exactly what happened.
I questioned the trans movement before detransitioning. I was "truscum" — I believed you needed physical dysphoria to be trans, though I did believe in non-binary identities and identified as non-binary for a time. That subgroup supported some of my questions about the mainstream trans movement, but some subjects were still off limits. I kept searching and found that radical feminists were the ones who didn't shut down those questions. I was initially horrified but kept digging. Eventually I found detransitioners online and was horrified by them too, but kept reading. Questioning the trans movement was one of the forks in the road that led me to detransition.
On the physical side: right before stopping testosterone I had blood work that showed liver enzymes just barely above the normal range. I have chronic back and shoulder pain that I attribute at least partly to five years of binding, as my shoulder blades are pushed farther apart than they should be. About a year after stopping testosterone my blood levels were pretty much normal female adult range. I tapered down before stopping and was surprised it only took a week from my last shot to get my period back. Some effects considered permanent are actually semi-permanent: voice, facial hair, genital changes, and chest size reverted somewhat. My voice has continued to get incrementally higher over time. I experienced a good deal of fat redistribution; my chest is definitely bigger than it was immediately post-op, and I probably have A-cup breasts now, though I don't wear bras. It took about a year to notice breast growth. My surgeon did more breast augmentations/reductions than female-to-male top surgery, so my incisions are curved up toward the armpits rather than straight under them.
I regret the fact that I hated myself so much that I injected drugs to change my appearance and paid a man to cut me open. But I don't regret having facial hair or a flat-ish chest. I like that my appearance challenges the norms a little, even though I don't like how I got there. I leave my face stubbly, and combined with my male name and generally feminine presentation, people sometimes think I'm a transwoman. A tattoo artist once asked me, while tattooing between my mastectomy scars, "why do you still go by (name) if you're a girl now?" I work with children, so the most common question is why I have facial hair if I'm a girl, or whether I'm "half boy." I play it off casually — "why do you have a beard?" "Because it grows out of my face." I try to send the message that it's okay for me to be funny-looking. Many of the kids I work with have learning disabilities and I think it's maybe nice for them to have a teacher who is also a little out of the norm. I am occasionally bothered by the idea that women may feel less safe around me, but overall I don't care much what others think of my appearance anymore.
I graduated before detransitioning, but I was at a job where everyone knew me as a man and no one really asked about it beyond how to refer to me. I lived in a pretty progressive city. I interact with men as little as possible.
I ran the blog guideonragingstars and an associated YouTube channel but stopped because I have no staying power with such projects. I made a video about the changes I experienced after a year off testosterone. I also did a peer survey specifically for female people with a history of transition or disidentification, including a graph of reasons for detransition. I attended a detrans women's retreat that was incredible to be around so many other women like me, and later shared contact info for others interested.
I don't believe gender identity is innate, and I don't believe transition changes someone's sex. I do believe dysphoria is legitimate and debilitating, and that some people benefit from transition in our current society. I think anyone contemplating transition should consider regret a real possibility and not just a TERF or right-wing bogeyman. I agree with most tenets of radical feminism but condemn those who use the label as an excuse to abuse trans people, and I've fought back against detransitioned women's writings being co-opted by unscrupulous radfems and fundamentalist Christians to claim no one should ever transition.