Toutes les histoires

Une histoire de détrans qui a réécrit ses opinions politiques

Féminin · Désisté·e144
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

J'ai désisté après avoir découvert la détransition, qui a été le catalyseur d'un grand changement dans mes opinions politiques. Je suis une femme détransitionnée/désistée, critique de la facilité avec laquelle les soins médicaux transgenres sont fournis, et je crois que toute personne qui envisage la transition devrait pouvoir écouter les histoires de détransitionnés sans se braquer. Je n'ai pas décrit d'interventions médicales précises, de chirurgies ni d'âges dans les éléments fournis. Je plaide pour le soutien entre pairs dans les communautés détrans et de meilleures statistiques sur des résultats comme les idées suicidaires après la transition. Je m'identifie actuellement comme désistée et j'encourage les autres à envisager de se retirer prudemment des hormones, en notant que rien ne change du jour au lendemain.

Histoire complète

I don't have a full detailed timeline of my own transition in these posts, but I can share what my experience has been. I desisted after learning about detransition, and that experience became a major turning point for me — it was, in my words, "the catalyst for many if not most of my political views to radically shift." I don't describe the exact ages or dates of my own first dysphoria, coming out, or medical steps in what I've written here, so I'll leave those details out rather than guess. What I can speak to is the process of coming out the other side. I've reflected a lot on how people get pulled into transition and what it takes to get out. I've told someone else, "You are a victim of a perverse ideology. You need to understand this was not your fault, even though you 'chose' it. Reading and listening to other detransitioners will help you to feel less alone and help you understand what happened." That framing — that it wasn't really your fault even though it felt like a choice — is how I make sense of my own path, and I believe connecting with other detransitioners is a key part of healing. I've also given practical advice to others considering stopping hormones: "You can always go back on hormones again if you decide to, and nothing is gonna change overnight. maybe quit the T and see how you feel?" That reflects my own view that stepping back from hormones is not an irreversible, all-or-nothing decision, and that taking time off to see how you feel is a reasonable approach. On the medical side, I'm fairly critical of how easily transgender medical care is handed out. My position is: "if you can't listen to the stories of detransitioners, and still be comfortable and confident in your medical decisions, you have no business with transgender medical care." I think anyone pursuing transition should be willing to sit with detransitioner stories without becoming defensive. I've also expressed concern about people who lack agency over their own bodies in medical contexts, calling one such situation "truly tragic." I care about data and transparency around detransition. I've asked whether surveys are capturing how suicidal ideation changes after transition — I wanted to see the bare statistics on that question because I feel "that is tremendously important," even if no one shares personal details, just the numbers. I've also been curious about comparing r/detrans membership to historical r/trans membership to get a rough (if imperfect) sense of detransition rates, since current comparisons are skewed by the growing popularity of gender ideology over time. In terms of my own mental health, I've taken a somewhat skeptical view of psychiatric medication, saying "all mental illness is situational. yeah sometimes you need meds but much of the time there are healthier ways that work." I don't describe a specific diagnosis for myself. On rebuilding life after detransition, I've thought a lot about identity and self-perception. I've advised someone not to feel obligated to their past self: "you do not have to do anything for your younger self. life is about learning, growth, and change. it's healthy to move forward. it's not healthy to trap yourself in the past." When it came to figuring out feminine presentation — wardrobe, makeup, hair — I described my own approach as paying attention to what I liked about other women and taking mental notes: I like very high-waisted jeans with loose shirts tied up in the front, I wear a lot of camisoles instead of bras for comfort, and I have small breasts. I suggested others do the same — just observe women and figure out what you like. On relationships and sexuality, I've emphasized trust: "I'd recommend not being intimate with someone you don't trust enough to talk about that personal of stuff with. trust is really important in sex regardless." I've been active in the detrans community, recommending the r/detrans Discord server (which has male-only and female-only spaces within it) as a support resource, and I've noted with some interest that r/detrans has surpassed 50k members. I also had an account reported for hate speech at one point, which I felt was unjustified by their own stated rules, with no avenue to appeal. Overall, I identify as desisted. I'm critical of how readily transition is pushed, especially without engaging detransitioner perspectives, and I advocate for peer support, better statistics, and a cautious approach to medical transition.