Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme cisgenre qui n'a jamais transitionné mais qui a passé du temps dans les communautés détrans pour y apporter un point de vue, ayant brièvement envisagé un THS pour une apparence plus masculine avant d'y renoncer. On ne m'a jamais diagnostiqué quoi que ce soit et je ne décris aucune intervention médicale, traumatisme ou difficulté de santé mentale qui me soit propre. Mes contributions se concentrent sur la question de savoir si les gens veulent être du sexe opposé ou simplement préfèrent l'androgynie, sur les limites du passing, sur l'AGP décrite comme un fétichisme traitable par la thérapie, et sur le soutien aux détransitionnés confrontés à des frictions sociales. Je reste critique de la transition sans esprit critique et des commentateurs sceptiques envers la thérapie, tout en insistant sur le fait que je ne suis pas en position de dire aux autres quoi faire. Je m'identifie actuellement comme une femme cisgenre sans projet de transition.
Histoire complète
I've never been trans and I never wanted to be trans, but I've lightly entertained the idea of HRT because I like the idea of a somewhat masculine appearance for myself. I naturally have very feminine features — large eyes, a thin jaw, a narrow nose — so even with a pixie cut and a men's T-shirt and sweatpants, I either look like a woman or, in my words, 'an abnormally tall 10-year-old boy.' I know I'm better off not committing to it, though I'm not even sure I could get access to it without lying about wanting to be trans.
I'm a woman who has always been cisgender. I enjoy feminine things, but I wouldn't describe it as euphoria. Most days I wear men's shirts and jeans around the house, or tank tops and jeans or sweatpants — not to be masculine, just because it's comfortable and I don't go out much. I like skirts and dresses when the occasion calls for it and I feel happy twirling in them, and looking feminine feels good, especially since I take more joy in those things than I used to. But I don't think 'OMG yes!!! I totally feel like a girl right now!' I might feel good stepping out in an outfit I like, but I don't spend every minute consciously focusing on how I look or dress.
The closest I've come to anything like euphoria was when I shaved my head. I'd had a grown-out pixie and kept short hair for some years, but having all my hair gone felt freeing and liberating. It took four years after I first wanted to cut my hair short before I finally did it ear-length, and the women in my family place a lot of emphasis on my hair for its natural color. For all their wanting, the person in charge was still me, and that felt kickass. I needed to clean it up with clippers my brother bought me and had little tufts where the scissors wouldn't cooperate, so I looked like a lunatic, but I felt what I'd truly describe as euphoria. Since I was never a trans woman, that's just my speculation on what gender euphoria might feel like.
I've spent a lot of time in detrans spaces, mostly answering questions rather than recounting a transition of my own. I ask people whether they want to be the opposite sex or whether they'd just prefer a more androgynous aesthetic, or something more masculine or feminine than what they really are. I've suggested that someone consider whether they have body dysmorphia, linking them to an NIH overview, and I've argued that finding people who accept you as a feminine man might make you less inclined to transition. I shared a friend's story: he grew up in a country where homosexuality is punishable by death, with strict gender norms and severe social consequences for straying from them. Once he moved abroad for university he had a blast with makeup and genderbent fashion, living openly as a gay genderbent man. He has called himself non-binary, but to him that just means 'I'm not a man the way society wants me to be and I'm ok with that,' not that his gender is outside man or woman.
I've been blunt with people considering transition later in life. I've said that most who transition after adolescence don't pass, that most will need cosmetic facial surgery to avoid being immediately obvious and most can't afford it, and that even Caitlyn Jenner, with all the money in the world, can still be read as trans. I've pointed out that digital editing and apps make it easy to feminize features in photos. I've told someone that they wouldn't be committing to 'being a woman' anatomically, only to passing for one, and listed sex-based differences — skeletal proportions, body fat percentages, skull sizes, hair type, pelvic bone shape — that hormones can't change. I've also said that being trans doesn't mean you 'always were' biologically the sex you're aligning with.
On AGP I've been direct: 'AGP is a fetish,' and getting rid of it is like asking whether you can get rid of a fetish. I'm not a medical professional, so I don't know if it's possible; the best way to find out is therapy, which could help someone explore the origins and factors of the fetish and manage it in a less distressing way. I defended that position against a commenter who was cynical about therapy, noting that therapists are legally mandated to keep disclosures confidential unless someone's life is in danger.
I've supported a detransitioner whose coworkers resented having to use their post-trans name, telling them they shouldn't be mad at themselves for 'confusing everyone' — that it's no real burden, like getting mad at a woman who changes her last name for marriage and then switches back after divorce. I called it lousy of the coworkers to think they have to 'understand' rather than just honor face-value requests, and said the town sounded like the type of place where collectivism is everything and no one thinks anything of thinking they know about other people. I've also pushed back on a comment that reduced a woman's grief over a mastectomy to whether men would find her hot again, saying women live with our bodies every day regardless of what men think, and that OP was coping with the effects of an invasive surgery and the grief she feels over it. I've been careful to say I'm not in a fair position to tell people what to do, since non-detrans people can't give advice under the sub rules, but I've wished people peace with themselves and support systems capable of guiding them.