Toutes les histoires

Une alliée sur r/detrans depuis 2019, jamais transitionnée

Féminin · Désisté·e174
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je ne suis pas détransitionnée ; je suis une commentatrice gender-critical qui suit r/detrans depuis fin 2019 en tant qu'alliée. J'exhorte systématiquement les personnes détransitionnées à croire que le rétablissement est possible, je leur conseille de rester à l'écart de la thérapie d'affirmation du genre, et je conteste le discours fataliste du « pas de retour possible ». Je suis critique du fait que les femmes trans se placent au centre des histoires des détransitionneuses et du « sexisme résiduel » de cette formulation, et je compare la médecine de transition actuelle aux lobotomies. Je suis sceptique face aux affirmations sur le sexe du cerveau et à la terminologie AMAB/AFAB omniprésente, préférant un langage « observé ». Je n'ai décrit dans cette transcription aucune transition personnelle, histoire médicale ou condition de santé mentale.

Histoire complète

I am not detransitioned myself — I have said repeatedly in this community that "Im not detrans so feel free to disregard" — but I have been an active, engaged reader and commenter here since at least December 2019, and I want to lay out what I have written and what it says about how I see these issues. I first showed up in December 2019 simply thanking someone for a poignant comment. By January 2020 I was asking detailed questions about the "cutesy" act that some trans people put on, wondering aloud why they do it, and theorizing that it might be "a way to identify in-group status" that I see "from both males and females." I was already thinking in terms of group dynamics and social signaling. I am clearly gender critical in my outlook, though I noted that the subreddit I post in "is not necessarily gc, so a mix of terminology is used." I explained the gc usage of "omab" and "ofab" (observed rather than assigned), explicitly framing "assigned" as pro-trans ideology's way of denoting "the supposed colonial nature of sex" and "observed" as denoting "the value of biological reality by gc circles." I also acknowledged that "amab and afab are so ubiquitous, and often times people arent aware of why theyre not the best terms to use" — I care about the language debate and hold a clear position in it. In February 2020 I responded at length to a young detransitioned woman in pain. I validated her anger — "Let yourself be angry and sad. Let yourself feel betrayed. You have every right to feel however you do" — and told her that her body would produce estrogen again, that her breasts could recover if she had not had top surgery, that she could remove body hair and train her voice. I told her she could "come back from this" and that maybe someday she would be thankful for the wisdom. My concrete advice was to explore therapy but "stay away from the gender affirming ones," to find an outlet, use reddit, and connect with other girls in real life who had had the experience. I framed survival in almost archetypal terms: "every person is the child of a survivor." I pushed back against fatalism in the community. When someone implied there was no coming back, I said "I dont think we should be saying things like that" because detrans people reading should "know they have options, not that theres no coming back." I compared the current medical approach to transition to "lobotomies." I was "absolutely dying to go into the future to see what people will say about this" — I expect history to judge the current era harshly. I am critical of how some MTF voices engage with female detransitioners' stories. I said an article read as if the author was mainly "concerned with how female detrans peoples experiences affect mtf people," questioned whether "its really a trans womans place to offer their perspective," and agreed with a line about "residual sexism to fight" — "yeah pretty much. No maybes here." I thought the framing of detransition as a necessary evil was weak, and that the author was "using the whole thing as a way to shift the focus of conversation onto themselves." On the science, I am skeptical of brain-sex claims: "Thats just diversity not a binary. Look at millions of straight male brains, youre very likely to see ones that look like female brains." I ask people whether they are citing a specific study. I have also engaged with practical, supportive threads — complimenting someone's voice (noting it sounded female but "one that has been on t before"), commenting on how self-conscious thoughts are legible to others nonverbally, and cheering on someone's story. I noted I am "only a few years older than this generation so i missed the wave" — meaning I am slightly older than the cohort that transitioned in the mid-2010s — and I expressed genuine admiration for them: "everyday im impressed with how insightful and driven you all are," predicting they will "become well adjusted older adults." I have not described any personal transition, detransition, medical intervention, diagnosis, trauma, or mental health condition anywhere in this transcript. My participation is that of an engaged, gender-critical ally and observer rather than a detransitioned person.