Toutes les histoires

Quatre ans de binder, aucune hormone, et un prénom gardé quand même

Féminin · Désisté·e572
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je me suis identifiée comme une personne trans FTM binaire pendant près de quatre ans et j’étais ouverte auprès de mes proches et de ma famille pendant trois de ces années, mais je n’ai jamais pris d’hormones ni subi de chirurgie — même si j’ai porté un binder et du ruban adhésif chaque jour pendant 1,5 à 2 ans, ce qui m’a laissé des douleurs à la poitrine et des lésions cutanées. Fin 2024 et début 2025, j’ai décidé de me désister, en gardant le prénom que j’avais choisi, David, et je suis maintenant une femme désistée qui gère sa grave dysphorie de genre par la pleine conscience et l’autodiscipline plutôt que par la transition. J’attribue ma transition à l’évasion, à la haine de soi, à un trouble alimentaire, à la misogynie intériorisée, à la répression sexuelle, à la peur de grandir, à l’autisme et à la jalousie. Ma qualité de vie s’est nettement améliorée depuis mon désistement — je suis plus sociable, plus productive et de nouveau capable de désirer des choses — même si j’ai encore des jours difficiles avec la dysphorie. Je suis bisexuelle avec une faible libido, actuellement dans une phase hétéro, et tout en soutenant l’autonomie corporelle des autres pour faire une transition, je ne crois pas qu’on puisse changer de sexe et je pense que la transition est un mauvais choix pour la plupart de ceux qui l’envisagent.

Histoire complète

I identified as a binary female-to-male transgender person for nearly four years, and I was out to my inner circle of friends and family for about three of those years. I presented as masculinely as I could without medical intervention, and I never really grouped myself socially with either gender—I had friends who were mainly women in some circles and mainly men in others. By late 2024 I was at an impasse: transition or desist. I didn't like presenting androgynously; it didn't feel like me. I hated being asked what was in my pants, hated not feeling like I had a place in social dynamics, hated that I wouldn't introduce myself to people because I didn't want to give them my given name but had no proper reason to give my preferred name. I felt socially stunted, isolated, and like I wasn't really a person. I acknowledged that, due to my odd socialization, I had a lot of gender bias and complex internalized feelings that made it hard to discern my actual relationship with gender. I decided that was a definitive sign to put further transition on the backburner while I sorted myself out, and that I would have a conversation with close friends and family, feminize my presentation somewhat for practical and aesthetic reasons, grow out my hair, bind less invasively, and use my given name and sex-assigned pronouns more freely. It felt bad—I didn't want to do it—but I told myself being a woman in the practical sense felt like the easy choice, and being cisgender felt like freedom. On January 5, 2025, I had what I called a moment of realization: the idea of letting go of an unattainable desire in favor of maximizing what I was stuck with went from upsetting and scary to freedom. I decided to keep my male name, David, saying there was no reason a girl couldn't be called David. I was tired of compromising the expressive, interesting person I was to chase a futile chance at passing for something I wasn't. I told myself I would like to be a man if I could, but I wasn't going to be a lifelong medical patient in service of an impossible desire to be a biological male. By mid-January 2025 I was gradually social-desisting after several years of being half-in, half-out of the closet. I decided to stop pursuing transition in favor of learning to manage my severe gender dysphoria and be the best woman I could be without altering myself physically or socially. I no longer planned to medically transition and was working toward finding my social, professional, and stylistic presentation as a woman. I live in a blue-bubble area of a much larger, more conservative area and attend art school, which made desisting more complicated because I knew people who would protest my choice. I was especially worried about telling my closest friend. Talking to my family went well—they thought my decision was mature and brave. I never took hormones or had surgery as far as my posts indicate, but I did bind and tape every day for 12+ hours over a period of 1.5 to 2 years, binding down to nearly flat with only about a 10-hour break on weekends. My bust was around 28DD. This left me with pain on my right side and a slightly raised scar-like spot where it connects to my chest, with crepey skin around it that felt like part of my breast belonged to an old woman. I quit taping and binding completely about two months before February 2025, and it looked better after I quit, though I'm a very slow healer. I was moisturizing and being gentle with the area. I also worried about my digital footprint: there was one published instance, from about a year before March 2025, of an androgynous photo of me under a slightly different pseudonym with 'he' pronouns in my information, in a field where work is published alongside one's name and picture. I had spent a long time deciding whether to let it go through reading male and told myself it was 'acceptance of myself'—which I later face-palmed about. I was afraid it could be used against me in my career, and I hated that the world could see an iteration of me I no longer agreed with. I had a handful of people I met after my transition was underway who believed I was male, and I dropped out of their lives almost entirely shortly before desisting. Rebuilding those bridges was hard—I worried about how to apologize for what I then called my willful deceit. I eventually took the advice to bite the bullet and tell a friend, taking cues from others' stories about how they'd done it. On causes: I've described my transition as an attempt at escapism—'a desire to escape myself. To face the facts, I hate myself.' I said my whole life had been a string of escapism attempts, transition being only the most socially acceptable one. I also described transition as an excellent way to escape personal responsibility: 'I can't do XYZ important adult thing because I'm not far enough along in my transition yet to be allowed to be happy. Therefore, I never have to grow up.' I've listed contributors to my dysphoria as an eating disorder, misogyny (internal and external), sexual repression, fear of change/growing up, and autism. I also identified jealousy as a factor, saying it's hard to fall into transgenderism without elevated jealous tendencies, and I envied my best friend for years. I noted I had severe physical dysphoria combined with indifference to the social aspect—I would have given my liver for a male body but enjoyed the aesthetics of all kinds of clothing. On sexuality: I realized I was interested in women at 8 or 9 years old and have always accepted myself as same-sex attracted, even repressing my opposite-sex attraction as a teen, which I think was a dysphoria manifestation. I identify as bisexual with a relatively low libido. I've questioned whether my attraction to women was partly envy—whether I wanted to be her or be with her—and whether I'd been leaning into the female side of my bisexuality as a coping mechanism for dysphoria, to separate myself from other women. My first attractions were sexual and romantic toward women, to the point I thought I might be wholly homosexual, but as I've gotten older I've come to feel almost the reverse, concluding my preference for men is so strong that a meaningful romantic relationship with a woman again is unlikely. I've been in a 'hetero phase' of my bisexual cycle for about a year as of May 2025. I came out as bisexual to my mom with, in my words, waaaay too much information. I experience sexual attraction weakly and inconsistently, needing weeks between experiences, and I described sex as less about my own pleasure and more a way to show love by making a partner feel good. On what moved me toward detransition: it was largely internal reflection and self-interrogation rather than therapy or external intervention. I described signs I was going to detransition as: paralyzing fear of the future as transition got closer and I had to reckon with actually going through the steps, which made me feel far from 'myself' and led me to interrogate my trans identity and then trans identity as a concept; romantic and sexual experimentation outside what my dysphoria deemed acceptable; sudden life changes, becoming very sad but very productive, aware of wasted time; new openness and a craving for connection, understanding, and honesty as the secrecy and shame that drove my trans identity gave way; and whimsy. I also described a dream about an old non-binary friend who said they couldn't respect my desisting because 'once you admit to being dysphoric, the cat's out of the bag. i don't want to be complicit in your self harm,' which I took as telling about how well-intentioned trans groups think. I framed my realization as: I didn't realize I wasn't 'trans,' I realized 'trans' isn't a thing—hormones and surgery don't change one's sex, a different name and presentation don't make one socially compatible with the opposite sex, and dysphoria is discomfort that can be assuaged through other means, for me largely mindfulness and self-discipline. I manage dysphoria by separating my desire to be male from my feelings about my body—recognizing it's a fact I wish I'd been born male, but that doesn't make my female body bad or in need of medical intervention. On mental health: I described severe gender dysphoria that I'm working to manage, and I said I was deeply neurotic and needed something to fret over. I acknowledged I hated myself and was working on that. In April 2025 I posted that I missed having an outlet for my dysphoria—when I was trans-identified I had the delusion the suffering would go away when I transitioned, and now it was just helpless misery, and some days were Hard. I also noted that within my detransition period I became very sad but very productive. On regret and outcomes: I don't frame my experience in terms of surgical regret since I didn't have surgeries, but I regretted the time and identity, describing awareness of 'the time I wasted' and embarrassment about my digital footprint. I noted I got off pretty easy on social, medical, and digital effects. As of June 2025 my quality of life had markedly improved: I found my perfect lipstick shade, bought a giant replica of my favorite flower, made plans with friends, gave a short piano recital in a beautiful dress for friends, family, and strangers, and found that I wanted things again—for a long time my only desires were so impossible that I became numb to wanting, feeling indifferent toward everything, and I'm learning to want things again. I described the transition from misery to engagement with life as incredible. On attitudes toward transition for others: I'm not against transition for other people under certain circumstances—there are some very binary, very transsexual individuals who transition well and are obviously benefited by it, but I believe 90% of people with gender dysphoria aren't part of that group, and transition was wrong for me and statistically will be wrong for most who consider it. I approach trans-identified people the way I approach smokers: it's horrible for them, no one should do it, but it's not worth being unkind or hateful—love people, question their choices. Strangers transitioning doesn't bother me; I think it's a bad choice but I don't lose sleep over it. I do agree that people insisting on inclusion in women's spaces and allowing children to transition are incorrect and unethical, but my contempt for that ideology has nothing to do with my feelings about the people. I believe in bodily autonomy and that people have the right to take medical, legal, or social transition steps, but I don't believe that makes them a protected class, and I don't agree with how the current American administration handles gender politics. I've said I don't believe it's possible to change one's sex and don't think attempting to do so is a healthy choice. I've also said that making permanent, life-altering physical changes to satisfy a sexual desire is psychologically damaging, and that a man considering vaginoplasty stands to lose much more than he stands to gain. I've been critical of what I see as the idea that transgenderism is an objective yes/no state of being rather than a subjective collection of behaviors that dysphoria can push one to engage in. I've offered advice to others questioning, encouraging someone with no prior dysphoria who loved their body to let it go if they can, and telling people to present however they want but not label themselves. I haven't described formal advocacy or activism, but I've been an active, encouraging presence in online detransition and desistance communities. On current identity: I identify as a woman—specifically, as I put it, 'a weird fucking woman'—who is female, bisexual, and managing severe gender dysphoria without medical or social transition. I kept the name David. I consider myself desisted rather than fully detransitioned since I never medically transitioned.