Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme désistante qui a détransitionné et qui conseille maintenant, dans cette communauté, de se demander si l'on transitionne pour soi ou comme bouclier contre le jugement social. J'en suis venue à croire qu'une grande part de ce que je vivais comme de la dysphorie était liée à la misogynie intériorisée, à la non-conformité de genre et à des prophéties autoréalisatrices au sujet des hormones plutôt qu'à une identité innée. Fréquenter d'autres femmes et avoir des modèles féminins masculins a énormément aidé ma dysphorie, et je trouve maintenant du réconfort à voir mon corps comme un simple outil, « une conscience dans une enveloppe de viande ». Je préviens les autres qu'ils le « regretteront tôt ou tard » si la transition n'est pas vraiment faite pour eux, et je plaide pour que les femmes puissent jouer dans les équipes féminines et pour que l'on reconnaisse les facteurs socioculturels derrière les différences de sexe perçues. Je n'ai décrit dans ces messages aucune intervention médicale, chirurgie ou chronologie précise de transition / détransition.
Histoire complète
I have been writing in this community for a while now, and looking back over what I've said, I can trace how my thinking has developed. Early on, in October 2022, I responded to someone by saying simply, "absolutely. you have no idea how bad it is" — referring to how bad the dysphoria or the situation around it felt at the time.
By early 2023 I had become much more analytical about what was driving me and others toward transition. In January 2023 I pushed back on the idea that testosterone makes people calmer or better behaved, arguing that testosterone is "the hormone responsible for aggression? high sex drive?" and pointing out that men commit most violent crimes, so "everything is telling me it's quite the opposite." I suggested that even beliefs about women feeling calmer after menopause could be "attributed to internalized cultural stereotypes" and that when you're led to believe false information about hormones, "it simply becomes a self fulfilling prophecy," noting there are studies on this.
On February 3, 2023 I described a study I'd seen: two groups of female soccer players, one actually given testosterone without being told, the other given nothing but misled into believing they'd received it. The group that actually had testosterone didn't change behavior, but the misled group became significantly more aggressive and competitive and performed better. I used this to tell another person that their fear of becoming "small and weak" on testosterone was "essentially just a self fulfilling prophecy" and that they'd "always been a female either way." I recommended they get off T and start playing with women, saying that socializing with women and "seeing how wonderful they are helped my dysphoria tremendously."
That same day I discussed growth plates with someone worried about height, explaining that both estrogen and testosterone fuse growth plates at high doses, but at lower doses they'd be fine, and that estrogen stimulates HGH production, so "i think you still have a chance."
I also wrote a long argument about physical differences between sexes. I argued that women are "socialized to be petite and therefore weak" while men are told to get big and muscular. I pointed out that studies on muscle mass of untrained men and women aren't fully accurate because untrained women are "far more untrained than untrained men," since men are more physically active and get more nutrition, especially as teens. I brought up the "bone bank" concept — childhood/teen physical activity affects bone density for life, which affects muscle. From my own experience, I recalled girls stopping running and playing in elementary/middle school while boys never stopped: "while my female classmate were peacefully sitting and gossiping, my male classmates were sprinting around the school until they turn red every single break." I also remembered my parents giving my stepbrother more meat "because he's a feature man, he must eat a lot," but not me. I noted that girls' malnutrition is a genuine scientific concern, that people in third world countries are getting bigger and stronger with better diet, and that at some point in history women gained 3 inches in height while men gained 1 inch just from better nutrition and being allowed to work. I mentioned Victorian women weren't allowed to run. Since getting into lifting, I'd learned women have significantly more HGH than men, which compensates for lack of testosterone, so women gain just as much muscle in relative terms, linking to an article. I also argued women have more muscle endurance, balance, and flexibility, and asked why we only consider as "strengths" whatever men excel at, comparing it to how differences between ethnicities aren't used to put people down — "it almost seems like male solidarity." My conclusion was that if everyone were socialized the same way there'd be more variety between individuals and women wouldn't be seen as weak. I advised the person to play on whatever team they wanted unless they were at a high level of hockey, but still recommended playing with women, "since once you detransition, men will no longer treat or see you as an equal and it simply becomes dangerous."
On February 16, 2023 I asked someone, "which part of this post gave you the idea that he's not actually crazy?"
On February 20, 2023 I responded to someone questioning why one needs testosterone just to be masculine, calling that mindset "very backward and dangerous." I said enjoying things associated with the opposite sex doesn't make you the opposite sex — "it's just called being an individual." I affirmed being gender non-conforming: "nothing wrong with being a masculine woman or a feminine man." I shared that even wanting features of the opposite sex doesn't necessarily make you trans — I knew cis women who wanted a deeper voice for the masculine aesthetic, "me including." I said having masculine female role models helped my self-acceptance tremendously, showing me my sex doesn't define me, and added my philosophy: "you're just a consciousness inside a meat suit lol, your body is just a tool to move you through the world." I diagnosed the person I was replying to as having two main issues: "internalized misogyny and being gender non conforming," and urged them to consider whether they were doing this for their own happiness or using transition as a shield from society's judgment, warning that if the latter, "you'll regret it sooner than later, like most people here." I ended by saying self love and acceptance is key.
On February 21, 2023 I complimented someone's androgynous appearance: "i instantly saw an androgynous woman tbh. i wish i had your features."
Overall, I appear to be a detransitioned or desisted female who has done a lot of thinking about internalized misogyny, gender non-conformity, and the social construction of physical sex differences, and who now counsels others in the community to question their motives before transitioning.