Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Histoire complète
I never posted my own story here; I mostly commented on other people's threads, but over time I said enough that a picture of where I stand comes through.
I first started having thoughts about transitioning about five years ago — that puts the beginning of it around 2018, since my earliest comments here are from August 2023. When someone asked me what feeling normal was like before those thoughts started, I turned the question back on them: were they still doing the same hobbies, work, relationships they had back then, and could they fill in the blanks and add back whatever was missing from that time. That is genuinely how I think about it — that something went missing from my life, and that the answer is to recover it rather than to keep moving away from it.
I am into fitness, and that shows up a lot in what I write. I know several men and women who take steroids, and I have been struck by how much knowledge and caution they exercise with those substances — testosterone included — which is far beyond anything I have seen from the trans friends in my circle. That comparison matters to me: people using powerful hormones recreationally or for sport treat them with more respect than I saw around medical transition. I also push back on the idea that workout advice splits cleanly by sex. I looked at a fitness YouTuber's channel and noted it was full of dance workouts and glute and ab development videos, and pointed out that none of those things are more beneficial to a female body than a male one — they are more appealing as types of exercises, sure, for most women, but that is not the same as being sex-specific. When someone asked about gaining fat while lifting consistently, I said plainly: do less cardio, increase daily calorie intake, and a personal trainer can adjust reps and weight depending on whether you want to build muscle or tone.
On the substance of transition itself, I have become fairly direct. I told someone flatly, "You can't change your sex or your sexual orientation," and drew a distinction I think is important: "'Detrans from being gay' is conversion therapy or forcing your natural traits back. Detrans from gender is the opposite of this, its embracing your natural state without needing a conversion therapy aka transition." I do not think transition is right for everyone — I have said openly that I think it may be the right choice for some people — but I am skeptical of how it is being offered now.
I have thought a lot about the social dynamics. When a poster described being dropped by friends after detransitioning, I told them they were better off knowing who their real friends were, and I made an observation that stuck with me: this topic comes up frequently in detrans spaces, but I have never seen people in trans spaces say "my friend is detransitioning and I don't want to be their friend any longer." When it does happen, I said, it is when the detrans friend also expresses opposition to gender ideology and is therefore labelled a terf. My read was that detransitioners' friends drop them because "they don't ever even want to think about the chance they made a mistake — and a life of no self reflection like this is not healthy." I told the poster to keep doing them, no matter where they end up.
I have also engaged with the statistics and the healthcare policy side. I corrected someone's reasoning about suicide rates — pointing out that two groups can both be 40 times more likely than the general population to die by suicide even if one has 10,000 members and 40 suicides and the other has 100M members and 4,000 suicides. On medication, I argued that drugs for other mental illnesses that do not work for 100% of patients are not banned; other options exist and patients are informed and often try several approaches before finding what works. With trans healthcare, I said, there is effectively one option, and it should be a good thing when studies come out showing effectiveness, good or poor, so treatment approaches can be diversified — but that is not the case currently. I was careful to say that papers raising concerns are not the same as people gunning for bans without thought to harm.
The most intense exchange I had was with a gender therapist who said they were "literally terrified" of making a mistake. I told them they had probably already made that mistake, given how self-aware their practice seemed compared to others, and that cognitive dissonance can protect us from fully facing reality. I said if they truly did not want to be an active participant in harm, they should quit and stop transitioning people. I doubted they were actually going against current care guidelines — treating other mental illness first, making patients aware of the limits of medicalization, not transitioning people without dysphoria, recommending trauma work for internalized homophobia or misogyny — and I said I was leaning toward their terror not being genuine, given the stories they had read lurking here of people who were textbook cases and detransitioned years later. In a follow-up I pressed harder: their ethics were the ethics they could meet "within your ethical obligations as a medical professional," and viewing "doing no harm" as accomplished up to the point where current, clearly harmful care guidelines kick in does not absolve them of actively doing harm. I asked the question that I thought they could not answer: of all their trans patients, how many moved to other doctors as detrans cases, or will never seek care in detransition? I hoped they never had a first-hand experience of it, but told them to reckon with the possibility before they had to.
The last long thing I wrote was to someone whose motivation for transitioning reminded me of a straight friend of mine who began transitioning years ago. I shared the whole story because I thought it might help. I was surprised when he came out — I had never seen him as feminine in behavior. Back then I thought all trans people experienced dysphoria, and I was further surprised when he said he didn't; he transitioned in adulthood with no bodily dysphoria. Any femininity he had, he explained, was simply that he did not behave in the ways the most macho male stereotypes would expect — hang-ups about not succeeding at those, not actual femininity. He had been very lonely, likely depressed, and lacked meaningful personal or professional community. During transition he says he hates men and centers them as the enemy, which was not the case beforehand; I think he feels comfortable saying that "as a woman" rather than as a man who didn't fit in. He does want to be regarded as a woman, to have a feminine body, and says he dressed in his mother's clothes as a young child. Transition has been positive for him in the community he has built, the purpose in the transition itself, and fighting for the trans cause — but you can achieve community and purpose without changing gender. Given he has no gender dysphoria, I think a sexual component is likely driving it, though we have never talked about it at face value. My general view: "I believe transition requires a strong motivation centered around the target sex. GD is one, and if someone lacks GD, I think sexual motivation around the target gender is the only other strong factor." I do not think sexual motivations or GD are bad reasons to transition, but I advised the person to consider whether they could be happy by addressing their issues in other ways — that is a lot of work, but so is transitioning. The other path of healing is less clearly cut, but I believe it will make them happier and healthier in the long run.
I also told someone asking a trans-identifying question to try r/questioning, since this is a sub for the detrans community, and I once replied to a framing about attraction with, "More like have you heard of bisexuality."
As for where I am now: I have not written out my own detransition timeline here, so I will not invent one. What I can say is that I had thoughts of transitioning starting around five years ago, I no longer identify as trans, I consider detransition from gender to be embracing my natural state, and I am now openly critical of how transition is offered — while still believing it can be right for some people. I have not described surgeries, hormone use, or medical complications of my own in these comments.