Toutes les histoires

Je lisais r/detrans en m'identifiant encore comme trans

Féminin · Désisté·e119
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui est arrivée sur r/detrans en 2020 alors que je m'identifiais encore comme trans et « désespérée de transitionner médicalement », en lurkant comme une « personne en questionnement dans ma propre transition » et en sondant la communauté sur la confiance et les connaissances des autres avant la transition médicale. Au fil de 2020 et jusqu'en 2021, je suis devenue critique de la façon dont la transition était promue — en m'opposant aux tests « suis-je trans » à critère unique, à l'accent mis sur le genre social plutôt que sur les effets corporels permanents, et à l'infantilisation des hommes trans — tout en défendant la capacité des enfants à reconnaître la dysphorie et en m'opposant aux insultes dans les publications anti-trans. En avril 2021, j'avais conclu que j'avais été confuse plutôt que trans, en disant à une autre personne « Tu n'as jamais été un garçon... Tu es une femme, et cela n'a jamais changé, tu t'es juste un peu perdue en chemin », ce qui reflète la façon dont je vois maintenant mes propres années d'identification comme trans. Je ne décris jamais avoir pris d'hormones ni subi de chirurgie dans ces messages, et je n'indique aucune intervention médicale, complication ou souci de fertilité. Je ne décris dans cette transcription aucun diagnostic de santé mentale, traumatisme ni idée suicidaire.

Histoire complète

I first came to the r/detrans community in April 2020, but I was not detransitioned at that point — I told people plainly that I was 'not detrans' and that the subreddit's rules were anti-transition and therefore likely biased. At that time I was still identifying as trans and was, by my own later description, 'already desperate to medically transition.' I recommended that someone asking for advice try gender therapy, or, if they didn't want that, try living as female again to see how they felt, and I noted that transition doesn't necessarily mean you can't have biological children because you can freeze your eggs. I stayed on as a lurker and questioner. In September 2020 I told the community I was 'here as a questioner in my own transition,' that I generally lurked to read others' stories, and that I didn't want to leave comments under a flair that would make people think I was detrans. I said I had trouble feeling sorry for people who did not do their own research, while clarifying I did feel sorry for them and did not intend to shame anyone, and I expressed concern that a fair number of people there had pursued transition without sufficient knowledge about it. I asked whether a 'would be detrans' flair would fit me, then corrected myself after noticing a 'questioning own transition' flair. I also asked what the flairs meant, including 'the lizard one,' explaining I'd given myself a random flair because I didn't know what they meant. I posted several polls in 2020 asking the detrans community about their birth sex, how confident they were in being trans before beginning medical transition, and how much they knew about the effects of hormones before starting them — questions that suggest I was researching transition carefully before committing to it. My views during this period were mixed. I called myself 'a trans lurker' and argued with people who, having decided their gender was no longer male, still called themselves trans guys, saying I didn't understand 'this branch of trans people who want to ignore the gender =/= sex that is so heavily repeated in so many places.' I was critical of what I saw as trivialising or pressuring culture around transition: I said I hated trans-supportive posts that claimed a single trait could guarantee someone is trans, arguing that nothing can do that 'without the whole context of their life, let alone given by a stranger on the Internet,' and that such posts trivialise being trans. I also said I disliked how much focus was placed on 'social gender' rather than 'the realistic, permanent, effects on your body,' and I complained that people who infantilise trans men are often the same people eager to cancel others for transphobia while 'blatantly seeing trans men as lesser men than cis men.' On the question of children, I argued that plenty of children can recognise sex dysphoria, though not every child who thinks they do is correct and appropriate therapy should be pursued before any rash decisions, while also objecting to the use of slurs in a post's title. In October 2020 I advised someone with doubts about upcoming top surgery to hold off, saying there was plenty of time to get it in the future since, unlike testosterone, its effectiveness doesn't decrease with age; I suggested the doubts might relate to an IUD or hormonal fluctuations, or might be worries about surgery, and recommended a therapist or journaling, adding that 'this might be temporary doubts, it might be the start of detransition, but the important thing is not to rush it.' By April 2021 my position had shifted decisively. When someone described being confused and having thought they were a boy, I told them to get a new therapist because theirs didn't sound fit to deal with gender issues, and I said: 'You were never a boy. Like you said, you were confused... You're a woman, and that never changed, you just got a little lost along the way.' I framed putting the years of thinking you were trans behind you as understandable and possible, comparing it to how trans people aim to put their AGAB life behind them. This is the clearest statement in my posts that I had come to see my own time identifying as trans as a period of confusion to be moved past, and to identify as a woman again.