Toutes les histoires

Onze ans de minipilule, pas de règles, pas de regrets

Féminin · Désisté·e1,8 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée — même si je dois être claire : je ne me suis jamais identifiée comme trans moi-même ; j'ai passé des années à fréquenter les communautés de détransition et j'ai des opinions très critiques sur les pratiques actuelles de transition, surtout pour les jeunes femmes. Je prends la minipilule progestative seule depuis mes seize ans (plus de onze ans), sans quasiment de règles et sans effets secondaires. Je crois que la plupart des transitions FtM viennent d'un désir d'échapper à la misogynie ou à un traumatisme sexuel, et que l'identification non binaire reflète souvent une misogynie intériorisée ou un désir de statut particulier plutôt qu'une véritable identité. J'ai plaidé pour la prudence avant les procédures irréversibles, mis en garde contre les effets secondaires sous-déclarés de la testostérone et de la chirurgie, et critiqué la culture de l'obsession du passing. Sur le plan mental, j'ai eu du mal à m'aimer par le passé, mais je ne crois plus que cela empêche les autres de m'aimer.

Histoire complète

I was born female and have lived my whole life in the UK. I have never identified as trans myself — I want to be clear about that up front — but I have spent years reading and posting in detrans and trans-related communities, and through those conversations I have come to understand a great deal about what leads people toward transition and away from it. I have been on birth control — the progestin-only 'mini pill' as we call it here — for over eleven years, since I was sixteen. It has given me almost no periods, maybe one a year, no side effects, and no pregnancies. I have found it genuinely essential; I don't think I could hold down a job without it, and I've recommended it to others dealing with heavy or difficult periods. I have never taken testosterone or had any gender-related medical procedures, but I have modified my body in other ways and I hold strong views about surgery. I am not religious, but I am sceptical of removing body parts in general — I point to links between tonsil and adenoid removal and immunity problems, and I'm suspicious of removing organs supposedly 'redundant' like the appendix. I believe everything in the body is probably doing more work than we realise. I have thought a lot about why people, particularly young females, end up identifying as trans. My view is that a large proportion of FTM transition is about escaping misogyny, trauma from sexual abuse or assault, everyday sexual harassment, and sexual expectations. I have also come to believe that some of the current wave of identification as non-binary or trans is driven by a kind of 'oppression olympics' — that once being gay stopped being unusual or conferring a kind of special status, some kids moved on to NB or trans identities to feel distinct. I am critical of non-binary as a concept, arguing that GNC and non-binary are opposites: GNC people accept their sex and show that males and females of all styles and personalities exist, whereas non-binary reinforces the idea that not fitting a stereotype means you can't really be your birth sex. I have also suggested that internalised or societal homophobia plays a role for some people. I have been quite active in pushing back on what I see as harmful narratives. I have argued against the idea that you have to love yourself before others can love you — that belief 'really fucked me up when I was younger'. I have argued that 'they' pronouns can themselves be a form of misgendering when used deliberately for someone. I have criticised the culture of obsessing over passing — walking, talking, sitting, laughing a certain way — as inauthentic, an act rather than anything real. I have also criticised the double standard where trans advocacy insists men can have boobs and vaginas while simultaneously treating those same traits as catastrophic enough to require surgical removal. On medical issues, I have tried to warn people about under-discussed side effects of testosterone, including balding — noting that many naive young FTMs expect to look like 'hot anime characters not balding bank managers' — and I have pushed back on the idea that because risks are listed in a leaflet, people who raise them are simply complaining. I have also discussed complications of chest surgery, including nerve damage, numbness, chronic pain and hypersensitivity, and I have criticised the '1% detrans' statistic as a myth. I have expressed the view that it is generally better not to be the one delivering unwelcome warnings to people set on transition, because you'll just be attacked for it. I have also spoken about how hard it can be for detransitioned women socially — the voice change and facial hair that out them in every public situation, the danger of being read as a woman with a deep voice — and I have argued that many detrans women do find partners who love and accept them. I have encouraged people considering transition to wait until their doubts are gone in one direction or the other, quoting the idea that 'when you feel uncertain, don't choose the path with no return.' On suicide, I have written at length encouraging someone not to give up, saying their life is worth living even if they're not happy, and that the problem is not their body or their sex but deeper reasons they may need years to understand. I have also argued that posting a single detrans suicide on trans forums is equivalent to posting every trans suicide on detrans forums — one case doesn't represent everyone. I have been open about not loving myself, but I no longer believe that stops other people loving me. I don't believe in God. Overall I would describe myself as critical of the current direction of trans medicine and trans ideology, particularly for young females, while still wanting people considering transition to be treated with compassion and given accurate information.