Toutes les histoires

Accepter d'être un homme a mis fin à l'obsession du genre

Masculin · Détransitionné·e36
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis un homme détransitionné qui ne s'identifie plus comme trans et qui a largement cessé de penser à la transition. Accepter que je suis un homme et devenir à l'aise avec ma masculinité ont été les étapes clés qui ont mis fin à mon obsession du genre. Je me concentre maintenant sur des priorités extérieures plutôt que de ruminer intérieurement, et je ne révèle ma détransition que lorsque je le choisis. Je suis critique de la façon dont la transition est promue en ligne et de l'idée que l'on « naît trans », et j'essaie d'aider les autres à réfléchir de manière réaliste aux résultats chirurgicaux et aux décisions médicales.

Histoire complète

I'm a detransitioned male who went from identifying as trans to accepting that I am a man. My transition and detransition happened before this transcript, so I can't give exact dates for them here, but by the time I was writing in January 2022 I was clearly on the other side of it. What I can tell you is how I think about it now. I used to be consumed by gender — constantly running 'what ifs' about being the opposite gender, obsessing over whether I should transition. That obsession has faded with time. I still browse the detrans subreddit occasionally for 'juicy content,' but I think about transgender stuff far less than I used to, and I don't think about transitioning anymore. In my experience, accepting that I am male was the key step that stopped me from fixating on transition. Being comfortable with my masculinity was the next step — everyone has to get comfortable with their masculinity and femininity and how much of each they want to show the world. I found that when I'm comfortable being a man, I lean less toward feminine energy. I do think intrusive thoughts about gender are fairly normal, especially for someone who has been through a transition, however brief. But obsessing over transition is inherently narcissistic. Everyone can be narcissistic about one thing or another, and I agree with others that finding new priorities matters — life isn't all internal, it's external too. Seeing Machu Picchu, going to a concert, getting a job that gives you security — those things enrich your life from the outside. I'm fairly blunt with people who are pre-transition or questioning. When someone tells me they don't think they act different than an average guy, I ask whether they've considered that they might act differently and just not realize it. When a male-identified person fantasizes about being a father, I point out that women don't fantasize about being fathers — maybe they're just a confused guy rather than a 'trans woman,' even if that's not as exciting to contemplate. I don't think people are 'born trans'; for many, being trans is not something you are but something you do. It's psychologically more pleasing to believe you're bound to some diagnosis or rigid path to your 'true self,' but I don't buy it. I also push back hard on the idea that gender roles can simply be dismantled — they're biologically influenced behaviors ingrained in culture over tens of thousands of years, and most people enjoy them, which is why they exist. I think people stuck in revolutionary thinking about 'changing' gender are struggling to cope with the world as it is and are engaging in fantasy instead. On medical questions, I'm cautious. Surgery is the only way to remove breast tissue — there's no shortcut. If you're on medications, you need a doctor who actually understands the drugs you're taking, because doctors don't understand the minutiae of medications they never prescribe. Asking randos online only gets you so far, and you're right to be wary of asking trans randos specifically, because they're inherently biased toward believing these drugs or blocking puberty have no negative side effects. I also warn people not to listen to older trans people on Reddit or Discord who say 'you'll just end up doing it later and regret it, that's what happened to me' — those people never had a real first transition. Thinking about transitioning isn't transitioning; taking HRT for four weeks isn't transitioning. They're lying about their psychological state and are still stuck in fantasy land. My real advice is that it's much easier to detransition once you've experienced the variety of mundane horrors that living as transgender exposes you to. It's nearly impossible to convince a pre-transition person not to transition — the male drive to 'do something' is that powerful, like trying to persuade a patriotic soldier not to march into battle. But if you really transition, have deep experiences, and understand the ins and outs, then when you detransition the obsession leaves you. Once reality replaces fantasy, you stop fantasizing. I don't tell people about my detransition unless I want to. I've argued with people online who immediately called me a harasser for expressing a contrary opinion, which I found telling. I also try to help people work through their thought process when they're incorrectly estimating surgical outcomes — I think I know the lines of thinking they're engaging with. Overall I'd say I'm critical of transition as a blanket solution but not opposed to other people living their lives; I just want people to be realistic about what they're doing and why.