Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Histoire complète
I have been active in detrans spaces since mid-2019, and most of what I've posted has been about the ideas I came to reject rather than a step-by-step medical diary, so I'll lay out what I can.
I was born female. I don't think I ever posted my exact ages or dates for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, or when I started hormones, so I'll leave those blank rather than guess. What I can say is that I ended up identifying as trans, going through some form of physical transition, and then detransitioning, and that by the time I was writing these comments I was firmly on the other side of that experience.
The thing that moved me most was arriving at the conclusion that gender ideology itself is a lie — that physical transition cannot do what I was told it would do, namely turn someone into the opposite sex. I wrote that a lot of people detransition for exactly that reason, and that was certainly my experience. I don't think I was ever told explicitly that I should be able to express those motivating factors only quietly; I pushed back hard against the idea that detransitioners should censor themselves because the truth might hurt someone's feelings or be considered too "political."
I spent a lot of time in these communities arguing about the underlying claims. I believed detransitioners' very existence undermines two fundamental claims of what I called gender ideology: that trans identity is immutable, and that transitioning is beneficial for anyone who identifies as or is diagnosed as trans. I wrote that people who once identified as trans but no longer do, or who regret the steps they took to physically transition, "shouldn't exist according to transactivists," and that this is why they get attacked with "the fervor of a religious zealot hunting down apostates." I also framed it as a motte-and-bailey: trans rhetoric focuses on dysphoria and the purported alleviating properties of hormones and surgeries, but sidesteps the deeper question of whether any of that means a person actually is the sex they wish to be. I was explicit that even if you accept dysphoria as an immutable condition requiring transition, "it still doesn't mean you are a man/woman." I quoted approvingly a passage about not wanting people "like me" to be "exploited based on our mental vulnerability."
On biology, I held a straightforward position: "you're either a male, a female, or have a medical intersex condition." When someone said biological sex was complicated for humans, I pushed back by asking whether it's complicated for dogs or cows. I also argued that the dominant position among trans people today is either that biological sex doesn't exist or that physical transition changes your biological sex, and that saying otherwise would get you branded truscum and banned from most trans subs — a shift I noted from twenty years ago.
I had strong feelings about the medical profession. I wrote that "the trans phenomenon has lowered my respect for the medical profession in general" and asked how doctors can swear an oath to do no harm and "go along with this insanity." I was also attentive to medical harms: I noted that nearly all FTMs seem to experience male pattern baldness to a greater extent than men, that I wasn't sure I'd ever seen an FTM on T long-term with a full head of hair, and I referenced reports of men with permanent erectile dysfunction from finasteride. I made a passing joke about insurance covering electrolysis if claimed as causing dysphoria. I also made a darker, more speculative comment about birth rates and sterilization, though I prefaced it by saying I wasn't asserting a globalist conspiracy.
I was clearly in a place of real anger and grief. I described a death as "another human life crushed under the wheels of this demented ideology" and wrote "RIP Michael/Kayla." I responded to a story I called one of "the stories you don't hear." I defended detransitioners' right to speak out, asking whether they are "only valid if they don't speak out against gender ideology." I also pushed back on the claim that misandry doesn't exist.
I don't think I ever posted about therapy, mental health diagnoses, family dynamics, relationships, sexuality before or after transition, or specific surgeries in this transcript, so I'll leave those fields empty rather than invent them. On regret, I never itemized specific changes I regretted — no explicit mention of voice, body, fertility, or particular procedures — but the overall thrust of my writing makes clear I regretted the transition path itself and the ideology I'd bought into. The intensity was high in 2019, expressed through combative, polemical posting. I don't have later data points to say whether it's improving, stable, or worsening.
As of these posts I identified as detransitioned and was openly critical of transition as it's currently framed and offered. I advocated for detransitioners to be able to speak freely about their reasons, including ideological ones, and I was broadly skeptical — though not blanket opposed — about transition for others, focusing my criticism on the medical profession, the ideological claims, and the suppression of dissent.