Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Histoire complète
I have never been particularly attached to labels — I scrutinise them so much that I don't really identify as detrans, let alone as transsexual. Hormone therapy and surgery, for me, were a way to express myself in this life I live, "albeit histrionic at times." Clinically speaking, I describe what I did as de-transitioning/transitioning out of synthetic enhancement and back to my sexed function. I am female and I went through an FTM transition and then detransitioned (FtMTF), and I use that label "Ftmtf" for myself when others want to associate with me.
I don't recall much of the trans community's language from when I was in it. Only after understanding my own experiences did I look to understand other perspectives, years after. I've said that I don't know much of what "trans lingo" means. What I do feel strongly about is the concept that "Mtftm is not MtM" and vice versa — a core idea I think mainstream trans people won't hear. It feels like a failure to me that people with fairly similar experiences to mine don't understand this. I question whether it's even a matter of needing them to understand, or whether I should just live as proof, showing them that I understand myself enough not to need their sympathy. I will always accept those who want to associate with me for who I am, Ftmtf — but I hate the option to pander to their idea of me as a failed transexual, that I am not or was never trans. That I am against; that completely neglects my self.
I've reflected a lot on why people transition. I believe the obsession over gender identity can come from trying to avoid being rejected by already established gender roles and standards — gender roles are a simple "grab & go" in most respects, and you don't need to follow them to the letter to be humanised; we can use them to adapt to situations. I've also said that generally everyone who transitions is sold on something — an idea or a promise. Speaking in religious terms, you were "devout" to something which was promised to you; you can "excommunicate" yourself, or rather re-identify with yourself. Re-identifying with your motives is fundamental to shifting the attitudes you have towards yourself. I've described medical transition as a cosmetic procedure in my mind, so it comes down to how informed a decision you make. Detransitioners often talk about the indelible impression medical transition has had on them, experiences which often lead from misinformed or uninformed choices.
I have thought a lot about dysphoria and dysmorphia as distinct terms. I've noted that historically there are records of females going through puberty expressing dysphoria/dysmorphia, and that this single observation helps make sense of an apparent trend in FtMTF transition and detransition. My issue is mostly with those who advocate affirmative cross-gender therapy for feelings of dysphoria in pubertal adolescents as an urgent matter. I've explained that "gender dysphoria" is a term used in the context of transsexualism, while "dysphoria" (a state of deep dissatisfaction, opposite of euphoria) and "dysmorphia" (a disorder preoccupied with appearance, characterised by negative intrusive thoughts over perceived flaws) are psychiatric terms, and that distinguishing them may help people interpret their thoughts and feelings better.
On the medical side, I have dealt with health anxieties after coming off HRT. I've discussed hypertension as something that can trigger feelings of anxiety, noted that an increase in blood pressure is recorded as a symptom of T therapy, and pointed out that lifestyle choices (caffeine, alcohol, smoking) increase the likelihood of these symptoms. I reassured someone that after quitting HRT their health will improve, mental and physical, and suggested that a doctor would probably suggest therapy for stress and run bloodwork. I specifically asked whether an elevation of prolactin had been noted in previous bloodwork, because I wondered whether it was a consequence of HRT itself, and I suggested that a comparative view (on/off HRT) of blood tests could verify to which degree symptoms are due to stress versus hormonal imbalances (FSH, GnRH, etc.). I've also commented on hormonal shifts after coming off testosterone — that fluctuating progesterone/estrogen in response to declining testosterone levels would be the most reasonable explanation for some symptoms, while still endorsing seeking medical advice. I've advised others to monitor levels with a prescribing GP, to manage stress, and to be proactive. I've also discussed supplements: I attributed someone's situation to maca root supplementation and recommended L-arginine and L-citrulline as vasodilators instead, mentioning that I use AAKG and L-citrulline myself to get a pump in the gym. I've recommended Vaniqa cream (about £80 in the UK) for facial hair, along with hydrators and panthenol balms to heal irritated skin first, and I've given hair-growth advice (castor oil, MSM, scalp massage, lukewarm water) for the awkward regrowth stage.
I have been through the awkward hair-growth stage myself after detransitioning, and I've talked about the frustration of facial hair removal. I've also reflected on identity beyond gender: "I am a child, an uncle, a daughter," and I found that the less I obsessed over myself, the more I was forced to consider others around me — you can find your "true identity" through striking that balance. I've said that what is wrong with us is probably to do with how we derive meaning from our experiences and how we decide to behave based on those thoughts and feelings, but that this is far from an isolated issue and not inherently wrong, just controversial.
I have been active in the detrans community, defending detrans and desisted people. I've argued that detrans people are ridiculed for the self-justification of certain trans people, motivated by concern for their own self-esteem and self-image, and that what I see is the protection of "truth" equivalent to how religion protects truth — simply dogma. I've said detrans opinions are deemed unqualified due to a perceived lack of integrity, a "non-qualifier" argument used to stigmatise the group, and that the stigma was manufactured by "detrans-phobes." I've criticised the use of absurd hypotheticals (the cat-in-the-microwave example) as unpersuasive and revealing "an undertone of absurd fear," and I've said the presence/voice of detrans and desisted people has close to the same effect on that demographic of trans people as yanking a dummy out of the mouth of a teething baby. I've also said, with a score of 26, "Nothing has convinced me that transexualism is fundamentally wrong" — I am not opposed to transition in principle, only to uninformed or pressured choices, particularly for pubertal adolescents.
I've engaged with mental-health topics in the community, distinguishing OCD intrusive thoughts from genuine identity questions, recommending people seek specialist help rather than looking to strangers to tell them who they are, and suggesting research into "ego-dystonic sexual orientation" for someone with OCD. I've also observed that someone who said they hate being judged by others is far more judgmental about themselves, to their detriment. I've noted that someone reading about another person's intrusive thoughts then developed similar intrusive thoughts themselves. On sexuality, I've observed that what one person reads as a sign they are inherently a certain gender is, to most people, an expression of sexuality — "cute girl has your mind racing." I've also reflected that I can feel disillusioned by gender trivialities yet still get caught up in tendencies to conflate personality/psyche with gender, and that I learn about myself by noticing the nuances others miss and those I can't reach.
As for my current status: I detransitioned, I don't strongly claim any label, and I consider myself female, living as a woman, using the Ftmtf label when it's useful. I don't describe an ongoing crisis — I've said "Not feeling good isn't enough to kill us" and offered that perspective to others. I have not described surgeries or hormone details in my own case beyond referring to having used hormone therapy and surgery as forms of self-expression and then returning to my sexed function. I have not described a specific date for my transition or detransition in this transcript.