Toutes les histoires

Un alter ego garçon à cinq ans, jamais d'hormones

Féminin · Désisté·e3,8 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme désistante qui a fait une transition sociale enfant et adolescente mais n'a jamais fait de transition médicale, et je ne m'identifie maintenant ni comme trans ni comme cis — juste comme une personne de sexe féminin avec une forme persistante mais plus légère de dysphorie de genre que je considère comme une maladie mentale plutôt que comme le fait d'être dans le mauvais corps. Ma dysphorie a commencé vers cinq ans, quand j'ai créé un alter ego masculin et affirmé être un garçon, bien avant de savoir ce qu'était le trans, et elle était assez sévère pour que je fantasme de couper ma poitrine naissante. J'ai désisté parce que j'ai compris que je ne pourrais jamais réellement être un homme, que la transition médicale ne valait pas les risques pour la santé et les complications sociales, et que je voulais parler librement de ma vie sans cacher mon sexe biologique. Je suis autiste et TDAH, et j'ai passé ma vie d'adulte à essayer de démêler le sexisme de l'enfance et les associations aux rôles de genre qui ont contribué à ma dysphorie, en utilisant des stratégies cognitives comme répéter dans mes rêveries le fait d'être une fille pour la réduire à un bruit de fond gérable. Je reste critique du genre et de la transition médicale, surtout pour les enfants, et je plaide pour une thérapie avant toute intervention médicale.

Histoire complète

I was born female, and my gender identity issues started very early — long before puberty. I remember wanting to be a boy for a long time before I made up a boy version of myself in my head at around age five and decided he was the real me. It became an obsession that only got stronger as I got older. I started referring to my anatomy as if it were male and tried to conform to the male social role completely, in every way I was able to — I had very little control over the clothes and toys I had, but I had always been very masculine in my behaviour and much preferred boys' clothes and toys. The female role made me deeply uncomfortable. I remember being really little, fighting with my mom to let me take off my top to go swimming, insisting I should be topless because I was a boy, and when she finally gave in, I ran around screaming in joy, "yay, I'm a boy, I'm a boy!" But my distress returned the next time I looked at my naked body and was reminded that I didn't have a penis. When I said to my mom "I'm a boy!" she said "no you're not!" — the lack of affirmation from my family my whole life, and the inaccessibility of medical transition, is what ultimately forced me to make peace with my biological reality. I was also bullied since preschool for many reasons I didn't understand. My brother used to point to my lack of athleticism as proof I wasn't a real boy, which upset me because I desperately wanted to be a real boy, so I tried to be good at sports thinking it would validate my "boyness." I was forced into things I hated and denied things boys were allowed simply because I was female. I was severely dysphoric as a child — fantasizing about cutting off my developing female chest so I could have my boy chest back at one point. When I was a kid, it felt like having been born with a female body was the cruelest thing the universe could have done to me. My dysphoria decreased significantly in my teen years; I was no longer constantly obsessed with being a boy until I was introduced to trans ideology. Things changed during puberty when boys stopped accepting me as one of them, I started to notice my body had no way of looking like a boy's again even if I cut off my breasts (which is when I stopped thinking about doing it), and I realized that if I wanted any hope of a social life, I needed to start making social compromises and stop dressing "like a boy." So I started doing some of the things I later recommended to others, which helped lessen the dysphoria, though it never fully went away. When I discovered what trans was as a teenager, I jumped on that train immediately. I socially transitioned — I was socially trans as a kid and then as a teen. I don't even regret socially transitioning; I liked being referred to as male. I never medically transitioned. The primary thing that made me detransition was realizing I didn't want to be a transman for the rest of my life — I wanted to be an actual male, but I couldn't have that, so what was the point? The initial reason I detransitioned was societal, but the reasons I stayed socially detransitioned and decided not to medically transition are more complicated: there's no real evidence for innate "gender identity," the evidence for long-term effectiveness of medical transition is very poor, I was terrified of the health risks, I couldn't get my family on board, and there are romantic/sexual prospects — I don't want to have the "I'm not actually what you think I am" discussion with potential partners. I also wanted to be able to speak freely about my past without having something to hide. I've come to accept that I'm female and always will be, but I think a part of my brain is still waiting for me to become a man. I still feel dysphoria sometimes, and it's difficult for me to conceptualize myself as a woman. It can be difficult to recognize the woman I see in the mirror as being me, and even sitting here now, it feels weird to think that's what my body is. At times I can forget my body is female and fully grown, and that I'm not going to grow anymore and become a man. I've thrown away my male alter ego, and I mostly just see myself as myself, even with my birth name, but it's difficult to recognize this person as female. Even though I know I am, and I can say it out loud, the sense of discomfort/weirdness persists. I don't like what the physical reality of being female entails, but it is, and I just have to get used to it. When I feel like being perceived as male is within my reach, it's very tempting to jump for it. I'm not neurotypical — I'm autistic, and I also have ADHD. I feel like I'm trying to rebuild my identity from the ground up as an adult. I'm considering the possibility that maybe my male identity was an autism mask that I got too attached to, but I don't know if masks can run that deep. I've been in radfem spaces. I'm in Canada, where the situation with trans issues is particularly intense. I haven't finished university but hope to be getting a job soon. I still interact with people, act, and most often dress in a very stereotypically male way — I have short hair and wear masculine clothes and no makeup — but I don't go out with the intent of being mistaken for male, and I don't lie to people about my sex. I'm regularly taken to be a teenage boy, despite being 22, unless I or someone else discloses my real name and age. I've been trying to unpack what led to my dysphoria — thinking back to the treatment I received in early childhood that differed from the way boys were treated and the perceptions I started to build up about what being a girl meant. A part of it is also the vulnerability that comes with being female. I'm trying to view being female as just a neutral fact and my body as just a body, which can make things easier to deal with, but the discomfort hasn't really left. I've also practiced altering my fantasy version of myself to look how I looked in real life — as a girl — changing nothing other than how I looked, my name, and my pronouns, so I was still in the male role but as a girl. That's how I got used to the idea of being a girl: by practising it in my head in a way that reduced my discomfort. I've also stopped calling myself a boy both in real life and in my head and practised calling myself a girl. This reduces dysphoria to background noise, to the point that it's manageable. I don't consider myself cis or trans — I am neither. I don't believe in innate, and especially not immutable, gender identity. I prefer to view dysphoria as a mental illness rather than being "in the wrong body." I now define being a woman as being an adult human female, and that's it. I consider myself a masculine person. I don't have any innate drive to "identify or be seen as a woman/girl" and I never have. I've wanted to be and be seen as boy/man for most of my life, and I'm still working on fixing that. I no longer consider myself trans. I socially transitioned but no longer consider myself to be or live as trans, so I'm desisted. I don't identify with any gender identity label. I don't have a "female gender identity" — I'm just a person who was born with a female body. I hate being called "cis" because it erases my life-long dysphoria struggle. I'd prefer my sex not be acknowledged unless it absolutely must be. I'm not straight — I experience same-sex attraction — and I never called myself a gay man. My gender dysphoria started in early childhood, before I was aware of sexuality, so internalized homophobia definitely wasn't the only factor, though I believe it was a factor for me beginning in childhood — specifically, believing no one of my sex could truly love me the way I love them. I was already severely dysphoric long before I started to feel like no girl could ever love me. I have no regrets about socially transitioning — I liked being referred to as male — but I wasted years believing I was a boy trapped in a girl's body when I could've been finding real solutions to my gender dysphoria. I don't regret not medically transitioning; I consider it the right decision. My dysphoria persists but is much milder than in childhood, and it's improving through my own coping strategies, though I haven't found a way to make it go away completely and stay away. Getting my whole brain to fully accept my sex is a different matter, but my conscious has accepted it and can deal with it. I'm generally critical of medical transition for others, especially children — I believe no minors should be transitioning under any circumstances. I think exploratory therapy should be a requirement for everyone with gender dysphoria before they are given access to medical transition. I'm not opposed to adults accessing transition if they fully understand what they're getting themselves into and have gone through therapy to work out the reasons for their dysphoria. I've done a lot of advocacy-style posting in the detrans community, arguing against the concept of "true trans," against puberty blockers for children, against the conflation of trans with LGB, and in favour of biological definitions of sex and single-sex spaces. I consider myself gender critical and have a gender abolitionist perspective.