Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui s'est identifiée comme transmasc binaire pendant quelques années, puis non binaire pendant environ deux ans, avant de revenir à une identification cis, un processus plutôt neutre pour moi parce que j'ai compris que j'étais simplement une femme. Je n'ai jamais fait de transition médicale — je n'ai jamais pris de testostérone — et je suis reconnaissante de ne pas en avoir eu l'occasion à quinze ans, quand j'en étais désespérément avide. Des ressources de neutralité corporelle destinées aux troubles alimentaires, la prise de conscience que la transition ne me rendrait pas heureuse et la compréhension de ma vision déformée des relations hétéros et de ma bisexualité refoulée m'ont toutes aidée à m'accepter. Je reste neutre à favorable envers les personnes trans en tant que militante de gauche, mais il m'arrive encore de ressentir de l'envie envers les transmascs et de regretter de ne plus faire partie de la communauté queer et trans. Je suis actuellement une femme désistante/détransitionnée qui ne sort pas avec des hommes et qui est socialement isolée.
Histoire complète
I identified as a binary trans person for a few years, then as nonbinary for about two years before I started identifying as cis again. Overall the decision to stop identifying as trans was mostly neutral for me, because by that point I'd slowly realised I was just a woman. I've identified as cis for well over a year now, though sometimes I still get a sense of envy for transmascs online.
I first discovered being transgender around age 12, and at that time I was very transmedicalist and anti-nonbinary. I identified heavily with my gender dysphoria and overall hated the trans community, though I later drifted away from that position to where I stand today: still pro-trans and pro-nonbinary. I used to have crippling gender dysphoria to the point of not being able to shower for days. I hated myself and felt a giant gaping hole in my chest because I knew I would never look how I felt I should have.
A mix of things led me to identify as a binary transmasc and later nonbinary. During that time I wasn't comfortable with stereotypical feminine things because it felt like it invalidated my identity. I also came to understand that I had a distorted view of straight relationships — when I imagined myself in a gay relationship it was easy to imagine a scenario where I was feminine and equal — and realising that helped me understand part of why I was so insistent on not being a woman. My suppression of my bisexuality stemmed from fear of misogyny in men and also not feeling like a "proper woman."
What moved me toward desisting was realising I really didn't want to take testosterone at all. The gender clinic told me they weren't accepting new patients, and while initially I was bummed out, I realised I was performing the emotions — I didn't really want to do it. I also accepted that going on T would give me side effects I didn't want, like vaginal atrophy, baldness, and a lot of hair in new places, and I knew that if I lived as a man I'd forever be hung up on my really wide hips. Transition would never bring me to a place where I'd be happy, and being "in the middle" would be worse, so I accepted myself for what I look like.
Body neutrality posts directed at people with restrictive eating disorders helped me a lot. One that stuck with me was something like "music sounds the same no matter what size you are" and "music doesn't sound better when you look a certain way, food doesn't taste better when you look a certain way." That sent me down the path of realising bodies are just bodies. Another thing that helped was understanding that no matter what my body looked like or how I was referred to, my life would still more or less be the same. I also used to stand in front of a full body mirror naked and accept that the body I saw was not going anywhere, breathing through the anxiety. When I was fifteen I was so desperate to transition I considered ordering T online and was convinced I could only be happy once I transitioned; four years later I'm grateful I never got the opportunity at that age.
I learned to separate my grievances with womanhood and misogyny from my perception of myself, which admittedly wasn't hard because I'm incredibly socially isolated. I don't date or have sex with men, though I've accepted my bisexuality. I'm a leftist and have been for years, but I'm neutral on trans identity, which is an odd position since basically everyone who agrees with me in other areas talks about anyone who isn't a trans advocate like a huge bigot. I don't feel I could consider myself a centrist. I'm not staunchly gender critical — I'm definitely very neutral on the topic — but this is the only active detrans subreddit.
I miss being queer and being part of the trans community. I see stories of people becoming staunchly gender critical after detransing, but I don't see anyone talking about feeling left out. I miss feeling like I'm reinventing myself, watching trans content and feeling connected to a group, meeting other trans people and having that click of sharing something so personal. Part of it might be for attention or wanting to be different. Transness was a social crutch — you can sustain a conversation or friendship with other trans people by just talking about trans things, and it feels like close connection because you can't talk about that stuff with non-trans people the same way. I fit in queer spaces the most. I'm aware this isn't a pro-trans subreddit but it's the most active detrans one. I think people becoming heavily against being transgender after detransitioning feel really hurt by the community and the aftermath of their gender journey.
I think a lot of the younger gay transdude population is teens hopping on a trend or falling into niche communities. As a woman, the most annoying thing to me is the constant push for penis inclusion in lesbian spaces. I also think activists never address that it's normal for people going through puberty to feel uncomfortable with their body, even to the point of distress, and it's a legitimate concern how you tell the difference between gender dysphoria and something that looks like gender dysphoria. I think society as a whole has a gender problem, but progressive spaces do too — nonbinary genders rely almost entirely on gender roles and stereotypes and reinforce what is masculine and feminine. I think femininity and masculinity are subjective and stupid, and labelling ourselves into categories based on them is stupid. I also believe there's no "right way" to be male or female and that the idea of a female experience is made up — you don't have to wear makeup or have long hair to be female. I've since realised how fun makeup and feminine fashion can be, which came from finally being comfortable enough with myself and my body to express myself that way.