Toutes les histoires

Six mois de testostérone, puis une goth qui rejette la féminité

Féminin · Détransitionné·e62
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée qui a pris de la testostérone pendant six mois, est sans depuis deux ans et n'a jamais fait de transition sociale. J'ai pris de la T à cause de l'AAP, d'un TOC sexuel, de l'objectification de la féminité et du fait de voir la féminité comme paralysante. Je m'identifie maintenant comme une femme goth de toujours, visiblement queer, qui rejette la féminité comme une socialisation patriarcale plutôt que de l'accepter comme faisant partie du fait d'être une femme. Je suis frustrée que la plupart des femmes détransitionnées reviennent à la féminité, ce que je vois comme un échec à déconstruire pleinement le binarisme de genre. Je n'ai signalé ni idées suicidaires ni automutilation ; ma détresse s'exprime comme une frustration politique et philosophique plutôt que comme une crise de santé mentale.

Histoire complète

I joined detrans after lurking for years, and I've been off testosterone for two years now. I was on T for about six months. I never socially transitioned, and I've always been visibly queer. I went on T because of AAP (autoandrophilia), because of how femaleness gets objectified, and because I saw femininity as something crippling. For me the dysphoria has always been rooted in the political rather than the purely bodily. It is really hard to come to terms with being treated as a woman in society when we live in such a male-supremacist world. Being objectified sucks, being seen as sexual is scary. There is enough solidarity and political theory out there for me to help myself when I have a bout of dysphoria stemming from that. It is also hard but possible when I struggle with AAP, which is almost daily, because I have sexual OCD. Again, enough sources for me to deal with this. What I cannot come to terms with is femininity — mine, other people's, anyone's. While the contents of femininity are pretty fifty-fifty between helpful and harmful, it does not matter, because all one hundred percent of it normalizes the exploitation of women. Money and time spent on grooming line men's pockets; beauty standards are driving us insane on a large scale; impractical clothing and limiting shoes are the obvious ones. And then there are things like motherhood, self-sacrifice, intuition, kindness that people define femininity as. I see it as pure socialization, not something inherent. We as women are socialized that way to be useful to men and to uphold capitalism. I have done feminine things before — I still put on eyeliner some days — but it has never been tied to me accepting myself as a woman. I just cannot understand how, for so many detransitioned women, putting femininity back on is what accepting being a woman means. It makes me question whether some people's transitions were more about rejecting femininity rather than discomfort with femaleness, because they view the two as interchangeable. I would much rather be outside of the norm — pain one — than force myself into femininity — pain two. It is almost a dignity thing for me, though I would not make it a dignity thing when analyzing other people, so what is left is confusion. I find fashion and style fun, but I cannot participate in aesthetics culture when it is so obviously pro-capitalist, in the same way that we understand why someone's interest in looks might give them an eating disorder but obviously want them to heal out of it. I have been a lifelong goth, thirty years old, and I love goth for being androgynous, rebellious, and anti-consumerist. I feel like a lot of politically inclined trans people see transition similarly — as a rejection of gender norms — but of course it has been co-opted and become the opposite, the same way gothic style has today. I wonder why the analysis of gender norms for detrans people seems to stop at 'transitioning reaffirms them' and where questioning femininity went. Back in the day it was more normal to have a tomboy phase, yes, but also to have a critical outlook even upon returning to a more feminine mode of living. I have never met a detrans man before, and it is much rarer to see them online or here, so I cannot comment anecdotally on whether men return to extreme masculinity upon detransitioning. When someone called me ill and said they would leave, I told them I thought that was unfair. In my own life I am not feeling an increased pressure to be internally feminine as a woman — looks-wise, yes, daily. The tradwife stuff is unreal to me. In the place I am thinking of, traditional women are expected to be the strong ones, the rocks, and tradwife stuff is seen as frivolous Western things; there, androgyny still seems cool, just under a different name — nonbinary. It felt nice in that conversation not to be seen as crazy.