Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis un homme gay détransitionné qui a vécu en femme trans pendant environ 4,5 ans sous œstrogènes (sans jamais bloquer la testostérone), arrêté fin 2021, et qui s'accepte maintenant comme homme tout en gardant le plus souvent une présentation féminine et androgyne. La détransition m'a apporté des progrès rapides en amour de soi et en spiritualité, mais j'ai lutté contre la solitude, les rencontres, l'inconfort face aux caractéristiques masculines de mon corps, et en septembre 2022 j'ai écrit que je voudrais être mort et que la vraie transformation était plus dure que la transition. Je fais remonter ma transition aux filières de la justice sociale, à l'admiration pour l'assurance des femmes trans, au harcèlement d'enfance, à des violences psychologiques et à une relation compliquée avec ma mère, et la pratique spirituelle et le fait d'entendre Blaire White ont été déterminants pour détransitionner. Je suis critique de la façon dont la transition est promue, des cadres identitaires non binaires et des cliniques du genre, et je défends la sensibilisation à la détransition en milieu clinique. Je ne regrette pas d'avoir détransitionné et je me définis actuellement comme un homme, en considérant le genre lui-même comme irréel.
Histoire complète
I was born male and I'm gay. Looking back, I can see that around five years before I started writing about this, I began moving toward transition partly because I admired the beauty and confidence of trans women — I didn't like how I looked, I had problems with dating and meeting people, and I created the connection that it would be easier to find love if I transitioned. My pipeline, as I've come to call it, was the classic social justice one.
I was on HRT for about 4.5 years — estrogen, but I never took an anti-androgen to block testosterone. I had one antiandrogen injection early on alongside my estrogen and felt like I was dying for a month with physical weakness, tiredness, nausea, lowered appetite and lowered mood, so I never took one again. I halved my dosage in November 2021 and quit a few weeks later. Around two months into detransitioning I was already saying the progress I'd made in myself, especially spiritually, was extraordinary — my love and respect for myself had gone up more in eight weeks than in the previous two years on transition. Three months off hormones I still felt good; in month three off E I started getting headaches, weakness and lowered mood, which a doctor said could be a normal effect of the hormone change. I had my first blood test since stopping estrogen in early April 2022. I haven't noticed many physical changes yet — I still pass as a guy or a girl depending on whether I'm en femme or have my hair tied up with no makeup.
I don't think I ever blocked testosterone, and I experienced menopause-like symptoms such as hot flashes and brain fog at one point, but the main issue affecting my quality of life was OCD-like symptomatology — I don't have an OCD diagnosis — obsessing over identity and the meaning of words and concepts.
A few things moved me toward detransition. Hearing Blaire White say she accepts she is male and simply chooses to live by female roles broke the spell for me — I realized I was having a hard time accepting nature. Becoming a Christian and learning about Gnosticism, Hinduism, Buddhism and other mystical traditions in my last year of transition probably subconsciously led me to realize I wasn't being true to myself; I'd been an atheist raised in secular schools with non-religious parents and never realized the importance of the connection to self. Transition had taken away my spiritual connection — I'd started admiring the physical rather than my inner being — and after five years I had lost most of my spiritual connection to myself. I also came to see that trans identity often becomes a characteristic of creative, intellectual and unique people, and that creative people are limited by being tethered to a fixed concept of who they are.
Two months into detransitioning I was beginning to think gender isn't real, only sex, and that gender expression is a mixture of nature and nurture. I don't identify with gender as a concept — both 'man' and 'woman' seem weird to me, and I won't describe myself as a man, I'm just me, though if others do that's fine. I don't mention pronouns; if somebody asks I reiterate that I'm male and tell them to use what comes natural. I was scared to come out to family because I felt like I'd deceived the people I love into a false map of reality. My gender clinician was visibly panicked as we discussed detransition and didn't listen because he was too set on the affirmative-treatment lens. From an NHS consultation I got the impression they don't offer surgery or support for detransitioners beyond checking hormones return to normal.
I told my mum I'd quit hormones and felt better just being me. She asked if I was having the operation to get my 'bits off' and when I said no she said, 'I would get bits off but that's just me.' That was weird, and it fit a pattern — she used to joke she was going to cut my penis off, not in a sexual way, in a really weird jokey way; the psychology is probably that she only had one kid and wanted a girl. Those comments hit differently now that we get on well. I was heavily bullied for several years through childhood, and I relate to childhood psychological abuse — not from my parents — mixed with not being accepted by my parents. I live alone, near my parents.
I still present en femme most of the time — about 80% of the time I go out — as a creative choice; I love fashion, makeup and the transformation of it. I've started creating more outfits that lean masculine because I spent over four years caring too much about making every outfit look at least mostly feminine. I've struggled with being comfortable with visible sexual characteristics — I bought jeans, felt uncomfortable about the bulge, briefly considered tucking, then changed into something that covered it, and I'm working on unpacking why. I'm also working on biceps and losing stomach fat since quitting E. I don't know if I ever want to pass as a man or if I'm fine looking androgynous; reading about gay men through history helped me see there are many ways to be male.
Mentally I've had a hard time. In September 2022 I wrote that I didn't wanna do this anymore, that I wished I was dead, that the real transformation was 10x harder than transitioning, that I'd relied on men too much for my validation, that I had no real friends, that 95% of my contact with the world was through Reddit, and that I hated the self-created cell I'd built in my mind. I clarified I didn't feel detransition was the wrong choice — it's just hard to do the hard things to tackle my underlying issues and live with purpose rather than focused on identity. I've also written about feeling like I just don't fit in in this world, that I'm not lonely but still alone, and about love as a 'high femme' male feeling impossible — that gay men don't see me beyond a fantasy and straight guys only want to hit it and quit it, leaving me essentially involuntarily celibate, with my soul sad. I'm a recovering sex addict who spent two-thirds of my life watching high-speed porn, and I don't have autogynephilia. I'm in my mid-20s, live in the UK up North, and I'm starting a new eco-friendly business — transition had dulled my creativity and passion for entrepreneurship for years.
I don't regret detransitioning. I love how I look now — my hips still look sexy because I am sexy, and I realize I was refining my style and getting better at makeup rather than estrogen making me like my face. I've become quite critical of how transition is promoted: I've written about the deification of trans people in LGBT spaces, about shame-based transitioning, about the gender clinic pushing me toward a non-binary identity, and about how I think gender is a spectrum rather than a binary. I've advocated for clinicians to learn about detransition, told a young person to grow up rather than delay adulthood focusing on 'being trans', and I refuse to answer when people ask my pronouns, telling them it's an insulting question. I believe people's feeling of not being enough can be faced without transition, and that transitioning out of that fear was, for me, a recipe for disaster.