Toutes les histoires

La transition a fonctionné, et pourtant ce n'est pas une identité

Masculin · Détransitionné·ePremière dysphorie 3 → Transition 27243
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis né homme et j'ai transitionné médicalement (MtF) vers 2019 après une dysphorie de genre depuis toujours remontant à l'âge de 3-4 ans ; je vis en mode furtif comme une femme, je suis en couple avec un copain, et je dis que la transition a très bien fonctionné pour moi médicalement. J'ai fait une introspection approfondie et conclu que mon souhait profond est d'être une femme, lié à un idéal de soi de « femme et mère », et je ne m'identifie plus comme trans ni même comme une femme — « Trans n'est pas mon identité ». J'ai pensé à détransitionner mais je dis que le THS n'est pas optionnel pour moi et qu'une détransition légale/sociale bouleverserait ma vie. Je suis un commentateur très actif, souvent à contre-courant, sur r/detrans, critique de l'idéologie du genre et du mouvement trans actuel tout en défendant que la transition aide réellement certaines personnes dysphoriques. Ma dysphorie s'est nettement améliorée grâce aux hormones, à l'entraînement vocal, à la thérapie, au travail sur moi-même et à ma relation.

Histoire complète

I was born male and I have had what I call gender dysphoria for as long as I can remember — since around age three or four. For years I coped by building a mask of what I thought I should be: I tried to be 'A Man,' worked out, tried to make friends, and by my own admission was 'quite frankly a bigoted pos.' I kept that up until I couldn't take it anymore and went full-on trans 'woman,' adopting the gender-ideology framework — 'misgendering people bad, trans women could be considered females,' etc. I felt better, but I was still, in my words, 'coping with reality.' I transitioned medically (MtF) about four years before October 2023, so roughly 2019. I've been on estrogen and testosterone suppression, and I've done extensive voice training — I reached the voice I wanted a few years ago and stopped, though I sometimes think about pushing it further. I've also had facial feminization work in mind; as of April 2023 I had an FFS consultation/approach involving forehead reconstruction and a hair transplant planned, though I later told someone else I'd reconsidered FFS entirely and didn't think I'd ever go for it even if free. I live stealth — everyone around me perceives me as female, and I say I'm 'perceived as female by society.' I'm 5'3. I've had an endocrinologist, GPs, and a psychiatrist involved in my care. I don't have a female puberty and I can't bear children; I've said adoption would be 'the moral choice' if my partner and I wanted kids. On causes: I've done enormous soul searching on why I've wanted to 'be a girl' since childhood. My current conclusion is that I don't care about being a woman socially — I just want to be female, which I describe as an internal ideal-self experience, analogous to sexuality but inward rather than outward. I've said my ideal self has always been 'a wife and a mother,' and I sometimes wonder whether my dysphoria stems from that — 'do I dislike the male body because it's not one a man who wants a wife would like?' — or from 'weird neo-natal development,' calling it 'a coin toss for me.' I've speculated that dysphoria could be nature, nurture, genes, or a combination, and I've said twin studies suggest a bit of both for homosexuality and transsexuality. I've also noted that while transitioned I 'automatically gravitated towards the gender ideology' and started putting feelings on pronouns, names, and having a 'perfect IG body,' but introspection helped me find the root of those feelings. I've said transition has worked very well for me on the medical side — 'it has overall as well, but only the medical side really mattered to me.' I've said I couldn't have the life I have without transition, and that being only attracted to straight men would make it impossible if I didn't look like a woman. I've described myself as 'functionally a(n infertile) woman.' I've said I used to hyperfixate on features not being feminine enough and not having had a female childhood, but I've grown and realized my idea of a female body was 'really just insecure and frankly sexist.' I now list benefits of my situation: no need for protection in serious relationships, no PMS or pregnancy scares, no menopause, and a better understanding of male psychology and anatomy. I have a partner — 'the love of my life,' a boyfriend — and I've said finding him was 'a big shortcut' and 'sort of a place where I belong.' I've said he was not open to dating a male at first but fell in love with me before I told him, and that he's the only person who knows everything about me. I've said I'm stealth and that's how our relationship is seen. I've said I'm strictly attracted to males and could have sex with women but find same-sex intimacy 'unaesthetic,' and I've said I've been attracted to a passing FtM. I've said I've grown out of internalized homophobia and self-hatred. I've discussed therapy: I listened to my therapist and worked on not caring about what others think, and I've said I'm 'much further' along in that process — I no longer feel I need makeup or to dress up to go out, which has improved my life. I've recommended therapy repeatedly to others and said I'd like to be a mental health specialist but it would take too long. I've said I have a big dislike/fear of doctors. I have schizophrenic relatives, which I cited when warning against messing with antipsychotics. I've been an active, often contrarian voice in r/detrans and related debates. I've argued that SRS and HRT do alleviate dysphoria for many people, that detransitioners are 'real valid people,' and that lying about transition's harms doesn't help. I've argued against the idea that transition is worse than suicide. I've defended puberty blockers' long use in precocious puberty. I've argued that a lot of FtM dysphoria is society's sexualization of women mistaken for gender dysphoria, while insisting there's no 'fake' GD. I've advocated for better-trained gender therapists, prompt appointments, and exploratory therapy before medical steps, and for gender abolition done constructively. I've said I 'hate the current trans movement' and that gender ideology 'has gotten way out of hand.' I've been critical of /tttt/ on 4chan and cut back on it myself. I've given detailed dating advice to other trans women, including advising non-disclosure until emotional investment — a position that drew significant backlash. I've also argued against infant circumcision, calling it involuntary genital mutilation, and described myself as both pro-life (life begins at conception) and pro-choice (against forcing pregnancy). I don't identify as trans as an identity — I've said 'Trans isn't my identity' and 'I don't feel like a woman, I feel like me.' I've said I don't know if I identify with the trans label 'especially these days.' I've said I don't identify as a woman either — 'I don't either' — but I live and am perceived as one. I've said I've considered detransitioning: 'I've thought about that a lot, but I know that not being on HRT is not an option for me, and legally/socially detransitioning would probably create a lot of issues in my life.' I've said I tried relationships where I identified as a man and it didn't bother me, but I don't know how I'd feel if truly perceived as a regular man. Overall I'd describe myself as a detransitioned-leaning but currently transitioned, stealth MtF person who is skeptical of both trans ideology and gender-critical absolutism, in a stable relationship, with dysphoria much improved through medical transition, therapy, and self-acceptance.