Toutes les histoires

Anonyme sur r/detrans : défendre que la dysphorie vient de la société, pas des corps

Féminin · Détransitionné·e280
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée ou critique du genre qui passe beaucoup de temps sur r/detrans à écrire pour dissuader les personnes qui se questionnent ou n'ont pas encore transitionné de faire une transition médicale, soutenant que la dysphorie est généralement une réponse à des attentes sociales sexistes plutôt qu'à un corps qui ne correspondrait pas. Je conteste régulièrement la statistique « <1 % de regret » en pointant les 36 % de perdus de vue de la cohorte d'Amsterdam, et je décourage activement les gens de commencer la testostérone ou la chirurgie. Je n'ai pas partagé dans ces messages de détails sur ma propre chronologie de transition, mon parcours médical ou mes chirurgies. Mon identité actuelle est celle d'une femme critique de la transition comme solution, et je vois mon plaidoyer comme une aide pour que d'autres évitent ce dans quoi j'ai été « induite en erreur ». Je n'ai décrit dans ce matériel aucune idée suicidaire, automutilation ni tentative de suicide.

Histoire complète

I have spent a lot of time in this community writing the same message to people who are questioning or about to start hormones, because I believe the framing matters. My core message, which I repeat almost verbatim, is: 'You are not struggling with being a woman. You are struggling with how the world treats your female body. The shame, the objectification, the pressure to perform a role you never chose.' I lay out how society tells women to be vulnerable, seek support, and express sensitivity, while telling men to be tough, show ambition, and take charge, and then I ask people to consider whether they truly want to be a man or are trying to escape what being a woman has come to mean in their life. I insist it is not the body that is hated but the expectations and assumptions forced onto it. I have written this for both directions — people identifying as trans men and people identifying as trans women — adapting the same structure to whichever body and social role they describe. In one reply to a person assigned female at birth who was considering testosterone, I warned that 'taking testosterone and pursuing your transition will only hurt you both in the short term and long, as you'll just be digging further down the rabbit hole.' I also told them that even being able to say 'I know what this is' is a big step, that they are not broken and not alone, and that getting comfortable in your body after internalising those messages takes time. I have also pushed back against the widely cited 'under 1% regret rate.' I pointed out that people are confusing regret with detransition, and that the detransition rate is actually unknown. I cited the Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015), which surveyed 6,793 people, and quoted its finding that only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret — noting that this is where the infamous figure comes from. Crucially, I also quoted the study's own admission of massive loss to follow-up: 'a large group (36%) did not return to our clinic after several years of treatment. Therefore, we could have missed some information on, for example, gonadectomies performed at other centers or people with regret.' Beyond the scripted message, I have written more personal appeals. I told one person: 'You don't hate yourself. You hate what you've been told you have to be. Gender dysphoria isn't proof that you were born wrong. It's a response to being forced into narrow roles and labels that never fit.' I argued that they internalised those expectations and made them their identity because no one gave them space to ask why they felt that way, and that what they need is care that helps them understand the pain rather than cover it with a new label. I also wrote to someone who had already transitioned: 'Transition didn't fix anything because it wasn't the real issue. The issue was how deeply you felt you had to be someone else to be accepted or happy. You're not broken. You were misled.' I encouraged self-expression without medical change — wearing makeup, dresses, or high heels if they want, because that is self-expression, not proof you were meant to change your body. I also posted a thread about doctors being afraid of being 'cancelled' for being gender critical, which I framed as 'a sad and unfortunate reality of our world.' I have described myself as someone who leaves 'the following text that I always leave on such posts,' indicating this is a recurring form of advocacy for me. In one reply I acknowledged that simply understanding the dynamics intellectually doesn't make everything feel okay, and that it is fine that it still feels hard.