Toutes les histoires

Une voix modérée dans les espaces de débat, puis les commentaires ont disparu

Masculin · Détransitionné·e38
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une personne détransitionnée qui a passé 2019-2020 dans des espaces de débat détrans et trans, en tenant le rôle d'une voix modérée et centrée sur les preuves, qui s'opposait aux affirmations absolutistes des deux camps tout en défendant la sécurité du traitement hormonal avec des données. J'étais d'accord que la transition devrait être un dernier recours après une thérapie approfondie, mais je m'opposais fermement aux détransitionneurs qui affirment que la transition est mauvaise pour tout le monde, en avertissant que de tels discours pouvaient coûter des vies. J'ai donné des conseils pratiques sur l'épilation électrique, la récupération de la fertilité après l'arrêt de la testostérone, et l'origine du mot « cis ». Mon identité actuelle et les détails de ma propre chronologie de transition et de détransition ne sont pas décrits dans ces commentaires.

Histoire complète

I came to the detrans community in early 2019 already somewhat engaged in debates about transition, and my earliest comments show me arguing with people I saw as making bad arguments — I called out a "false dichotomy" and noted that we were in an echo chamber, while insisting I was "saddened by your misfortune" rather than challenged. I positioned myself as someone seeking common ground between detransitioners and what I called the "trutrans" lobby, and I repeatedly tried to broker dialogue: I invited someone to start a new topic or DM me, and I said I was glad to see people considering information from multiple sources. My views on transition were nuanced and I defended both sides against extremes. I agreed that "transition should be a last resort after extensive exploratory therapy into why someone feels dysphoric," but I was equally appalled by what I called the detrans mindset that says "I was just walking down the street and the trans wave engulfed me" and then wants to outlaw treatment. I warned, in strong terms, that detransitioners who claim transition "is not right for anybody" could push policy that leads to suicides among people for whom transition is genuinely needed, writing that I hoped "the shame of that being on your conscience will be enough to temper your absolutist tirades." I engaged heavily with medical and scientific claims, generally defending the safety of hormone therapy against what I saw as overstated risks. I pushed back on claims that estrogen carries "huge health risks" for strokes, citing attributable risk figures and pointing out that men have higher stroke mortality than women up to age 85. When someone cited a source, I checked it: "search for the word 'transgender' — find the word is not in the document — conclusion, you're spewing nonsense." When they later provided real data, I thanked them but still argued they had "overstated your case," quoting studies showing the direct evidence is "sparse and inconsistent" and that there was "no increase in VTE among transgender women receiving other forms of estrogen." I also asked for sources on the "androgens in utero" rat theory and thanked someone when they provided it. On practical matters I gave direct advice: I corrected someone that "electrolysis kills the hair follicle — not 'puts them to sleep'," and I told someone coming off testosterone that "gaining back testosterone is likely (near certain?), but producing viable gametes — YMMV. The shorter amount of time, the better." I made a wry comment about electrolysis providers: "I suspect they care about people who have more hair than they want — and money in their pockets." I also explained the etymology of "cis" as a contrast to "trans" replacing the older "trans vs normal" framing. I was clearly read as being on the trans side of these debates — one person thanked me for "thinking about us." My last comments in 2020 were brief: one a one-word reply ("Nancy"), and one asking a commenter to clarify whether they thought abuse is a sign someone would want to transition or detransition. Throughout, I saw myself as a moderating, evidence-seeking voice pushing back against absolutism on both sides.