Toutes les histoires

Des binders à la poubelle — des parents qui ont dit non

Féminin · Désisté·e1,1 k
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis née femme, je me suis identifiée comme trans pendant un temps et j'ai porté des binders, mais je n'ai jamais commencé d'hormones — mes parents m'en ont empêchée, et je leur en suis aujourd'hui reconnaissante. J'ai jeté mes binders en juillet 2024 comme geste symbolique et je m'identifie maintenant comme une femme détransitionnée/désistante. Je suis active dans les espaces detrans, critique des dynamiques fétichistes et narcissiques du discours en ligne sur le genre, et je conseille à ceux qui doutent de la transition de ne pas aller jusqu'au bout et d'impliquer un médecin. Je ne signale aucun diagnostic de santé mentale précis, ni idées suicidaires ni automutilation dans ces messages.

Histoire complète

I was born female. I identified as trans for a while and socially presented in a masculine way — I owned binders and a lot of what I called my "man shirts," though most of those were just unisex band tees that I still wear because I like them. I never wore my binders in well over a year before I finally decided to throw them away on July 28, 2024, and even then I held onto them for a while first. I posted about that on the detrans board, asking if anyone else holds onto things like that even though they doubt they'd ever use them again — it got a lot of support. I never started hormones. In an August 24, 2024 comment I wrote that a post "makes me want to make me thank my parents for not letting me start hormones oh my god," which tells me my parents intervened and blocked me from medically transitioning. I'm grateful for that now. I've also advised other people in similar spots: "You seem similar to me, if you are doubting it I wouldn't go through with it," and I repeatedly urge people to talk to a doctor before making hormone decisions — "I know that when dealing with hormones better safe than sorry." On the identity question generally, I don't buy the framing of innate gender feeling: "I personally don't believe there is a right way to 'feel like a girl', you just are. I also don't think that anyone feels normal, even people who we may perceive as normal." I've also said there's "so much more to women than 'skirt go spinny'" — I'm frustrated by reductionist or fetishistic framings of womanhood and transness. I'm active in detrans and gender-critical adjacent spaces online and I comment a lot. I've expressed disgust at what I see as fetish content in trans and detrans spaces — I mentioned looking up "detrans on Tumblr" and finding "weird fetish posts saying that they will send nudes to a transphobe if they get 100 notes," saying "these people need help wtf." I've criticized posts that claim "why transwomen are better" and are "just weird sexual shit," telling those posters to "just say you're a raging narcissist and move on." I've said "Alot of them are pornsick" when discussing certain trans women's behavior online. I also believe "sexuality is inherently exclusive" and I've pushed back on people who I feel are "downplaying other peoples problems and making it about them instead." I'm critical of certain trans activism's implications: I've questioned where trans women expect "these ovaries" to come from, noting women who have uteruses removed usually keep their ovaries because "they are part of the endocrine system in your body." I've also raised concerns that artificial wombs could worsen organ trade and human trafficking. On pronouns I take a practical line: "pronouns are for OTHER people to refer to you. They are going off of how they are interpreting what they're seeing. It's generally not malicious." I've dealt with some body dissatisfaction — in August 2024 someone asked about breasts and I advised getting a good bra, noting they're "still growing since you're 15" and that "everyones breasts look different anyways," which suggests I was around 15 at that point and had some concern about my own chest. I've also said "SAME" in solidarity with someone else's experience there. I've responded empathetically to others in the community — "ugh me too OP im right there with you," "real as hell, sending hugs," and I said I felt bad for someone whose "projection here is INSANE." I don't describe specific trauma, diagnoses, or mental health conditions in these posts. What comes through is a mix of relief at not having medically transitioned, ongoing discomfort with fetishistic and narcissistic dynamics I see in online gender discourse, and a fairly firm critical stance toward certain aspects of trans activism, while still being supportive and kind to individuals who are struggling.