Toutes les histoires

Argumenter contre la transition sans révéler la sienne

Féminin · Détransitionné·e316
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme qui a détransitionné ou qui est critique du genre ; je passe l'essentiel de mon temps sur Reddit à encourager les hommes efféminés et les femmes masculines à ne pas transitionner, et à critiquer l'identification non binaire et l'effet du mouvement trans actuel sur le féminisme. Je soutiens constamment que le sexe est fixe et observable, que les stéréotypes de genre sont le vrai problème, et que les gens devraient être libres d'être non conformes au genre sans changer de sexe. Je n'ai pas partagé publiquement les détails de ma propre transition médicale dans ces commentaires. Je crois que le mouvement trans a nui au féminisme et rigidifié les rôles de genre. Je reste bienveillante et aimable envers les gens tout en les détournant de la transition.

Histoire complète

I have been active in detrans and gender-critical spaces on Reddit since at least May 2023, and almost everything I post is aimed at other people questioning their gender — mostly feminine males and masculine females. I don't talk much about my own medical history publicly, but the way I write makes clear where I stand and what I've come to believe. I tell feminine men directly that they can simply be feminine men: "There is ABSOLUTELY nothing wrong with being a feminine man. You don't have to be trans if you don't want to be." I've reassured people that it's becoming more socially acceptable to be a femme man, and I've told someone outright, "You could just be a feminine male. You don't have to adhere to society's standards of what a man is." When I see masculine women, I tell them they're attractive and that they should ignore stereotypes: "Masculine women exist and they are fucking hot in my opinion. You have feminity no matter what because you are female. Please don't pay any attention to stereotypes." A lot of my frustration is directed at how rigid gender boxes have become. I wrote a longer comment in January 2024 that I clearly feel strongly about: "I really wish the feminist movement of the early 80s stuck. You know the one where nobody cared if you as a female wore men's clothes and were masculine? The one where gender roles were obliterated (instead of the rigid boxes we have now)... That was the whole starting point was so that you COULD be female and masculine, or male and feminine. But you were the sex you were observed at birth. The trans movement has done so much harm to feminism and trying to move past gender stereotypes. The whole they/them pronouns did nothing but hurt the movement honestly." I've repeated the same point about 70s and 80s feminism — that the whole fight was about being able to wear whatever you wanted regardless of sex, and now everyone is "boxed up" into narrow categories. I'm skeptical of how people identify, especially non-binary identification. I posted in July 2024: "Every single female person that I've met that that says they are non binary wears make up, dresses in women's clothes, has women's hair styles, basically presents as woman. Like what? How are you a non binary person when every aspect of you present as a stereotypical woman?" I've also commented bluntly on passing — noting that I clocked someone as a woman "right away. Facial hair and all," and arguing that humans have a biological instinct for detecting sex, even if people are often just being polite when they say someone passes. I believe sex is fixed and observable. I've told someone, "Yes because your a woman. Full stop. No matter what you 'look like' you'll always look like one because you are one." When I see people I think are making a mistake, I feel genuine sadness — I've written "That's sad" and "This is exactly how I feel. It's so hard to watch." I've also named what I see as the root issue behind some transitions in a single word: "Misogyny." I don't publicly detail my own transition or detransition timeline, surgeries, or mental health history in these comments, so I keep that private. What I do put out there is consistent: I want people to stay their natal sex, reject stereotypes, and not medicalize discomfort with gender roles. I'm supportive when I think someone looks good, but my core advocacy is劝 people away from transition and back toward accepting sex-based reality.