Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis un homme détransitionné/désistant — plus exactement qui n'a jamais transitionné — né homme de parents indiens en Amérique, qui a rejoint r/detrans et r/askAGP fin 2024 à cause d'une légère dysphorie de genre et de fantasmes de travestissement, et qui en est venu à comprendre que je ne suis ni trans ni AGP mais un homme non conforme à l'aise, qui se sent intérieurement non binaire. J'ai un trouble bipolaire de type 2, un TOC, un TPOC et probablement un TSPT, issus d'un foyer volatil, parfois physiquement violent, avec des parents tantôt chauds tantôt froids dans un mariage arrangé. Je n'ai jamais pris d'hormones ni eu aucune intervention médicale de genre, et je n'ai aucun antécédent déclaré d'automutilation ou de tentative de suicide. J'envisage maintenant ma dysphorie à travers le prisme de la spiritualité hindoue de mes ancêtres, en voyant l'idéologie moderne du genre comme un symptôme de faillite spirituelle, tout en sympathisant avec les détransitionneurs et en soutenant les droits civiques des personnes trans. Je reste à l'aise de me présenter de façon androgyne et en « boymoding », et je n'ai pas entièrement tranché si je m'identifie comme cishet ou non binaire.
Histoire complète
I was born in America to parents from India, and I was born male. I'm a millennial, and I only relatively recently — in the past few years — started questioning my gender identity. I have never transitioned, taken hormones, or had any medical interventions related to gender.
I joined r/detrans and r/askAGP around late 2024 because I was experiencing mild gender dysphoria and fantasies about wearing loose, gender-neutral, feminine-leaning clothing. Over the course of participating, I came to realize I am neither trans nor AGP — I'm a comfortably nonconforming man, though internally I 'feel' nonbinary. I'd be happy to pass as androgynous or a 'feminine man' while still being able to 'boymode.' I describe myself as fairly certain I'm either cishet or nonbinary, and at one point said I was 'trending towards nbace/nbase.'
Some concrete details about my appearance and how I present: during the COVID quarantines I lost a lot of weight, and my facial features started looking more like my mom's. I wear my hair long, very long and voluminous, and more femininely. When I'm cleanly shaven my face reads more feminine. Once at the grocery store with a mask on, people called me 'ma'am.' My mom, who is an orthodox Hindu, keeps asking me 'are you trying to be a woman?' and I tell her I'm literally not trying anything — that she should see me as someone who cares so little about gender norms that I'm accidentally androgynous. I like it this way. I once told a white friend who I think is bi that I 'sorta look like an indian woman with a beard.'
I had some profound experiences where I remembered my earliest memories as an amorphous overweight blob in the void of my grandma's bony lap while she and my grandfather played Tamil and Sanskrit hymns. I realized that is my base identity and that I'm nonbinary, forcing myself to be a cis male. But I also reasoned that even if I attempted to become a woman I'd be forcing myself just as much as I'm presently forcing myself to be a cis male, which at least I'm already used to and fit in as — it sounds like a lot of effort to change for not much reward. The androgynous male thing kinda works too.
I have bipolar 2 disorder, OCD, and OCPD. I only relatively recently started considering gender dysphoria a possible trigger for both my depressive episodes and — to a much lesser extent — my hypomanic episodes. I have no stated history of self-harm or suicide attempts.
My family background: my parents had an arranged marriage and both of them were 'the men of the house.' They were really hot and cold to each other, me, and my brother — lots of anger, some physical violence. It was enough to give me PTSD, I think, and they still had severe anger issues through my adolescence and early adulthood. I said I would have been better off without a dad who felt so emasculated in front of my mom.
I'm a practicing Hindu and I'm very grounded in the religion of my ancestors. I've said that this turned me nonbinary but more of a 'perceiving light-mind blob in the void' kind, not the gender-fluid kind. I've quoted at length from the Tamil Vedas (Thiruvaimozhi), the Tirumantiram, the Rigveda, and Sanskrit concepts like bhava and avatār. I've discussed the ancient Indian hijra/'ali' third-gender tradition and the Tamil poetry describing a soul that is 'neither male nor female.' I believe modern gender ideology is a symptom of rampant spiritual bankruptcy, and that gender theory is a symptom of spiritual unwellness. I've said that in Hinduism, fully understanding scripture causes ego death, after which you rebuild your ego with a mix of preferred legendary figures — and that 'kinning' isn't much different from Sanskrit 'bhava.' I've also said I genuinely believe everyone's identity is artificially contrived, beyond gender.
On transition and detransition generally: I've said I genuinely believe there are plenty of MtFs who are able to cure their gender dysphoria and live productive, healthy lives, which is what we should hope for. I've argued that if suicide rates among the gender-dysphoric go down and detransitioners are able to lead meaningful, happy, healthy lives, then there is a net social benefit to transition becoming more accepted. I've said detransitioning as a phenomenon alone should give pause even if there's no suicide, and that I'm guessing not many people are looking into suicide rates of detransitioners. I've said I have no stake in this personally. I've also said at one point that I joined this sub and askAGP (which I later left) because I realized I have mild gender dysphoria and some fantasies of crossdressing.
I've expressed a range of provocative opinions: that redpillers are 'closet chasers,' that TERFs pull MtFs out of the AGP fantasy like ruining suspense of disbelief, that lesbianism is an ideological threat to the patriarchy and an intentional deep-state hit, that I'm a man with gender dysphoria who supports lesbian separatism, that internalized misogyny is a nonsensical term, and various conspiracy-adjacent takes (Palantir honeypots, CIA-run chan boards, Thiel/Vance). I've said I'm anti-caste and that the exact opposite of the caste system is 'marxist lesbian separatism.' I've joked that I want to date a cis lesbian girl ('chat i can fix her'). I've said I am not into men. I've advocated for people generally: 'you don't have to force yourself into any definition... just don't be an asshole.' I've also said 'at this point i just tell trans folk "we agree on civil rights, not much else".'
I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond posting and commenting.