Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme détransitionnée : née femme, j'ai fait une transition sociale et pris de la testostérone pendant environ un an, de 18 à 19 ans, puis j'ai arrêté d'un coup, et je suis détransitionnée depuis plus de deux ans. Je regrette tout, y compris la transition sociale, et ce que je pleure le plus, c'est le changement durable de ma voix, qui a baissé sous T et reste rauque, instable et source de dysphorie, bien que je sois genrée au féminin au quotidien. Tous mes effets secondaires physiques de la T (inflammation de la thyroïde, bouffées de chaleur, douleurs pelviennes, rétention urinaire, émoussement émotionnel) ont disparu à l'arrêt, mes règles sont revenues normalement, et mon visage et mon sourire sont revenus vers ce qu'ils étaient avant la T. Annoncer ma détransition m'a fait plus peur que d'annoncer que j'étais trans ; j'y vais progressivement, j'ai gardé mon prénom de naissance sur mes papiers officiels, et je n'ai dit ni à ma mère ni à mes meilleurs amis que je regrette tout. Je me décris aujourd'hui comme une femme à 100 % et j'adore ça, tout en restant critique de la transition médicale des mineurs et du modèle de l'affirmation à tout prix.
Histoire complète
I was born female and grew up in Poland. Looking back, I had what I now call reversed gender dysphoria even before I ever thought of myself as trans: I wanted to be shorter, wanted less body hair, and was disappointed that I only grew small breasts. Around 14 or 15 I struggled with internalised biphobia and briefly tried to push myself into identifying as a lesbian, though that phase didn't last long. I'm bisexual, not a lesbian, and I now think the societal assumption that a masculine woman must be a lesbian was one of the things that pushed me toward transition — I felt I couldn't be a woman if I couldn't find a group of women to fit in with.
I was bullied in primary school, and I had trauma connected to my birth name. I came out as trans, socially transitioned, and went on testosterone. I was absolutely certain at times — that certainty is when I started T — but I also had impostor syndrome and periods of doubt beforehand. I was 19 when I stopped, and I had been on T for about 10 months to a year.
The changes on T happened faster emotionally than physically. Very quickly my way of thinking and feeling changed drastically. I became emotionally flat and dull — I couldn't "feel into" anything, even imagining deep emotions felt impossible. I'm a very sensitive person, an artist who loves art, moving stories, my complex imagination and colourful sensations that come just from thinking about things, and having that almost completely gone was awful. I felt like I was hiding inside a shell, both as my skin thickened and my feelings went out of reach. I also lost things like feeling butterflies in my stomach, because all I felt down there was nothing or constant pelvic pain — my reproductive system wasn't working at all. I developed thyroid inflammation, unbearable hot flushes and pins and needles whenever I got even slightly sweaty, and constant mild abdominal pain. I also had trouble urinating — sometimes I couldn't pee at all even with a very full bladder — which became one of the things that drew the line for me on hormones.
It did give me stability and got rid of my PMS, but I ended up missing my predictable cycle of moods tied to my menstrual cycle. PMS wasn't only misery and crying for me — it was also the time I was extra sensitive and really listened to myself, the time I set boundaries about things I'd been ignoring. I stopped T cold turkey. The first thing that changed quickly was that my voice... no, actually the first thing was my smile came back to how it was — the way fat and tissue wraps around the face during expressions is a big part of what made me look male, and it reversed. Then came the emotional and cognitive improvements.
I'm now over two years off T (about two and a half years as of my most recent posts) and physically I've never been better. All the physical problems — thyroid inflammation, hot flushes, pins and needles, abdominal pain, emotional flatness — went away after stopping. My periods came back about a month after quitting and have been normal and regular since. My face looks much more like it did pre-T.
The hardest lasting change is my voice. It dropped on T and hasn't fully recovered. My comfortable speaking range sits between 110 and 170 Hz, but my full stable range is about 82 to 260 Hz (E2 to C4). I can access head voice/falsetto from roughly A3 to D5 (220 to 587 Hz), but it's very unstable and I have to relearn it almost every day, and sometimes it doesn't work at all. My voice is fry-heavy and raspy — I say it sounds unhealthy, like I smoked for decades. People who knew me pre-T say it changed a lot, but strangers say it sounds androgynous or in-between; I get gendered female in daily life and get complimented on my voice, though once a doctor asked if I had a sore throat. It takes conscious effort to sound feminine, and I avoid speaking from anxiety, which people tell me makes it worse — my family says I used to be loud as a kid but now they can barely hear me, and I can't make a loud sound without it sounding terrible. I've been training by singing, and I see progress in range but not stability. The grief over my voice has been long and painful, and I still regret it.
Mentally, detransition has been a huge relief. I'm over two months off T in one account I gave, and I already felt much more like myself; by a year off, I said I'd never been better except for grieving my voice. I'm a very sensitive person again, and I said I missed my "insanity" — my emotional range — and that sometimes you have to lose something to really cherish it.
Coming out as detransitioned felt, in my own words, more scary than coming out as trans. I've been going gradually: I haven't told my new course professors to use different name or pronouns than what's in my documents (I still have my birth name and female sex marker on them), I've gone slightly more feminine in presentation, I tell people I use any pronouns now instead of male ones, and I mostly just ignore how others refer to me. I go by Milo with my friends, which I think of as fairly gender-neutral, and I keep my deadname for official settings and family — my family never stopped using it. I used to feel very bad about my deadname, partly because of bullying trauma tied to it, but now I feel neutral to positive about it, though I still wouldn't use it in some settings because it doesn't feel right. I mentioned detransitioning to a guy I was flirting with. My mother never affirmed my trans identification — she always refused to call me anything but she/her — but now she does this odd thing where she calls me he/him and then corrects herself to she/her right after, which I think is hard for her because of my voice. I haven't told her yet that I'm detransitioning.
Some of my closest friends are, in my words, "loud and proud gender warriors," and I haven't told my best friend that I want to detransition. One friend is falling into a transfemme pipeline rather than just staying gender non-conforming, and another suddenly wants low-dose estrogen after previously saying estrogen wasn't for them because they didn't want to grow breasts — I know low dose won't prevent that and I'm worried they'll regret it, but I don't know how to raise it. I worry I may have been an unintentional "inspiration" to them with my medical stuff, which I don't like at all. They think I left T for medical reasons only and don't know that I regret the whole thing, including the social transition.
On causes, I now think my brain turned my insecurities into escapism and wanting to be a boy. I've become quite critical of the affirmation-only model and of medical transition for minors — I was very struck by the case of Chloe Cole, who was twelve, and I argue that at that age you can't even go on a school trip without parental permission, so the heavy individualism and personal-responsibility framing is damaging when applied to children. I think the responsibility lies more with doctors, trans influencers and activists with ideological influence than with the community in general, and I don't think acknowledging that medical system failures means seeing yourself as a forever victim.
I've developed a fairly specific theoretical view. I define gender, dropping self-identification, as a set of societal expectations based on society's perception of your biological sex, and I hold a gender-abolitionist stance — I think those expectations are a tool of oppression rooted in economic relations, so real change requires changing the economic system first. I distinguish that from what I call transsexualism, which I see as a genuine brain-body mismatch — a medical thing, rarer than social or psychological transgenderism, which I see as a personal cope with the hardships of being seen as one's sex. I'm skeptical that transition is the optimal long-term solution even for that mismatch, and I've suggested the mismatch could just be an acceptable quirk rather than a disorder, comparing it to how the content of hallucinations varies with cultural attitudes. I define woman as an adult human female, and female as a body following the developmental blueprint toward producing eggs and carrying offspring — it doesn't require wanting or being able to have children, just that the body developed in that direction. I'm skeptical of claims that HRT lowers suicidality, and I've asked for actual studies, arguing the correlation may reflect general mental health issues rather than transness specifically, and that existing studies may suffer from type I error and a replication crisis.
Feminism mattered to me in coming back to my body. I said the main thing in making my dysphoria disappear was learning about feminism in past socialist projects — the idea that a man and a woman can simply be workers and be equal. I think modern feminism is failing women, particularly around how female bodies are oversexualised and objectified, which shaped my own discomfort with my chest — I noted it's hard to like that body part in clothes when the shape is so objectified, especially if you don't want men's attention.
As of my most recent post, I've been detransitioned for over two years after about a year on T. I still regret what happened to my voice and it still makes me dysphoric, but I describe myself as back to being "100% a woman and loving it," that life has been much easier, and that I'm glad I got rid of the desire to be the opposite sex completely.