Toutes les histoires

La dysphorie était une pensée, pas un ressenti

Féminin · Désisté·e182
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis une femme détransitionnée, F 37, qui en est venue à voir la transition comme une solution par procuration à une détresse psychologique enracinée dans une famille dysfonctionnelle et fusionnelle, avec des parents émotionnellement immatures, et qui se définit maintenant simplement comme elle-même, sans besoin d'être autre chose que ce que je suis. J'ai éprouvé de la dysphorie de genre mais j'ai conclu que « se sentir comme un garçon » était une pensée plutôt qu'un ressenti, et mon chemin a consisté à intégrer l'énergie féminine et masculine en moi plutôt qu'à faire une transition médicale. Les thérapies somatiques, la CNV, l'étude de la psychologie et des communautés comme Genspect m'ont le plus aidée, et j'accepte maintenant lentement ma féminité après des années à la vivre comme une insulte. Je reste critique de l'idéologie trans et de la terminologie genrée tout en étant compatissante envers les personnes qui font une transition. Je n'ai décrit dans cette transcription ni hormones, ni chirurgies, ni étapes médicales de détransition, ni idées suicidaires.

Histoire complète

I grew up in what looked like a picture-perfect family from the outside, but inside there was enmeshment, passive aggression, and emotionally immature parents — old hippies who said "you can be whatever you want to" but, as I later realized, not a boy. There was a huge disconnect between what was said and what was behaved. My parents were both great and horrible: lovely values, dreams, ideas, very creative, but horrible at communication, collaboration, emotions and understanding. My mother talked badly about my father to me, and I really didn't like her; growing up to be a woman felt horrifying, and I thought many times that my life would be easier if I was a boy. My sister and I essentially parented each other emotionally because our actual parents couldn't provide that. I was longing for belonging, connection and understanding that I couldn't get at home or, really, at school. I grew up watching The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Velvet Goldmine, and Hedwig and the Angry Inch, so I always thought of LGBT as kind of "normal." I experienced gender dysphoria — I have tried it, it is a real experience — but over time I figured that "feeling like a boy" was a thought, not a feeling, and I had to unpack what the thought was pointing to: distress about inner and outer not aligning, needing to be understood, belonging, acceptance. I also had to unpack my distress with my sex, what social and cultural stuff I was resisting, why I didn't want to be like my mother, and the identity of being bi. I don't identify with being bi as an identity — it's just how I feel about sexual attraction — but I think not fitting into heteronormative society fed the sense of not being born in the right body. There was a lot to unpack. I came to see transition, with hormones and surgery, as a "proxy solution" (a phrase I heard Az Hakeem use) for psychological distress — feelings live in the body, so it's hard to detach mind from body; I described it as a "masculine solution" (GAC) for a "feminine challenge" (integration of the paradox). I don't judge people who go that route: some people are not capable of unpacking their trauma and go with the trans identity as a solution to their psychological distress, and it might be the right solution for them. There are also countries where you cannot be gay, so trans is the only option for living — that's sad, but at least they can live. For me, the solution was not to transition but to integrate feminine and masculine energy within myself — very difficult in a toxic environment (I reference Gabor Maté's The Myth of Normal), and it's an ongoing process. I'm on a path to integration now (I've been following the Pathways to Liberation "matrix" framework) and I no longer see a need to be anything other than what I am. The journey to get here was very difficult; I wonder if it could have been less difficult, or whether the turbulence itself is a contributor to the integration. I'm ok with being a woman now, in my 30s. I remember a childhood movie about a girl who stops wanting to be a girl, calls herself Kurt and lives on a boat, and I find it interesting that so many young women don't want to be women — including me. I still wrestle with femininity: "Is feminine a slur for you? It sure was for me some years ago. I'm slowly learning to accept my femininity, it's a long steep process." I never really liked dresses, but over the last couple of years I've been slowly trying them out, though I'm picky about practicality (no pockets!), fabric (I hate polyester, nylon, silk), colour and shape, and I can easily end up back in pants and a t-shirt. I ask my husband for help styling myself. I also use cross-dressing-type strategies for safety and comfort, similar to what others have described. Short hair I love; long hair I like the look of, so I try to have both. What has helped me most is (psycho-)somatic work: going into the body, exercise, voice healing, qi gong, biking, dancing, gardening, going to the beach and forest — basically self-care. I also use Nonviolent Communication (NVC) a lot, translating judgements into needs, and I recommend Marshall Rosenberg's The Surprising Purpose of Anger; I follow Cup of Empathy, Yvette Erasmus, Miki Kashtan, Yoram Mosenzon. I've dug into psychology generally — enmeshment, codependency, dysfunctional family systems, drama triangle, empowerment dynamic, CPTSD, emotionally immature people. I've hosted free sharing rooms on Discord to hold space for others. I think the brain can rewire, maybe not down to gender identity, but maybe it can. I don't want anybody to be "cis" or conform — I don't conform and don't believe in "normal." I'm skeptical of gender-identity ideology: "by trans ideology, you are just trans, no further questions asked. I'm not so sure about that." I also find the newer terminology reductive — calling a whole human female a "chest feeder" or "bleeder" feels belittling, even if the strategy is to be more specific. I think the war on gender is really a split in consciousness, black-white thinking, not seeing the whole picture. I believe in going to the root cause rather than treating symptoms, and I think the side-effects of GAC are a lot more than other treatments. I've recommended Genspect and Stella (its founder) to others as a place for detransitioners to find community, support and care; it was hard for me at first to watch their videos because I didn't like how they spoke about trans people, but now I see it in another light. I live in Denmark, where GNC people are mostly accepted. I'm F 37. My life really started in my 30s — I was so lost in my teenage years and most of my 20s, and having a lot of sh*t in my baggage made me who I am today. When I was 4 or 5 I went to the hospital for surgery on a weird thumb and, dreaming under anesthesia, imagined I was Pippi Longstocking and kicked all the doctors — I didn't want the surgery. I have painful periods, worse when I'm not in balance with myself (e.g. if I eat sugary foods). I don't recall particular boy characters I liked as a child; I like cartoons a lot, animal or imagined characters, and very cartoonish movies like The Mask or The Fifth Element. I've had relational experiences that fed my insecurity about femininity: a gay guy fell in love with me but didn't want to be bi; a guy I was with declared himself gay a couple of months later, which baffled me and fed my insecurities; a girl I kissed later told me "sorry, I'm lesbian" and I never heard from her again.