Toutes les histoires

Six ans de binding, puis les journaux intimes et la misogynie intériorisée

Féminin · Désisté·e298
Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.

Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.

Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.

Résumé

Je suis née fille, je me suis identifiée comme un homme trans pendant un temps, j'ai porté un binder pendant environ six ans, puis j'ai désisté/détransitionné vers 2019-2020 après avoir tenu un journal et travaillé sur la misogynie intériorisée et la dysphorie. Je ne regrette pas la transition et je me sens encore liée à qui j'étais pendant cette période, mais je crois que ma dysphorie était enracinée dans un sexisme appris et un désir d'échapper à ce que la condition de femme signifiait pour moi. J'utilise encore mon prénom masculin dans certains contextes, je prends la détransition lentement et je me concentre sur l'acceptation de moi-même plutôt que sur un but fixe. Je suis actuellement une femme détransitionnée, active dans la communauté détrans, offrant soutien et pistes d'écriture de journal aux autres. Je n'ai décrit dans ces posts aucune idée suicidaire ni automutilation.

Histoire complète

I was born female and identified as a female-to-male transgender person for a period of my life. By November 2019 I was openly describing myself as "a female to male transgender person" and actively seeking advice from women who had detransitioned, because I was worried that internalized misogyny was driving my transition. I wrote that I had "some ideas that being a woman means less power and more sex appeal/femininity," that I was bisexual but had never felt romantic attraction toward a woman (which concerned me), and that I wanted to grow out of those ideas and make sure they weren't what was driving my transition. Around that time I was already beginning to question things. In mid-2020 I described having started "really working through a lot of my gender feelings a few months ago," which places the start of that active working-through period in late 2019 or early 2020. I journaled extensively about my dysphoria, and I talked with close friends about it. I wrote that "the more I journaled and talked to my close friends about it, I just naturally slipped into a lot of this stuff" — meaning I gradually became more comfortable presenting as female without forcing it. I had bound my chest for six years. In June 2020 I said I had "really recently" been able to do a "180" on binding, that I always wore a bra to work now, and that the thought of doing that even five months earlier would have given me "some kind of freakout." Dysphoria was still hard for me at that point, but I was managing it. I recommended journaling about dysphoria specifically: "When I asked myself more why I didn't want breasts and what having breasts meant, I was able to deal with it better." I desisted/detransitioned. I don't think I ever described medical hormone use or surgery in these posts, so I'll leave those details out. I came out to people as male before desisting, and by mid-2020 I said: "Sometimes it doesn't stress me and those are the best times, but I do get stressed sometimes because there are people I came out to as male before desisting." I noted that it stressed me out when people made a point of gendering me male in a way that was clearly unnatural and awkward for them. At a new job around 2020, everyone simply assumed I was female, and I didn't correct them: "When people at my new job said I was female I didnt tell them any different." I still went by my male name at that point. I said: "Right now I still go by my 'male' name. It confuses people, but I don't give a shit. If (nice) people ask I tell them I lived as male for a while, but now I don't." I noted that some friends still used he/my chosen name, and that I had some family who never accepted me in the first place, which mattered less to me now. I mused that a name change puts too much emphasis on gender in one's life, and that I might or might not change back to my birth name eventually. I framed detransition for myself not as "going back" but as "not caring either way." I said: "The more private progress I have on my self esteem/unlearning sexism, the more detransition stuff I'm able to do, not vice versa." I took it slow and didn't force myself into things. On causes: I believed (and still largely believe) that for many people, including me, transition was tied to learned sexism and internalized misogyny. I listed common reasons I thought FTMTF people transition: not being able to accept attraction to women; not wanting to be with men "as a woman"; feeling that being a woman is dangerous because of sexual abuse; depression and needing hope that transition would change everything; the addictiveness of fantasizing about changing yourself; and sexism — the internalized idea that women are weak and men are powerful. I said: "Personally, I didn't think I could be a woman cause I thought it meant all these other things about me had to be true." I also said I knew being cisgender would make my life easier but felt I couldn't be, because that would mean being comfortable in women's clothes, acting feminine, and liking she/her pronouns. I also connected dysphoria to deeper past experiences: "Your dysphoria probably stems from concrete things that happened to you/you saw growing up. People internalize things they see and connect it to what gender means, and sometimes transition is a way to escape that. You probably need to reconnect & understand your past to move past the dysphoria." I have no explicit mention of an autism or ADHD diagnosis in these posts, so I'll leave that out. I do reference depression indirectly when advising others to tell parents about struggling with depression and to look into CBT/DBT, but I don't explicitly say I was diagnosed with it. On regret: I explicitly said I did not regret transition. In June 2020 I wrote: "Tbh being trans got me where I am. I was curious about gender and I learned about it in the way that was most popular at the time. I don't regret it, & I don't think any of my experiences as a trans person were not... as a trans person. I didn't feel like a hurting woman on the inside & I don't really see myself that way in retrospect." I added: "I still feel very connected to who I was during transition even if I'm living differently. Who I was then was authentic in a different way." And: "I don't regret any of it or wish that someone wouldve told me something to change my mind." What I did wish was that someone had told me suffering wouldn't last forever: "I wish someone would've told me that I'm not going to suffer forever and some day my body will be ok with me... It would not have made me reidentify, but might've eased the pain to have someone there for me." I also said: "Tbh being trans got me where I am" and that being trans was a real expression of feelings I still have, just dealt with differently now. I talked about being "both trans & detrans" with a close detransitioned friend. On community and influences: I said that an online figure named Crash was "one of the online figures that instrumental in my decision to detransition," and that their words helped show me an option for being myself that didn't involve "tearing other parts away." I also mentioned that Kalvin Garrah had put out videos interviewing detrans people. I was looking for detransition-related media, including a zine called Blood and Visions, and I shared music I related to (Dazey and the Scouts' "Sweet Cis Teen," Jeffrey Lewis songs). I was active in the detrans community, giving advice to others. I shared a list of journaling questions I asked myself during my detransition: "what does it mean to be a woman? what does it mean to be a girl? what does it mean to be a man? why do i want keep living as trans? why do i have doubts about my transition? what makes me feel the most dysphoric? why don't i want to be seen as a woman/girl, when at one point it was okay with me? why did i start identifying as trans? did i see boys and girls treated differently growing up? did this change how i saw women?" I was thoughtful about the trans/detrans divide. I said I didn't think detransition should have a goal, and that "to detransition in a way that is not accepting yourself just as you are defeats the point of detransitioning." I criticized both communities for over-focusing on appearance and passing: "Focusing on your appearance like that in my opinion has really negative mental effects on both communities." I advocated for better therapy screening, more honest medical care, and connection between trans and detrans communities. On sexuality and relationships: I described myself as bisexual in 2019. In June 2020 I said "pretty much everyone I've been with in the past has been trans" and that all my friends used to be trans, with many now detransitioned. I said I believed "some people are born with dysphoria, but especially now it's usually a manifestation of learned sexism," and worried I couldn't date a trans person because we'd disagree on that. On adversity: I don't describe specific personal trauma in these posts directly, but in December 2023 I responded to someone else's story of assault and rape by saying: "just like you I wanted to change my body as a solution to a deeper problem. it is a very confusing thing." This suggests I too had wanted to change my body as a solution to a deeper problem, but I don't have explicit details of what that problem was from these posts. In February 2024 I wrote about sexual shame and body disgust: "even if you've never had a partner, i'm sure you can imagine how your heart would break if a woman you were with was crying out of disgust towards her body when you slept together... you deserve the same compassion. detransition and sexual shame are complicated, heavy issues and i think they take time to fully unravel, but you are not ruined." This was advice to someone else, but the framing ("detransition and sexual shame are complicated, heavy issues") suggests I was speaking from experience with sexual shame, though I don't state it as directly my own. In February 2024 I also said I hoped one result of increased detransition would be "a more vibrant community for butch women, gnc women, and feminists — that's what i am longing for!" Current status: I identify as a detransitioned/desisted woman (female), I still sometimes go by a male name, I'm comfortable with my past as a trans person without regret, and I'm still working through internalized sexism and self-acceptance. I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm in these posts.