Ces histoires ont été résumées à l'aide de l'IA.
Sur Reddit, les gens partagent souvent leurs expériences à travers plusieurs commentaires ou publications. Pour rendre ces informations plus accessibles, detrans.ai rassemble toutes ces pièces dispersées en un résumé et une chronologie uniques et faciles à lire. Tous les prompts du système sont documentés sur la page des prompts.
Parfois, l'IA peut halluciner ou affirmer des choses qui ne sont pas vraies. Mais généralement, les histoires résumées sont des reflets précis des commentaires originaux des utilisateurs.
Résumé
Je suis une femme désistée qui a fait une transition sociale mais jamais médicale, et je m’identifie et vis maintenant en femme. J’en suis venue à détransitionner grâce à l’amour et au soutien de mon copain hétéro, ainsi qu’à la découverte de r/detrans en septembre 2020 ; je me suis délibérément retirée des communautés trans, j’ai pratiqué l’exposition affirmative avec mon partenaire et travaillé sur l’amour de soi, ce qui a réduit ma dysphorie d’un facteur dix en environ dix mois. Je n’ai aucun regret chirurgical ou hormonal puisque je n’ai jamais transitionné médicalement, même si la dysphorie sociale — comme se faire appeler « jeune fille » — me fait encore mal, et je m’attends à ce que cela s’estompe. Je vois maintenant la transition comme un traitement possible parmi d’autres de la dysphorie de genre et je plaide pour une thérapie avec un thérapeute neutre, sans agenda. Je ne rapporte ni idées suicidaires ni automutilation dans ce témoignage.
Histoire complète
I first came to understand myself through dysphoria: I hated being called female, hated my breasts and vagina, my feminine voice, hips, face and girlish name. I believed the narrative that transitioning was the only solution to dysphoria, so I socially transitioned and lived as a man — I was 'stealth' to people around me. I never medically transitioned: no hormones, no surgery, but I did transition socially entirely.
In hindsight I recognise contributing factors: I experienced a lot of internalised misogyny and underwent a lot of childhood trauma. I also think a lot of dysphoria in people like me is cultivated by focus and exposure — I've described how constantly watching trans media and focusing on your sex characteristics can turn apathy into discomfort, and then, especially once you enter transmedicalist circles that prize 'crippling dysphoria' as proof of being 'truly trans', that discomfort spirals. I came into the whole mess pretty much dysphoria-free, in my reading of my own experience.
The turning point was my boyfriend. The initial reason I desisted was that I knew he was entirely straight and there was no way he could love me as a man. He helped me feel better about my body and helped me feel attractive, and helped me feel my female parts are more right. He would listen to my feelings, talk them through with me, and devote a lot of his time to actively helping me feel less dysphoric. In many ways it felt like a dilemma between being a man and keeping him; viewing him as a kind of 'goal' gave me the motivation to keep working at detransition. I don't know if I'd have had the strength to keep going without that.
I came across r/detrans around September 2020 and felt incredibly inspired — I had never realised overcoming dysphoria was even an option. Over the following ten months my dysphoria did not go away completely but improved tenfold, though getting there involved a lot of emotional pain and confronting the dysphoria head on. What I did, in rough order:
- I distanced myself from all links to the trans community: blocked all trans content from my YouTube recommendations and left all trans-related social media, because constant exposure was bringing attention to my own dysphoria and that was not healthy.
- I got my boyfriend to start saying the things that normally made me dysphoric — referring to my body parts in a female way, telling me I am a woman — while I put effort into relaxing hearing it and telling myself it was okay. Because it was gentle and came from a place of love, it didn't trigger me the way it normally would. After a couple of months I felt very comfortable hearing those female terms from him.
- I stopped hiding from my body when getting changed, and gently touched the parts that made me dysphoric while telling myself, 'It's all okay. It's just me; it's just my body.'
- I tried to take on board that I am not defined by my sex — it defines me no more than having two legs or a nose. I tried to view desisting as simply learning to love my body as it was.
- I worked on overriding the angry voice saying 'why couldn't I just be male' with positive affirmation, soothing myself instead of worsening the dysphoria. I told myself that being dysphoric didn't mean there was anything wrong with being a woman.
- I thought critically about the dysphoria and asked why I felt the need to be male. I never reached a concrete answer, and that lack of an answer only reinforced that desiring to be male was an ungrounded feeling.
- I came out as detrans to a few accepting friends and had them refer to me as female, giving me a safe space to experience being referred to as a woman.
- I had my boyfriend compliment my feminine parts, and sometimes complimented them myself, so they felt beautiful rather than shameful.
I never had a particular plan; I just took it slowly and kept pushing my comfort zone. Trying something new hurt a lot because I had to face the dysphoria before learning to manage it. When triggered I sometimes tell myself 'so what?' — getting gendered as female in public is nothing more than people accurately acknowledging my body. Within a few months I could shower comfortably and was so much happier in general.
Coming out to people has been terrifying but okay. I told a close friend I had previously been stealth to — the first time I'd ever told anyone — sending a long paragraph and then lying there shaking and panicking, but they understood. An older woman calling me 'young lady' out in public still brought on incredibly frustrating dysphoria, but I have real hope that one day it will wash over me with no discomfort at all.
I have never medically transitioned, so I have no surgical or hormonal regrets; my losses are the years of social transition and the pain itself. I do not regret it in the sense that, as I put it, 'I did what I needed to have done at the time.' I am a lot happier after choosing to treat dysphoria with self-love rather than transition — it's far nicer feeling content with one's body than despising every aspect of it.
On transition for others, I frame gender dysphoria as the condition and transition as only *a* treatment among others, such as working through it in therapy. I recommend a general therapist rather than a transgender therapist, and one without an agenda to push you either towards or away from transition. I see transition as a worst-case-scenario treatment: it can only mitigate, not eliminate, dysphoria, because you never truly have the body of the opposite sex. I compare it to body dysmorphia, where the gold standard is contentment with a healthy body rather than hormonal and surgical manipulation. I'm careful not to encourage or discourage anyone's transition directly — for instance, when someone raised faith-based objections, I argued the 'made in his image' argument is selectively applied and told them not to decide based on faith when it has no bearing, while explicitly not pushing them either way.
I've also engaged critically with the discourse: I think the 'super straight' concept is acceptable but the term itself is transphobic; I've argued that identifying as trans is not a conscious 'choice' but more like a placebo effect working behind your back; and I've been protective of detrans data, objecting to polls without a 'see results' option because most respondents aren't desisted/detrans themselves.