Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha fatto la detransizione/desistenza — non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi, ma per un paio d'anni ho preso in considerazione la transizione prima di scegliere la radicale accettazione di me stessa. Sono femmina, ho la PCOS e in passato ho affrontato otto anni di grave anoressia, bulimia e autolesionismo insieme alla disforia di genere. Ora, a 30 anni, ho imparato ad amare il mio corpo e la mia presentazione mascolina e GNC, e nel 2019 ho detto «sono una donna» ad alta voce per la prima volta senza che mi sembrasse sbagliato. Sono critica verso la transizione medica, ho posizioni critiche sul genere e consiglio attivamente agli altri, negli spazi della detransizione, di rallentare, evitare la chirurgia e uscire dalla propria testa. In questa trascrizione non sono descritti ideazione suicidaria, autolesionismo o tentativi di suicidio dopo la detransizione.
Storia completa
I was born female and I have PCOS. I first ran into gender dysphoria in my late teens or early twenties — I was considering transitioning for a couple of years, roughly around my mid-twenties, before deciding against it. I never went on testosterone or had any surgeries; I chose what I call a path of 'radical self-acceptance' instead. I told myself it was okay if I was never fully comfortable with my breasts, and that dealing with that discomfort was better than surgery. A couple of years after that decision, I found that I actually came to love my breasts and my body in general, and I stopped obsessing over every detail of it.
I also have a history of about eight years of severe anorexia, bulimia, and self-harm, alongside the gender dysphoria. Getting rid of all of that largely on my own was the hardest thing I've ever done, but it taught me that change is possible if you commit to it. I'm a firm believer in willpower and gradual changes. I don't frame it as fluffy positivity — I think a lot of these mental health problems are patterns we impose on ourselves, often not for noble reasons, and that we resist changing because we don't want to let go of familiar negative thinking and a ready-made reason to feel sorry for ourselves.
I'm 30 now (as of March 2019) and I've grown into being comfortable as a masculine, gender-non-conforming woman. For a while after desisting I tried performing femininity as a way of accepting my womanhood, but it never felt right and just made me uncomfortable, so I stopped. I'm only slightly androgynous in looks and personality-wise I'm not a pushover, and I get called a man by friends and men I sleep with — simply because I'm not a stereotype. That used to bother me; now I see it as other people struggling with the fact that women aren't walking stereotypes of femininity.
Coming to terms with being a woman was a slow process. Only in May 2019, at thirty, did I say 'I'm a woman' out loud to someone and have it feel right rather than like an ugly word that didn't describe me. I said it with conviction, tired of people telling me I'm 'more like a man' because I don't take shit from people. I feel a fierce belonging with women now, even though I'm still not fully comfortable around very feminine women — and I've accepted that's fine; I don't have to be like them.
I now think a lot of the desire to transition comes from internalised misogyny — wanting the respect and rights men seem to have, and feeling too different from other women to belong. I see gender dysphoria as sitting in the same category as body dysmorphia and eating disorders: some people are more predisposed, but the causes are social — sexual trauma, internalised homophobia or misogyny, and in males a severe dislike of masculinity and idealisation of womanhood. I'm sceptical of the 'gendered brain' idea; I point out that brains of homosexual men also resemble those of heterosexual women, that brains are just bodies, and that no scan can diagnose someone as trans. I also think there's essentially no research on treatments for dysphoria other than transition, and no solid evidence that transition treats dysphoria — and that transition often just makes people obsess more about passing and how others see them.
Things that helped me included meditation (I recommend apps), getting physically and socially active — walking, sports, volunteering, classes like painting or pottery — and deliberately changing what I consumed visually: I unfollowed hyper-feminine Instagram accounts and followed hundreds of strong, active women instead — boulderers, climbers, BMX riders, skaters, callisthenics athletes, hikers, runners, tomboys and GNC lesbians. Watching nature documentaries and seeing female animals give birth, hunt, teach and protect their young on their own also genuinely helped me appreciate being female. I've also come to like my PCOS rather than resent it: I love getting hairier each year and that it's easier for me to build muscle, and it was a relief to come off birth control and have my breasts return to their normal AAA cup size.
I've been active in online detransition and desistance spaces, offering advice to others considering or going through detransition. I've recommended videos by a detransitioned man on YouTube about making detransition constructive, and shared an article by a detransitioned epidemiologist on suicidality and affirmation. Practical advice I give to younger people includes: don't rush, don't get surgery if you don't want it, wait it out; try thinking of yourself as a woman privately without a big public 'coming out'; stop hormones if you want but consult a doctor first; and get out of your own head by engaging with life externally. I'm critical of professionals who push vulnerable people toward transition and of the wider psychiatric tendency to medicalise ordinary human experience. I hold gender-critical views: I don't think gender is innate, I don't believe identifying as something makes you that thing ('I'm female, I don't identify as one. I just am'), and I think femininity does not equal womanhood. I also believe trans people should have rights simply because they're people, not contingent on any brain scan.
Current status: I'm a desisted, detransitioned woman — I never medically transitioned — who is comfortable in my body and my masculine, GNC presentation, and I actively advise others against rushing into transition.