Tutte le storie

Scrivo dall'altra parte dal 2019

Femmina · Detransizionato/a91
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione dopo aver vissuto come uomo e oggi scrivo da una prospettiva fortemente cristiana sui danni della transizione e sulla falsa promessa dell'affermazione. Sono attiva nelle comunità di detransizione dal 2019, avverto gli altri di cercare terapeuti non affermativi e sostengo che la transizione medica tipica maschile sia in gran parte irreversibile. Credo che la società offra agli uomini ben poca empatia e sostegno veritieri, una realtà che ho vissuto sulla mia pelle. Vedo la detransizione come qualcosa che produce una visibile «scintilla di speranza» negli occhi delle persone. In questo materiale non ho descritto la mia storia di transizione medica.

Storia completa

I have been reading and posting in detransition spaces since at least late 2019, and my own views have been shaped by a mix of religious conviction, personal experience living as a man, and watching others go through transition and detransition. I came to this community with a strongly Christian moral frame. Early on I wrote that it's 'hard to look at this world and not recognize Christianity got one thing very right: this world truly does belong to Satan,' and I welcomed someone home by calling her 'Magdalene.' I've also framed the transition journey itself as something like a roller coaster imposed on a person — 'You've taken her on a roller coaster. Can you blame her for wanting off?' — which suggests I see people as being carried into transition by others and then wanting out. I speak about living as a man from direct experience. In March 2020 I described myself as 'a 6'4", handsome, charismatic, and successful man' and said that, apart from my wife, 'I get absolutely no empathy or support from anyone other than my wife. It's just how society treats men. There's exceptions, I'm sure, but being unloved and untrusted is the default existence for men.' I made a related distinction that being treated well and accepted socially is different from being supported or cared for. I have a wife, which tells me I'm in (or was in) a marriage at that time. I'm skeptical of easy affirmation and of diagnoses in general. I advised someone, with the highest-upvoted comment I've posted here, to 'talk to a non-affirming shrink' and warned that 'If they affirm what you say about yourself, you should seek second opinion. A good psych will lead you to finding things out about yourself, not tell you things you think you already know about yourself.' I added: 'Beware of ANYONE who tells you things about yourself. Whether it be a licensed psychologist or an anime picture on Discord.' I also endorsed a definition of diagnosis as 'something you can put on a form to get you a particular drug or therapy.' I've thought about the sex breakdown of transition and detransition. I asked why the majority of trans people are MtF while the majority of posts on this subreddit are FtM. My answer, which was unpopular (score -19), was that testosterone blockers and estrogen are 'powerful and traumatic for MTF' and that 'there's never a way to regain your manhood once it's gone.' I argued we don't see more MtF detransitioners 'because there's more permanent damage,' and that 'FTMs have a greater recovery rate because discovering firsthand that male-privilege is a myth is a powerful redpill. And FTM, there's no irreversible surgery. If a MTF has gone all the way, there's no coming back.' I acknowledged this view might be seen as sexist. I care about the moment of detransition itself. In July 2020 I wrote about 'The beam I see in the eyes of people after they've detrans'd... it's beautiful. Like, a spark of hope or something.' I have not described my own transition, surgeries, hormone use, mental health diagnoses, therapy history, family of origin, or sexuality in this transcript, so I'll leave those areas out rather than fill them in.