Tutte le storie

Una transizione impeccabile a 19 anni — e il desiderio che non fosse mai successa

Femmina · Detransizionato/aPrima disforia 14 → Transizione 14 → Detransizione 196,2K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransition e che ha vissuto come uomo trans dai 14 anni e ha preso testosterone dai 16 ai 19 (3 anni e 2 mesi), smettendo ad agosto 2019 dopo aver trovato r/detrans mentre cercavo informazioni sulla caduta dei capelli. Ho avuto una transizione 'perfetta' — passavo in modo impeccabile, ho ottenuto tutto ciò che volevo — ma la rimpiango profondamente, soprattutto la voce permanentemente più profonda e i peli sul viso, e vorrei non aver mai preso ormoni. I miei cambiamenti fisici si sono in gran parte invertiti nel giro di pochi mesi dallo stop (ridistribuzione del grasso, seno che si riempie, perdita di peli sul corpo, ritorno del ciclo), e la mia salute mentale e la mia gamma emotiva sono migliorate drasticamente senza testosterone. Ho fatto coming out pubblicamente a novembre 2019 ricevendo un sostegno enorme, sono tornata al mio nome di nascita e da allora ho fatto un video virale su YouTube sulla mia detransition e ho iniziato a scrivere un libro. Ora mi oppongo con forza alla somministrazione di ormoni o bloccanti della pubertà ai bambini e credo che la transizione debba essere per gli adulti un'ultima risorsa assoluta.

Storia completa

I was born female and grew up in a household that was chaotic from the start: my sister abused me out of her own anger issues, my dad was an alcoholic, and my mom stayed with him. I was put on ADHD medication in second grade and then diagnosed with depression, anxiety, and bipolar by age 12, and I stayed on medication until I was 14, during which time I also dealt with anorexia. I hated myself and my body from a young age, thinking I was too fat, and I matured quickly — creepy men online were objectifying me from age 10, and I was sexually harassed by older men before I turned 15 because I grew up on the internet. I was a happy, feminine child, but puberty felt like it destroyed me and took my body away from me. I was exposed to the trans movement at 14 on Twitter, when all my friends were coming out as non-binary, genderfluid, or trans. I came out as a trans boy at 14-15 (socially) and I had always wanted to be a feminine gay boy — I had an obsession with becoming one, which was common in my friend circle. My first therapist tried to teach me CBT and refused to give me a hormone referral because I was only 15 and it was against her moral code; I got angry and stopped seeing her. Eventually a therapist from the LGBT center kept telling me how my eyes lit up when I told my rehearsed trans story, and she got me on hormones. I begged my parents for about six months nonstop and they finally signed the paperwork, though they weren't happy about it and didn't actually see me as male until the hormones started changing me. I started testosterone cypionate weekly IM injections at 16 (July 2016), beginning at .5ml, then .75, then back to .5, then .75 for the last year — 100-150mg per week. It felt like a magic shot: I was more confident, my mental blocks were removed, and I passed 100% within months. I started high school with my new name and was accepted immediately. I had been dropped out of school for three years before that, had no friends, no driver's license, no ID, no job — so I got to start completely from scratch as male. I identified as a gay male for the first year of transition, then met an ex-girlfriend and realized I still liked girls. Over three years I got everything I wanted: deep voice, broad shoulders, facial and body hair, no periods, and I passed flawlessly. I lived stealth after the first year and it was comfortable. But I never related to men — how they talked about women, their roles, their expectations. I always felt like 'a man with an asterisk.' I started growing my hair out in May 2018 and dressing more femininely, which actually relieved a lot of my discomfort. I also got in shape and lost about 50 pounds, and I realized I felt more happiness from that than from the hormones. Then, around September 2018, I started losing my hair, and I panicked. I searched Reddit for 'trans men who stop testosterone because of hair loss' and found r/detrans, and it stopped every gear turning in my mind. I realized I am a woman. I stopped testosterone cold turkey — my last shot was August 23, 2019, after 3 years and 2 months. The first month was brutal: exhaustion, sore joints, depression, sleeping all the time, and I almost dropped out of my first semester of college. Around late September/early October the physical symptoms eased. I got my first period in about 4 years on October 30, 2019, just two months after stopping. My estrogen and testosterone levels returned to the female range within about a month and a half. Since then the changes have been dramatic: fat redistributed back to my hips, thighs, and breasts (I went from a small saggy chest to a 36C), my muscles atrophied, my shoulders slimmed, my face shape changed back, my body hair thinned dramatically after a single full-body shave, my skin softened, and my voice even lightened somewhat. Within 3-4 months I was being gendered female again when I didn't speak. I came out publicly in early November 2019, first to close family and friends, then to everyone on Facebook and Snapchat, asking them to call me by my birth name again. The response was overwhelmingly supportive. My sister took it the hardest — she had taken my original coming-out very personally and still doesn't use my birth name, though she doesn't misgender me. My parents have been fine with it. I had been the 'first' trans kid at my high school, given speeches, been in a play and a documentary about it, and I realized I had spun so many narratives that I blurred the line between my story and reality. I had bound my chest for 4+ years and I think my ribs are permanently deformed. I never had any surgeries — I'm deeply grateful I never pursued top surgery, because I started liking my breasts again and now they've filled out beautifully. Permanent changes remaining: my voice is deep (a baritone, within the male range), I have facial hair that still grows on my neck and cheeks requiring shaving every 2-3 days (I plan on laser/electrolysis), and my hairline receded and was still shedding months after stopping (I got bangs to cover it). I also believe my clitoris changed and hasn't reverted, though I don't mind how it looks. I started professional voice training in January 2020. The guilt over my voice has been the hardest thing. I listen to old voice recordings and cry. I had a perfect voice before. I also felt intense regret about the lost years — I wish I had grown up with the teenage girl experience I was meant to have. In the first few months I oscillated between despair and hope; one night I went all-out in women's clothes, makeup, heels, and a guy walking past said 'hey ladies,' and it was the first time I felt noticed for who I actually was. I came to forgive my mom — she told me she never believed I was trans from day one but took me from therapist to therapist because I was so suicidal she felt hormones were the only thing that would keep me alive. My first therapist refused; my LGBT-center therapist eventually got me the referral. Mentally, testosterone had made me numb — I could barely cry for three years (I used to cry every day), and I was baseline 'fine' all the time. After stopping, my emotions came back fully; I cried spontaneously, felt happiness strongly, but also felt depression more strongly again. I'm unsure whether I actually have bipolar or any mental illness at all, but I knew I needed to start therapy. I also struggled with comfort eating and weight gain after detransition (about 40 pounds over two years). Weed helped my anxiety short-term but I didn't want to depend on it. On relationships: I'm mostly attracted to men and dating as a trans person was impossible — I was rejected for my appearance by straight guys and for my genitals by a gay guy. A gay man I was involved with said he was in love with me but cut off our romance completely when I told him I was detransitioning. After detransitioning I went on Tinder, met a guy who didn't care that I was detrans, and we started dating. My sexuality has shifted off testosterone — I noticed my sex drive is completely different and I've wondered if I might be a lesbian, though I never would have felt that way on T. I also realized I love being submissive with men, something I rejected before. I was given testosterone before ever having sex, and my views on sex were shaped by my time as a trans man. I've done advocacy: I made a YouTube video about my detransition under the name Elle Palmer that went viral, I started writing a book about my experiences and other detransitioners, and I've been active in detrans communities, including a monthly Skype detrans group. I also posted comparison photos on Reddit (2019 vs 2020 vs 2021) documenting my physical changes. I now firmly believe children should not be given hormones or puberty blockers — this is an adult decision. I think social transition with cautious support and therapy is preferable to a hard 'no,' which pushes teens deeper into the trans community, but parents shouldn't be pushovers either; my mom gave up on parenting me and I wish she had been more forceful. I think hormones should be an absolute last resort, that most people who transition are running from something in their past, and that the trans community is built on self-hatred. I still believe some people genuinely need transition, but it's far less common than we're led to believe. I regret transitioning — I wish I had never taken testosterone, and I would gladly take 20 more years to reach self-love if it meant never altering my body chemically. The regret is intense around my voice especially, but overall I am far happier now than I ever was on testosterone; I feel like my brain and body have finally become one.