Tutte le storie

Tre anni di estrogeni, nessuna transizione sociale

Maschio · Detransizionato/a176
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un maschio che si identifica come detransizionato, che non ha mai fatto la transizione sociale ma ha preso estrogeni e bloccanti del testosterone per circa tre anni a partire dal 2017 circa, e continuo la TOS pur vivendo come uomo perché migliora la mia salute mentale. Accetto di essere maschio e di non poter mai essere femmina, e ho scelto di vivere come ragazzo mascolino invece di fare la transizione sociale. Sono sposato con figli, probabilmente sterile e non ho avuto complicazioni fisiche gravi dagli estrogeni. Sostengo le persone GNC rispetto alla transizione, contrasto sia la disinformazione anti-trans sia il dogma della comunità trans e sto imparando a convivere con la disforia persistente invece di risolverla.

Storia completa

I was born male, and I've never socially transitioned — only medically. About three years before June 2020, my body dysphoria and dysmorphia became too extreme for me to handle, so I decided to start taking estrogen and testosterone blockers. I waned in and out of trans circles near the beginning, but I honestly can't stand the trans communities; there is so much censorship of speech and science, and you aren't allowed to question anything. I'm tired of hearing that 'male' and 'female' are simply social constructs and that since intersex people exist you can be whatever you want — I think that line of thinking is unhealthy. There needs to be a point where we accept reality for what it is. I might look and sound like a woman, but I will never be female; I am a male, and I've always known that as fact. I feel that's why I was never able to make a social transition. I'm not interested in performing stereotypical femininity either — I prefer short hair, men's clothes are more comfortable, and I am mostly attracted to women. Presenting as a man makes my life so much easier in almost every way. My only hangup is that I cannot shake my dysphoria/dysmorphia to save my life. I honestly don't know why I want to be a female; I've had several therapists probe my head to no avail. It's how my mind has always been, but I'm learning to refocus on what I can control. I have seen some major mental health improvements since switching my body's dominant hormones, so I will most likely keep taking estrogen, although I will never identify myself as a woman. I have control over my voice and my chest is easy to hide. I think I usually come off as either a butch lesbian or a young boy, and I don't mind being gendered as male or female, so I've decided it's much easier for me to live out the remainder of my years as a masculine guy who looks more feminine. I noted that I'm technically not detransitioning since I've never socially transitioned and don't intend to stop HRT. Later I explained that I thought — and still think — that being a woman means being a female, and that I really have no reason to be dissatisfied as a male. I don't have any special reason why I want to be female; I just do. I made an attempt to transition medically in hopes of getting close enough to female so I might be happy, but it'll never be enough. I still take HRT, but that's it. I'm married with kids and take estrogen still, even though I live as a man. It does help me with my dysphoria, but it hasn't had a massively pronounced effect on my body, other than looking 15 years younger. My chest is easy to hide and I haven't had any issues with sexual function. As far as I know, I'm sterile at this point, but we don't want any more kids. I believe you really need to involve your spouse in any decisions you plan on making. I've come to believe that it's much easier to be gender nonconforming than it is to be trans. I believe sex dysphoria is real, it can be intense, and it causes some to attempt transition, but being a feminine man or a masculine woman is miles easier than fully integrating yourself medically, socially, and legally into the sphere of the opposite sex. It's impossible to transition fully into male or female, so to some extent a transitioned person is the hyper-extreme version of a GNC person, and it's not easy. I don't dislike my place in society; I simply dislike my body. I can't explain it. I would take being at ease with my body over being at odds with society. When I see anti-trans posts in the community I follow, I push back: I've said 'This isn't gender critical 2.0,' and that such posts are just arguments against gender ideology meant to discredit trans-identified people. I'm here for solace and support, not to read anti-trans posts — transitioning works for some people. I've also defended the medical side: my doctor was very thorough, all of my hormone levels were watched very carefully, and the issues raised in a critical post (E1, E2, E3, low testosterone, cycling progesterone) were all discussed and addressed by the clinic I visited. I don't think transitioning is the best solution by any means, but I think it's unfair to spread misinformation about it — misinformation is the biggest issue I have with the trans community. I've offered support to others: I told a woman who was disgusted with herself that it's okay to be a woman who takes testosterone if that's what makes her happy, saying 'I'm a male who takes estrogen' and that I try not to focus on labels or others' opinions and just live life my way — I'm not perfectly happy, but no one is. I told another person they hadn't 'fucked up' their whole life and that they were suffering and did what they could to heal that suffering. I also advised someone worried about a partner's transition that there's not much you can say to dissuade someone who is already convinced they are trans, and that pushing will only result in resentment. When someone described debating themselves every time they took estrogen, I said that's a good sign they should stop, since from their post it didn't sound like it helped them. I'm learning to accept life with dysphoria rather than eliminate it. I tell myself, 'I'm not the same person that I was yesterday' — we are a culmination of our experiences, and how we let those experiences shape us is up to us.