Tutte le storie

Anni da donna trans, poi allontanarsi dalla città natale

Maschio · Desistito/a819
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono un uomo detransizionato (desistito) che per anni si è identificato come donna trans ma non ha mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi, e sono desistito circa un anno e tre mesi prima di gennaio 2025 dopo essermi allontanato dalla mia città natale e dai coetanei trans. Ora vivo come uomo, sono in una relazione felice con una ragazza che spero di sposare, mi sono convertito al cristianesimo ortodosso e ho ricostruito i rapporti con la mia famiglia, soprattutto con mio padre. Attribuisco la spinta alla transizione alla retorica misandrica, all'autismo, all'esclusione sociale, alla paura della pubertà e della sessualità maschili e a una comunità trans online/di persona controllante. La mia disforia si è in gran parte dissolta quando ho smesso di ossessionarmi sul genere, anche se quando sono giù ho ancora impulsi intrusivi di fare la transizione (e, di rado, pensieri suicidi), che inquadro come lutto e fantasia di fuga. Sono critico verso la transizione per gli altri e faccio un sostegno informale tra pari nella comunità detrans.

Storia completa

I desisted about a year and three months ago, and I'm only now starting to realize how much damage the trans identity — and frankly the weird level of cultiness around it — did to me and to my relationships. I never even medicalized, but the social and psychological damage was still wild. I'm still coming to terms with it, but thank God I desisted, because I could have lost my relationship with my father, who means everything to me, and I never would have met the girl I hope to marry. Life is so much better on the other side. I'm a male desister — an MTFTM desister, as I've described myself — meaning I identified as a trans woman but never took cross-sex hormones or had surgery. I came out and socially transitioned to a degree, but I thankfully never passed and never medically transitioned. I fully desisted only after I got away from my hometown and my trans peers. One of the big drives toward transition for me was misandrist rhetoric that left no room for positive male behavior, plus a lack of positive role models for what healthy masculinity looked like. I was constantly being told that men were oppressors and sex pests, and I transitioned in part because I didn't want to see myself as that — I wanted to be a good person, not a rapist. I also felt awful about suddenly having what I experienced as the power of violence, especially hearing messaging about men being inherently violent and abusive and seeing that to a small extent in my own family. I think transition and redpill ideology are two sides of the same coin, both a psychological reaction to misandric narratives. Male adolescence scared me. I remember being 14 and seeing how hairy my legs had gotten and thinking 'absolutely not' and trying to shave them. I remember reading that 'estrogen will kill my sex drive' and thinking 'perfect!' When I was 13, I had a crush on a girl who left our conversation to join a braid train, and I remember looking at the pretty, thin, blond, socially competent girl whose hair she was braiding and thinking 'why can't I be Emily! I wish I was Emily!' I'm autistic, socially awkward, and more feminine-leaning, and I think a certain type of autistic, awkward, sensitive young man can end up internalizing the object of his sexual desire — a kind of AGP to avoid the world — because if he were a man with male sexuality, he would be evil, and also girls are scary. 'So I'm going to become the girlfriend.' Modern pornography made this worse. I also think a big part of gender dysphoria is trying to avoid adulthood; I see parallels between GD and anorexia in that both are trying to avoid growing up. I was always someone who had more female friends than male, who was 'the safe male' but never really included, and that feeling of not really being included was a big part of my drive to transition. The trans community I was in was controlling. My online community couldn't control what I was doing behaviorally, but my in-person trans 'community' was super controlling, particularly about what I could say out loud, with decently large pressure to present 'queer.' There was big social status among my trans peers for being one of the 'lucky' ones to get on E or T, which was a behavioral pressure. Dissenters were almost completely crushed — it was not acceptable to say you liked Blaire White, my community ostracized me for failing to use it/it/its pronouns, and I was heavily discouraged from listening to my family, my church, and gender-critical sources, which were outright anathema, as was anything short of full gender philosophy. There was a sense of feeling chosen or special, guilt manipulation for daring to question anyone's self-ID, and emotion-blocking techniques like 'internalized transphobia.' What moved me toward desistance: I realized the belief system was incoherent, and I found a real community of people kind and wise enough to tell me the truth instead of letting me continue to self-destruct and burn all my relationships to the ground. Being trans is a horrible, self-obsessive way to live — you're constantly obsessing over your own identity, what kind of trans you are, how much 'transphobes' hate you, what you need to do next. I ultimately realized the fantasy (and it is a beautiful fantasy — who wouldn't want to be a beautiful woman!) is not worth it and wasn't going to make me happy because it was absurd. I went through a long phase where I realized the thing I wanted — to be a real girl — was impossible, but I still desperately wanted to be one. Then I learned to let go and turned myself around. Before, I was a recluse who hated himself and everyone around him. A piece of advice I heard from my dad and then from an Eastern Orthodox priest who escaped the mafia has drastically changed my life: 'You are not your thoughts, you are not your feelings. You are what you give your life to.' Most thoughts and feelings come from outside, not from you; you don't have to listen to them. This isn't repression — you just see the thought and decide 'eh, I don't want to.' My dad also taught me this, having learned it from a Benedictine nun. I also read 'Thoughts Matter' by a Catholic nun named Meg Funk, which helped me get out of my own doom loop of stressing over features and making it worse. After desisting I engaged in real community — in my case a church — and converted to Orthodox Christianity. I love our theology of sex and gender. Suffering is framed as necessary for salvation and growing closer to God. I've found that true masculinity is defined by serving others and sacrifice; what both the manosphere and misandrists call masculinity is actually a lack of masculinity. Real masculinity is turned outward — sacrificing oneself for others — while fake masculinity is turned inward, about getting what you want. Jesus is the model: aggressive toward those who hurt the weak, gentle to those who need him, living his life for others. Falling in love with a very feminine girl also helped me — she's awesome, has helped me through so much of this, and made me realize that men and women complement each other in healthy relationships. Now I have an active community, a beautiful girlfriend (Orthodox, though we aren't engaged yet — 'we're getting there'), I babysit little kids, I volunteer, and I go to the gym. I'm back to being my parents' kid, and I get to be an older brother to my little brother, a son to my mother. My mom needs a strong son to open pickle jars, my brother needs a male role model, my girlfriend needs a man to stand up for her. I've discovered deep, emotionally intimate male friendship, which is much more fun than the niceties people gave me before. I love my muscles and square face now. I'm still not a huge fan of my facial and body hair, but I don't hate it as much as when I was obsessing about it. My dysphoria almost completely cleared up once I was no longer obsessing about my gender. Family: my mother yelled at me and hit me when I came out and continued to verbally attack me, which drove me deeper in. My dad, by contrast, talked with me late into the night about what I was interested in, hugged me all the time, made me chocolate shakes, and was an awesome dad. I could have lost my relationship with him had I continued. Mental health and ongoing struggles: I still have intrusive thoughts — the urge to transition returns whenever I feel down, even though I'm normally happy, in a happy relationship, and studying what I love. I described that urge as an escape fantasy: 'I don't like my life at that moment, so the urge to use the maladaptive coping mechanism comes back.' On 2025-03-12 I told another poster that I have these thoughts too — both to just try transition or to kill myself — and that they hurt really, really bad sometimes. I really want to be a girl even though I know it's an impossible desire and transitioning wouldn't make me happy. I framed this as grief. I'm tired of being constantly reminded of the worst years of my life. Sexuality: I wanted a girlfriend, real relationships, and community — that was a core reason I desisted. I'm straight; I now have a girlfriend I hope to marry. Attitudes toward transition for others: I'm critical. I think gender identity is an unfalsifiable, immaterial concept — the whole thing is a religious belief, like Once Saved Always Saved Evangelicals or Calvinists who leave their group. I don't think pumping our bodies full of the wrong hormones will fix problems with our minds, saying that for myself as much as for others. I've told people that 'just get a mastectomy' is crazy — our bodies aren't meat legos; we are our bodies, and we belong to a whole lot of other people. I've advocated for the sub to remain a space for detransitioners and desisters rather than a political football, and I've asked conservative/gender-critical lurkers not to engage. I've also noted there's a difference between not recognizing someone's self-declared identity and hating trans people. I've done informal peer support in the community, offering to talk and DM people who are struggling. I regret the years lost to the trans identity, the relationships I nearly burned to the ground, and the near-miss of losing my father. I did not medically transition, so I have no surgical or hormonal regrets. The regret I do feel is easing over time as my life has improved dramatically on the other side.