Tutte le storie

Scrivere di medicina della transizione senza una propria cronologia

Femmina · Detransizionato/a341
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna che ha fatto detransizione, anche se in questi post non ho scritto della mia cronologia di transizione. Quello che ho condiviso è un punto di vista costantemente critico sulla medicina della transizione: credo che i bambini non dovrebbero mai prendere queste decisioni, che il movimento si regga su un dogma di gruppo, che il seno e le funzioni del corpo non siano solo estetica e che alcune identità trans siano guidate dal feticismo. Do valore alle persone che hanno desistito come prova dei danni del transgenderismo e considero l'etichetta «intersex» usata in modo improprio per legittimare il transgenderismo. In questo materiale non ho riferito ideazione suicidaria o autolesionismo.

Storia completa

I was born female, and my own transition history is not something I have written about in these posts and comments — what I have shared publicly is my thinking about transition, sex, and the politics around them. I came to r/detrans in April 2024 and began by commenting on other people's situations. When someone described a young person's transition decision, I said that "these decisions should never be made by a child." I have been blunt about what I think is driving the broader phenomenon: I described it as "simply dogma" that "isn't meant to make sense," arguing it works through social psychology — testing how much contradiction group members will follow so they are less likely to deviate later — and I said there are "a lot of mad scientists and psychopaths behind this movement." I have also engaged with the medical and sexual side. When someone raised sexual dysfunction, I suggested that less masturbation was the only thing on offer if hormones were not the cause, allowed that it could be psychological but "could very well be the hormones," and urged seeing a mental health professional "one that is not going to lie to you, that may also be challenging." On dating, I advised being upfront early so women who would object can say no, saving time for both sides. In April 2024 I made my own post, titled "Textbook AGP?" with the body "I would say so," which drew no support (score 0). I pushed back elsewhere on the use of "Incel" as a catch-all insult, arguing most incels are "just sexually frustrated males with no direction" and that characterizing them that way opens the door to red pill culture. My views on transition medicine are critical. I objected to the framing of breasts as merely aesthetic, saying anyone who understands "basic human anatomy and hormones" knows breasts "have more important tasks that regulate the female body," and I criticized the treatment of avatars and online gaming as making people see bodies as aesthetic pieces. I argued that trans women "fetishize" the biological experiences of womanhood for affirmation, when those experiences are bodily functions rather than affirmation, and I said the same applies to SRS — "it's not just a piece you put on." On intersex conditions I wrote that "indeterminate sexual development" is a statistical anomaly, roughly 0.001 of the intersex population, that I hate the label because it paints an inaccurate picture and is "used to legitimize transgenderism at the basis of sex." I have been supportive of desisted people as witnesses, noting they are "the concrete proof of the dangers of transgenderism" and that the right seems to be the only side willing to listen to them. I also told someone whose partner was fetishizing a transman's body that it was "purely fetishistic" and that they deserved monogamy instead. I have argued at length against the idea that society prizes masculine-conforming men, saying virtually all media calls masculinity and conformity "toxic," and I told a commenter to seek professional help. I believe the beauty of the sexes is that both are praised for their differences. I have been combative in these exchanges, telling one person "Plz seek help" and offering to DM them links, and telling another I was done replying because they were deep in "brain fart." I have not described my own dysphoria, transition, hormones, surgeries, or detransition date in this material, so those details are not part of what I have written here.