Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono una donna che ha desistito/fatto detransition: dai 16 anni circa e per due anni mi sono identificata come ragazzo, usando i pronomi they/them, un binder e un packer, ma non ho mai preso ormoni né fatto interventi. La mia disforia era radicata nella misoginia dell'adolescenza, nella sessualizzazione da parte di insegnanti e nella scoperta di essere lesbica. Alla fine dei vent'anni sto bene nel mio corpo, esprimo la mascolinità attraverso lo stile e mi comprendo come donna politicamente ma non binaria/genderqueer dentro di me. Sono contenta di non aver mai fatto una transizione medica e sono critica verso le pressioni, sociali o mediche, che spingono chi si interroga sul genere verso la transizione. La mia salute mentale e l'immagine corporea sono migliorate molto grazie alla comunità, all'allenamento con i pesi, alla neutralità corporea e al reinquadrare i tratti del corpo legati al genere come neutri.
Storia completa
I was a gender-nonconforming kid who didn't pay much attention to my body or gender until around age 11. Most of my friends were boys, and I had a string of girl 'best friends' who I now realize were probably proto-crushes. I had no notable trauma in early life. When I entered middle school, I began experiencing more misogyny in daily life and saw ugly examples of it online. I developed fast and my school had a strict dress code; teachers commented on my 12-year-old body as a sexual object and shamed me for 'distracting boys.' I was also struggling with the realization that I was queer — I hadn't known lesbianism was possible as a young child. I imagined myself as male in many of my romantic fantasies. I started to hate my body and girlhood around that time because it was literally the source of most of my problems. I'm not sure I'd call it dysphoria, but I probably would have been diagnosed with it if I'd seen a specialist. The harassment, threats, and degradation I experienced daily made my depression feel like a straightforward reaction rather than a mental health problem per se.
In high school, my dysphoria continued to get worse. I had a small group of trans and queer friends, and we were reading actual gender theory rather than absorbing simplified ideas from social media. Around age 16 I started using they/them pronouns with friends, dressed masculine, and got a binder and packer. All of this felt good and helped with the dysphoria. I wanted top surgery and testosterone, but concluded it was best to wait until I was 21 and financially independent, since my parents weren't at all supportive. I identified as a guy for about two years.
I never started hormones or blockers. Now, in my late twenties, my dysphoria bothers me far less than it used to. I'm really glad I didn't medically transition when I was younger and have no plans to in the future. I'm much more comfortable with my chest, genitals, and body in general — I express masculinity through clothes, haircut, and mannerisms, but that's it. I can look at myself naked in the mirror and like what I see, and I've been in several healthy relationships.
My understanding of gender has helped enormously. I think of gender as the culture surrounding sex — a social construct, but a real one. I think gender identity is determined by a mix of biological, sociological, and psychological factors. When my parents use she/her for me, they're mostly saying 'we know you're a person with a vagina/uterus.' When I speak out for feminist causes, it's because I'm politically aligned with womanhood — my life is altered by being perceived as a woman. Socially and spiritually I identify as nonbinary; I often 'feel like a man' and enjoy embodying traditionally male gender roles, and I sometimes pass as man in public. I used to ID as nonbinary or transmasculine only, and for a while identified as a trans man, but I never felt 100% about taking testosterone and couldn't relate to cis men in my life — I wanted to stay in community with women. I realized I didn't have to feel like a woman in order to be one. I now understand myself as a woman in a political sense, but my spiritual/internal sense of self is masculine — I'd consider this a form of nonbinary or genderqueer identity, but I don't ID as cis or trans. Reading Stone Butch Blues really helped me, as has learning about transmasculine/butch history.
I think a lot of my progress came from finding a healthy in-person community — I couldn't have done it alone. I also learned about the body neutrality movement, which helped me take a more neutral view of my body rather than chasing self-love as 'perfect.' I strength train and think of it as gender-neutral, celebrating functional progress. I've reframed features like curves, body fat in hips and chest, and broad shoulders as neutral body parts rather than gendered ones. I've also recognized that identifying as nonbinary didn't stop people from treating me like a woman, so the work I do to combat misogyny has to be external — I'd feel dysphoria if perceived as a man.
I've never been on hormones or blockers. I have a curvy figure with a lot of body fat in chest and hips, but I work out for big shoulders, wear loose straight-cut clothes, and look basically like a burly little dude in public. I'm not hiding my figure, just presenting it differently.
On Reddit I've given advice to young people questioning transition, urging them to work on mental health first, try CBT, sleep 8.5 hours, exercise, spend time with friends, and get away from incel communities. I've argued against the idea that transition is obviously the right choice for anyone with gender issues and said it bothers me when people try to tell others they're trans; I know a few detransitioners who transitioned due to social pressure. I've pushed back hard on conspiracy theories linking trans healthcare to eugenicist or Nazi plots, calling the logic shockingly weak. I've also counseled someone considering detransition to treat it as a 'second transition' — experiment first, try binding or different clothes at home, try he/him with close friends in private. I've recommended ERP techniques, reading about Body Dysmorphic Disorder, somatic therapy, and EMDR for trauma-related genital distress. I have a girlfriend who is trans and a friend group that's about 60% trans women.