Tutte le storie

Sette anni di disforia svaniti senza una sola dose

Femmina · Desistito/aPrima disforia 8 → Desistenza 261,4K
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna desistita, nata femmina, che si è identificata come trans e ha fatto la transizione sociale per circa 8 anni (all'incirca dai 19 ai 26/27 anni) senza mai prendere ormoni né fare interventi, per paura degli aghi e della chirurgia e per il desiderio di preservare la fertilità. Ho sentito per la prima volta di essere nel corpo sbagliato a 8 anni, nel 2000, ho scoperto la transizione a 19 anni tramite YouTube nel 2012 e a 26-27 anni ho deciso di non farla; dopo di che la mia grave disforia durata 7 anni è in gran parte scomparsa quando ho riconosciuto che era radicata nelle norme sociali, nella misoginia interiorizzata e nell'omofobia più che nel mio corpo fisico. Oggi mi considero una donna gay mascolina e cristiana, a volte penso ancora «sono trans» secondo certe definizioni, e sono contenta di aver evitato la transizione medica soprattutto perché voglio dei figli e non voglio interventi né ormoni a vita. Ho l'HOCD e una misoginia interiorizzata su cui lavoro attivamente, e ho avuto un brutto infortunio alla caviglia, ma la mia salute mentale e la mia qualità di vita sono migliorate da quando ho desistito. Credo che la transizione possa essere giusta per una piccola percentuale di adulti con disforia grave a esordio infantile dopo un'approfondita consulenza, ma che la maggior parte di chi la fa non dovrebbe, che i minori non dovrebbero prendere decisioni per la vita e che tutti dovrebbero essere informati sui tassi di detransizione e sulle complicazioni.

Storia completa

I was born female and first thought I was in the wrong body around age 8, in 2000, when I was told repeatedly that girls couldn't play sports, take shop or automotive classes, drive, or do the things the boys did. I was a tomboy with a bowl cut who wanted to be called Henry and wore boys' clothing, and in the 1990s everyone just laughed it off — there was no gender-affirming care then, and when I went to counseling they just prayed for me and told me I needed to change or I would go to hell. My mom laughed when I first said it and told me that once I was an adult I could wear men's clothing, so I secretly wore boys' clothing I got from friends. I didn't even know what trans was until I was 19, in college around 2012, when I found it on YouTube — all these shy girls blossoming into handsome, popular young men, and I wanted to become that. I socially transitioned from about 19 onward: I wore men's clothing, drew on a beard when alone, and wore a packer, and I self-injured female body parts. I identified as trans for about 8 years total. I never started hormones because of a severe fear of needles and surgery — the thought of giving myself a shot every month for the rest of my life caused panic attacks — and because I didn't know at the time that testosterone could be taken in gel form. I mentioned dysphoria to a counselor in 2013 but nothing came of it and I didn't push harder. I had both physical dysphoria (hating my genitals, wanting larger muscles and abs, and having very small, tuberous A-cup breasts that meant kids at school called me a boy) and social dysphoria (hating being known as a "female athlete," wanting to be strong and a leader). I also had pretty severe genital dysphoria and at one point really pushed for genital surgery. What drove me toward transition was wanting to be good at sports, to lift heavier — after years of lifting I could only manage around 30 lbs on upper body — to be dominant and taken seriously in the workforce, and to date women without people thinking anything of it. Being trans also felt like an easy cop-out for my attraction to women and my insecurity issues. I thought I was just wired wrong and meant to be a boy. Social media had a big impact: I saw before-and-after timeline videos where sad, overweight people became fit and happy, and I only ever saw the attractive, Justin-Bieber-esque trans guys on YouTube, so I thought testosterone only lowered your voice and added a bit of toning. A few years later I found the "dark side of YouTube" with videos of horrible side effects of long-term testosterone on the female body — overweight, hairy, balding guys with complications and regrets — and that was a stark contrast. Then I read something about how you likely won't look like Justin Bieber but instead your uncle. I realized I only wanted to be a very specific type of man: athletic, good-looking, popular, a ladies' man — not a hairy, balding guy who stayed home with no friends. I decided at 26, in 2018, that I was not going to transition, and firmly at 27. A few days after my cousin's wedding in 2019 I wore a dress and the whole shebang — literally my worst nightmare, and I almost didn't go — and nothing bad happened. No one told me I looked bad, no creepy guys hit on me, I didn't feel lesser for being seen as a woman. That's when I realized transitioning was a lot of work for a small chance of a better life. Shortly after that, at 26 or 27, I realized I wanted to have a baby, which became one of the main reasons I'm glad I never transitioned. My dysphoria, which had been severe for 7 years, pretty much disappeared overnight once I realized I wasn't actually a man. I came to understand that my dysphoria was almost entirely cultural and social rather than physical: I never felt it sitting on the couch, working at my desk, or taking a bath — only in direct response to being told I couldn't do something, being compared to feminine women, or reading something. Once I realized all of my dysphoria stemmed from social norms, I stopped hating myself physically, because it wasn't fair to my body to keep being harmed because someone decided I wasn't supposed to wear basketball shorts. Gender-critical content partly helped me decide not to transition, because it taught me that the only qualification to be a woman is being an adult human female, and it didn't matter that I didn't like pink. I don't label myself a radfem or any type of feminist because I don't hate men, but some radfem content has helped with my internalized misogyny, which I still struggle with most days and actively work to overcome. I stopped identifying as a boy and started embracing being a masculine gay woman in my late 20s. I consider myself a desister rather than a detransitioner since I never medically transitioned, though I fit most definitions of trans and I still think "I'm trans" in some sense because I like men's clothing and stereotypical activities better. I just no longer think there's an issue with how my brain and body are mapped — the issue is with how society perceives masculine and feminine things. I'm a desisted woman, a Christian, and pretty much a lesbian or at least 99-to-1 bisexual. I've had HOCD (straight OCD) all the time, which makes dating hard — I'd be going out with a woman and suddenly can't stop thinking I have to be with a man — and part of the treatment is not acting on the thoughts, so I was single for years. I never had TOCD; when I identified as trans I was 100% sure of it with no doubts. I've never been autistic. I had a bad ankle injury in 2020 that forced me to shift from being a dumb jock to an artist and completely rewire my friend groups. I played hockey for 18 years plus softball at youth, high school, and adult rec levels. I'm 28 as of early 2021, so I was born around 1992-1993. I've never had sex and have been led on by 6+ relationships with people who weren't attracted to me. I've tried to date, getting only 1-2 matches per month from women versus 200+ messages from men, and I started matching with men just to get out there and stop having panic attacks on dates, but the quality was much lower. I'm now dating a great woman. My softball team told me I'm single because I'm not masculine enough — I look like the more masculine partner but have feminine mannerisms. One of the main reasons I considered transitioning was thinking I could get more dates as a trans guy, but I realized I didn't want a male body for the other 99% of my life. I've mostly dated straight women who were not into me physically, which caused real damage. I still prefer men's clothing and wear it daily, but I now wear women's clothing at work without it bothering me, and I have long hair now so I'm hardly ever mistaken as trans. I still have internalized misogyny I work on daily, and I watch shows with female leads and read literature with strong female characters to help. I'm glad I never transitioned because of fertility, health, and the fact that I don't want surgeries or lifetime hormones. I don't regret not transitioning; I'm glad I avoided the medical risks. I think transition is right for some adults with severe, childhood-onset dysphoria and no untreated mental health conditions, after thorough counseling, but that most people who transition shouldn't, that it should be a last resort, that under-18s shouldn't make lifelong decisions like that, that there should be a minimum counseling requirement before hormones, and that everyone should be advised of detransition rates and possible complications. I don't think trans people are bad and I don't consider myself a TERF, but I don't support TRAs and I think the trans narrative can be harmful. I've spoken up about desister voices needing to be heard and pushed back when I was told I'd be banned for posting as a desister rather than a detransitioner.