Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.
Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.
A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.
Riassunto
Sono un uomo gay che ha fatto detransition/desistenza: non ho mai fatto una transizione medica, ma ho passato circa due anni ossessionato dal dubbio di essere transgender dopo un'esperienza scatenante a 17 anni, e oggi mi identifico serenamente come gay effeminato. La mia ansia di genere è iniziata nel 2014 e si è risolta con l'università, l'allenamento e l'approccio scettico dei miei genitori; nel momento peggiore ho avuto una certa ideazione suicidaria, ma ora sono felice e non temo più di ricadere in quegli schemi. Rimpiango gli anni persi nella confusione ossessiva, non certo cambiamenti medici, dato che non ne ho avuti. Ho una visione critica ma sfumata della transizione: non credo nell'identità di genere innata, ma accetto che alcune persone traggano davvero beneficio dalla transizione, sostenendo che il modello affermativo fallisce con chi non è adatto. Sono attivo nelle community detrans, discuto le teorie AGP/HSTS, il calo delle barriere alla transizione e incoraggio chi ha dubbi.
Storia completa
I am a gay man who was born male and have always identified as gay. I came out of the closet at 12 (in one account) or 13 (in another) to my mom, who asked me 'are you sure you don't want to be a girl' or 'do you want to be a girl?' — I said no, though I remember feeling weird about the question. I lived comfortably as an effeminate gay boy for the next four or five years with no real thoughts about gender.
Then, at 17, everything changed in an instant. I was in bed one night on 4chan (which had recently introduced an /lgbt/ page) listening to the Hedwig and the Angry Inch soundtrack — a musical about a gay man who is forced/tricked into a sex change operation — and it was like a switch flipped or a lightning strike. Suddenly I started wondering if I was transgender. The next morning 'Am I transgender?' was the first thought in my head, and it stayed that way for a couple of years. A pit developed in my stomach that never went away.
For the next two years I obsessed constantly. I would scour my personal history for transgender signs, wondering if I had been lying to my mom when I said I didn't want to be a girl. I would 'test' myself — imagining myself doing things as a girl versus a boy, imagining myself in a music video as a man versus a woman, monitoring my physiological response, asking myself the 'push a button' question. I tried masturbating to trans porn to see if it would 'unlock' some secret desire, which it never did. I introspected constantly about whether I wanted a vagina. I would blink and the whole day had passed thinking about this. I cried into my pillow because I was so confused — I reasoned 'only trans people spend loads of time wondering what gender they are,' but it never clicked into place the way discovering I was gay had.
Eventually I 'came out' to my family as trans. They all doubted it was true; my mom more-or-less said 'okay, but I don't think you are transgender.' I treated this as another test — I thought if I told enough people I was trans I would finally believe it and could move on, but I never could accept it. My mom introduced me to a Tumblr blog on 'Pure OCD,' which finally seemed like an explanation that fit me perfectly. It didn't immediately solve the problem. I still wandered around in the dead of night, and I recall that it was around this time I started having some suicidal ideation.
The problem eventually started to solve itself. First, I left my small home town for University and my life became fuller and more satisfying, and my anxieties melted away. Second, I started going to the gym and working out, which gave me a new connection to my body and identity. As soon as I felt proud of myself as a man, the problem became redundant — I had a clear vision of myself I never had before, and the dissatisfaction and uncertainty disappeared. I also credit my parents' sceptical approach: 'in my view my parents taking a sceptical approach saved me from making a mistake.'
I never medically transitioned — no hormones, no surgery, no puberty blockers. I experienced what I later described as 'phantom limb feelings' that I thought were symptoms of gender dysphoria, but they didn't last. It has now been nearly 10 years since that period (my gender anxiety began in 2014), and for the last few years I've been brave enough to frequent r/detrans without fearing I'll fall back into old patterns of anxiety. I couldn't be happier with my gender identity now — it isn't even a question for me. I'm an effeminate gay man and that suits me fine.
I now hold a critical but nuanced view of transition. I think gender is not really a spectrum but has two fixed poles, and I don't believe in an innate 'gender identity' buried within us separate from biological sex. I think gender roles are generally a good thing that give shape to people's lives, while also believing GNC people should be free to present how they want without prejudice. I've argued that some people genuinely do seem to benefit from transition (I cite Amanda Lepore as someone I can't imagine being happy as a man), but that the gender-affirmative model has a huge hole in it because it doesn't account for people who aren't suited to transition. I've advocated that the sub should allow arguing that some people might benefit from transition, and I've pushed back against the idea that everyone who detransitions deliberately misled doctors.
I've been active in discussing AGP/HSTS typology, J. Michael Bailey's 'The Man Who Would Be Queen,' and Blanchard's theories, and I've discussed how I think the threshold for transition has dropped dramatically over the years. I've also been banned from other subs for my views. Sexually, I identify as a gay man and have a boyfriend — I've described holding hands with him in Washington DC and being slapped in the back of the head in a homophobic attack, whereas in England I've experienced little abuse despite wearing women's clothes when clubbing.
Overall my regret is not about medical changes (I had none) but about the years lost to obsessive anxiety and confusion. That regret has largely resolved — I'm now happy, and I spend time encouraging others who are in the position I was in, telling them it isn't permanent and that they'll be okay.