Tutte le storie

Mai stata trans, ma scrive comunque negli spazi detrans

Femmina · Desistito/a77
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna bisessuale di 30 anni che non è mai stata trans, anche se ho avuto qualche mese di sentimenti genderfluid durante un periodo depressivo. Scrivo spesso negli spazi sulla detransizione, consigliando di sospendere gli ormoni gradualmente, di vedere la transizione come ultima risorsa e di guardare alle sue conseguenze invece che solo al suo fascino. Attribuisco molto del disagio di genere a pornografia, patriarcato, pillola anticoncezionale e stress, e raccomando la terapia per derealizzazione e depersonalizzazione durante la detransizione. Parlo apertamente del mio corpo, tra cui una piccola cicatrice alle labbra e un naso rotto, e della mia sessualità, compreso essermi innamorata di una donna trans dopo anni di identificazione come lesbica. Resto solidale con chi ha fatto la detransizione, mettendolo però in guardia dal negare la realtà delle persone trans con discorsi d'odio.

Storia completa

I was born female, and I have never identified as trans — I say plainly that I am not trans myself. What I did go through was a few months of some "genderfluid idea" during a depressive period, which I describe as not the same thing as being trans at all. I'm about 30 years old as of May 2020, and I'm bisexual: for many years I thought of myself as "so lesbian," and only later realized I had fallen in love with a man — specifically a trans woman, whose body I knew well even with hormones and surgery, and whom I understood to have grown up and been socialized male. That realization is how I understood myself to be bi. Most of what I post is advice and argument aimed at other people in the detransition and gender-questioning space, but threaded through it are my own experiences. I talk about my body directly: I say "we the females generate testosterone too," and I introduce myself in one thread as "i'm an AFab." I describe having seen a lot of vaginas and vulvas in real life, all different. I mention a small accident years ago — a little cut to one labia that healed well but still feels different and sensitive in that zone, and that has "marked me forever." I also have a broken nose, broken years ago, which I'd happily have rhinoplasty on for breathing and aesthetics, though never a size reduction because I like it big, just not the hook shape. I have strong views about how women's bodies are treated culturally. I trace high heels back to menswear, note that jewelry was for both sexes in ancient cultures, and argue that recent history changed this because women weren't allowed to have bank accounts, so jewelry became emergency money in case a husband died. I tell a poster worried about thick eyebrows to use a toothbrush for direction, comparing them to Cara Delevingne's. I push back hard on porn-influenced self-perception: I tell people to stop watching porn, not for moral reasons but because I believe it causes neuronal damage and makes pleasure harder, and I urge them not to go back to it. I also attribute a poster's distress about her labia to the "roast beef vagina" memes and to a birth-control pill that "absolutely destroyed" her emotional state, suggesting she come off it. I'm direct and sometimes crude in giving sexual advice — recommending strapons, condoms, lube, harnesses, and starting with stimulation rather than penetration if a partner isn't into it. I argue that women can orgasm anally and that a lot of men need training to be multiorgasmic while "we who born females have that by default." I'm critical of what I see as unrealistic scripts: heteronormativity, the "rough man submissive woman" code, and the idea that a delicate man must be with men or get surgery to be with a woman "healthy." I say girls like me exist and like those guys in a healthy way. On transition itself, I take a skeptical, last-resort position. I tell people to look at the consequences of transitioning, not just the beauty, and that transition is understood as a last resort for extreme cases of dysphoria, not a first option. I warn a trans-identified person that males will never fully accept them as men — they may accept pronouns, but not access to power or real socialization — and that the real problem is the patriarchy, not being female. I question why nonbinary people get top surgery immediately while trans dysphoric people need six months of duration to be considered real. I also ask whether a poster's distress might be menopause-like symptoms, framing finishing detransition as arriving at menopause and calling it beautiful. I suggest derealization and depersonalization are coping mechanisms for the stress of detransition and advise getting help for that stress. I encourage people coming off hormones to do it gradually, since the body needs hormones to function, and to get testosterone from friends if they've had surgery. I reassure people that their trans friends won't hate them unless they start denying their reality with hate speech, which some detransitioners do at first. I've also speculated about causes: I ask whether someone's dysphoria originated in the insula, and I suggest one person's preference might just be an evolved ape's taste for aesthetic and symmetry, with gay men usually more aesthetic, and that a woman who doesn't like skirts is simply researching another aesthetic to be more "peacock" herself. I've told someone who said they didn't care about others' opinions to just start treating themselves with male stuff without transitioning — "start doing with yourself what you would do if you were born male" — and that if they really need to transition first, they aren't being sincere about not caring. Currently I'm a 30-year-old bisexual woman who has never transitioned, with only a brief genderfluid period during depression behind me.