Tutte le storie

Difende i detransitioner online dal 2019

Femmina · Detransizionato/a60
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una persona che ha fatto detransition, vive in Nuova Zelanda ed è attiva su r/detrans dal 2019, difendendo il diritto dei detransitioner di parlare del danno che hanno subito e criticando la glorificazione della terapia ormonale come soluzione ai problemi della vita. Io stessa ho smesso gli ormoni e descrivo l'esperienza come aver imparato «a caro prezzo» che la transizione non faceva per me, anche se da allora mi sono «ritrovata». Sono critica verso certe comunità trans online, in particolare verso quella che vedo come pressione sugli adolescenti che si interrogano, e per questo sto lontana dagli spazi online MtF e da Twitter. Sostengo chi sta facendo detransition e mi oppongo alle molestie contro chi posta come detrans. La mia identità attuale è quella di persona che ha fatto detransition e non mi identifico come cisgender.

Storia completa

I have been active in the r/detrans community since at least September 2019, and my comments make clear that I speak as someone with direct experience of transition and detransition. In a September 24, 2019 exchange I pushed back hard against an outsider who referred to people here as "people who thought they were trans," writing: "many people on this sub were trans, they spent years on hormones, had surgeries and spent years id'ing, that is trans." I defended the right of detransitioners to vent about "the ideology that hurt them" after being "mistreated by doctors," and I noted that "a lot of people here dont id as cis," so labeling them cisgender was itself a misstep. I also acknowledged that detransition is not always negative — some people have a smooth transition and a smooth detransition — and suggested that much of what outsiders call transphobic is really people being "critical (rightfully)" about negatives that happen during transition, including recent articles being posted. I did not lay out my own full medical timeline in these comments, so I cannot give exact ages, dates of hormones, or surgeries for myself. What is clear is that I went through a transition, later stopped hormones, and identify as detransitioned. On September 25, 2019 I advised someone else who was proud of their hair that there was no need to pursue further changes: "I think stopping hrt is already a big step so mabye just leave it at that for now to see if this is right for you." That framing — stopping HRT as a significant, sufficient step — reflects how I approached my own process: cautious, incremental, and skeptical of rushing. I have been supportive of others going through the same thing. On September 26, 2019 I consoled someone whose friend had turned away from them for trying to do what was best for themselves, saying "thats no fair a friend would turn away." The same day I called out a commenter who was harassing detrans posters, especially positive ones, and calling detransitioners sex workers: "youre being cruel stop spreading your hate on all these detrans posts esp the positive ones." By November 25, 2019 I was reflecting more openly on what had drawn me in and what I had learned. I told another user, "i do think HRT is really glamorized nowadays as something to fix every life problem when its not. You thought you were doing the right thing for you and i'm sorry you had to learn in a harsh way that it really wasn't but at least you found yourself again now." That sentiment — that I believed I was doing the right thing at the time, only to learn harshly that I was wrong, but that I have now "found myself again" — is the core of my own story as I tell it to others. I also expressed regret on behalf of someone who felt they had wasted time, telling them "you're still young" and that the painful experience could eventually be looked back on as "some kinda positive note, a self discovery." On the same day I explained why I distance myself from certain online spaces: "This is one of the reasons i stay away from MtF cycles nowadays, but even on twitter its hard to avoid. like i know not all of them are like that but the amount i see like this is alarming and then there's some trying to push it on teens even who are only questioning." I chose not to elaborate further, saying "i could get more into this without being vague and put more depth into it but nah." I am based in New Zealand, and I noted that in NZ the term "egg" is "used as an insult a lot so idk i just laugh whenever i see the 'SUCH AN EGG UWU' bs online." Overall my stance is that detransitioners deserve to have "their voices and pain heard," that critical discussion of transition's negatives is legitimate, and that people who are uncomfortable with that should leave the subreddit rather than silence others. I am supportive of people exploring whether transition is right for them, cautious about HRT being oversold as a cure-all, and critical of the online culture — particularly around MtF communities and the pushing of transition ideas onto questioning teens — that I feel contributed to harm.