Tutte le storie

Maschiaccio, set porno e anni a «queerizzare il genere»

Femmina · Detransizionato/a106
Queste storie sono state riassunte usando l'IA.

Su Reddit, le persone spesso condividono le loro esperienze attraverso più commenti o post. Per rendere queste informazioni più accessibili, detrans.ai raccoglie tutti quei pezzi sparsi in un singolo riassunto facile da leggere e una cronologia. Tutti i prompt di sistema sono indicati nella pagina dei prompt.

A volte l'IA può allucinare o affermare cose che non sono vere. Ma generalmente, le storie riassunte sono riflessioni accurate dei commenti originali degli utenti.

Riassunto

Sono una donna lesbica butch che ha fatto detransition/desistito, che ha passato anni a «queerizzare il genere» prima di capire che il genere è solo stereotipi e performance mentre il sesso e il sessismo sono reali. Ero un maschiaccio che si sentiva estraneo ai ruoli prescritti alle ragazze, ho lavorato nell'industria del porno e sono arrivata a vedere sia la cultura trans sia quella del porno come sette che mi hanno fatto abbandonare i miei valori fondamentali. Ora mi batto pubblicamente, parlando in dibattiti, alle riunioni dei consigli scolastici e davanti al Congresso, per il pensiero critico sul genere, anche se credo di aver perso un lavoro progressista per aver fatto coming out come persona che ha desistito. Ho avuto un padre alcolista che ha abbandonato la mia famiglia e un'ex fidanzata violenta, e ho affrontato la depressione (notando che il testosterone non era una buona cura). Resto vicina nello spirito alla comunità della detransition pur credendo che le persone trans e quelle detrans non possano essere davvero amiche strette.

Storia completa

I was a tomboy from day one, always disgusted by the roles women and girls were relegated to and expected to play. For a long time that caused me to feel distant from the whole idea of "girl" or "woman," and society's constant division of people into "boys and girls" in irrelevant circumstances made me think I didn't belong with the other girls. I knew I wasn't a man, but I didn't feel like I fit with the girls either. I spent years "queering gender" and being busy "with myself in my head about wtf that even meant," and I now realize gender is nothing more than stereotypes and performances — it isn't real, but sex is, and sexism is. By hyperfocusing on my own identity, I was turning my natural revulsion of patriarchal society and female oppression inward and making it about something being wrong with me that I could fix or escape on my own. I now understand I was always fine — there was something wrong with the world. I eventually reconciled with my female body at puberty, including realizing I liked how my developing breasts felt. Once I wrapped my head around the fact that I could be a woman — because I identified deeply with women's shared experience of oppression — and still be "BUTCH AS FUUUUCK," everything made sense. It's my job to show the world that a woman can out-butch a man, not to become a man. I still sometimes feel a hint of dysphoria, but everything about that realization felt right and still does. I was a little radfem at one point. I also used to work in the porn industry, and I've said that both trans and porn culture conditioned me to ignore things that were actually deep, core values I held. It was a real headfuck trying to unpack all of that, and a years-long head trip trying to find myself again after leaving both "cults." Letting go of all the gender nonsense really did feel like leaving a cult, and I had to learn how to use all of my own brain and really think critically about a lot of things again. I now feel much more proud to simply exist as a defiant butch lesbian female than I ever felt all those years I was "defiantly queering gender." My life has been radically shaped by being female, no matter how I identify or identified my gender, and that connects me across time and space to every other female regardless of how they identify. Once I started connecting with intergenerational lesbian community and female-only spaces, to realize there were fellow rebels out there who were still women, everything started to make so much more sense. These days I put zero effort into being read one way or the other — I just do me. If it's someone I'll talk to again, I'll make it clear I'm a woman if they ask or if it comes up; otherwise it's for other people to worry about, not me. On adversity: my father became an alcoholic, started cheating on my mom, and eventually abandoned us. People told me I needed to "let go" of my anger and that "forgiveness is a gift to yourself," but it was my uncompromising rage at him that gave me clarity and enormous strength to get through that period relatively unscathed. I also broke up with an abusive ex-girlfriend, and finally talking about her and allowing myself my anger was the most healing thing in the world. I can't begrudge any female her misandry — it's a reasonable response to the trauma of patriarchy. On mental health: I've referenced depression and said "T is not the best treatment for depression, trust," implying I was on testosterone at some point for it. I've also counseled someone else through suicidal feelings, recommending the book *Radical Acceptance* by Tara Brach, which helped me through an incredibly difficult time in my life and changed the way I see the world. On community and advocacy: I've spoken on panels and at school board meetings, helped organize talks and build support spaces, and testified before congress. Being part of that push has been hugely helpful in making me feel like I'm doing something and not feeling alone. I've said there can be serious social blowback in very liberal/progressive bubbles, and I think there's a strong possibility I may have lost a very good job in a very "progressive" workplace over simply coming out about being a desister as neutrally as I could. It can make you paranoid. Once, after a school board meeting where I used my full name, someone tried to photo and doxx me, but they misidentified me in their photo as the man I was standing next to. I've also met a detransitioner at a womyn's land event who had transitioned as a kid and was detransitioning as an adult. I've collected a list of detransitioners on Twitter/X over the years. On relationships with trans people: I don't think trans and detrans people can be friends. I still technically have trans friends, but they're more acquaintances than friends, and I accept there are lots of things we'll never be able to talk about, which means we can never be close friends. It's sad but harsh reality — but if they ever start questioning things themselves, they'll know who might be safe to talk to, and I'll be there. On attitudes toward transition: I've cautioned against mindreading, called certain views "mainstream, majority opinions," and said "It's never too late to detransition" and never too late to start learning to accept yourself just the way you are now. I've noted that the majority of the recent surge in gender-dysphoric youth at clinics are natal females despite historically most referrals being natal males, following that many are seeking transition for reasons other than those historically encountered. I've also said I couldn't let myself speak or even think for a long time out of fear of the "TERF" label, calling it everyone's Get Out of Misogyny/Homophobia Free card. I've told people to just wear what they like without worrying about gendered expectations. My more right-leaning relatives gently approached me about these issues and I told them, "No, that's reasonable as hell to be concerned about!"